This past Thursday, MLB held its 2018 Rule 5 Draft – and, while Rule 5 pickups can really only be e-value-ated sometime down the road, there were a handful (that would be five – four fingers and a thumb) names I found intriguing. I’ll take a quick look at those players in this post, but spend more time reflecting on a handful (plus one) MLB Rule five Draft moves BBRT’s finds intriguing. Those include:
- The “Pirating” of arguably the best player ever taken in the Rule 5 Draft;
- A Hawaiian who didn’t start flyin’ until being exposed to the Rule 5 Draft twice;
- How the Twins turned one Rule 5 pick (who never took the mound for them) into two Cy Young Awards AND CASH;
- A Rule FIVE draftee who appeared on the roster of a record FIVE different teams (and at FIVE different positions) the season after he was drafted;
- The “catch and release” of a player who was selected in the MLB Draft five times before signing, was later exposed to the Rule 5 Draft and went on to hit 400+ home runs; and
- A Rule 5 draftee whose Face, name and arm the legendary Branch Rickey just could not resist.
But first a few interesting names from this year’s Rule 5 Draft. (Note: Only certain players not protected on each club’s forty-man roster can be selected in the Rule 5 Draft – at a cost of $100,000. The player must be kept on the selecting team’s roster for the entire upcoming season or offered back to the team from which they were selected for $50,000.)
Richie Martin, SS
The former 2015 first-round pick of the A’s was the first player taken in the draft (by the Orioles). The 23-year-old is best known for his defensive skills (soft hands/good arm), but last year the 5’11”/190-pound right-hander hit .300-6-42, with 25 stolen bases at Double A Midland and may be coming into his own at the plate. He has shown steady improvement in the batter’s box over the past three minor league seasons (.224-.266-.300). There are those who say his range may be better suited to second base. The Orioles, who won only 47 games last season, are pretty thin in the middle infield, so Martin has a good chance to stick with the team.
Sam McWilliams, RHP
At 6’7”/190-pounds, McWilliams – taken by the Royals from the Rays with the second pick in the 2018 Rule 5 Draft – has the kind of size MLB teams like to see on the mound. The long and lean righty, however, still has a lot to prove. The 22-year-old is 23-26, 3.77 in five minor league seasons, with 305 strikeouts in 403 1/3 innings.
McWilliams is seen to have a considerable upside, with a low-90’s fastball, a slider and an improving changeup. He was drafted right out of high school by the Phillies (Round 8, 2014); traded to the Diamondbacks (for Jeremey Hellickson in November of 2015) and traded to the Rays (with Colin Poche for Steven Souza, Jr.) in May of 2018. He may have found a landing place in the Royals’ bullpen. (Keep in mind the Royals finished at the bottom of the AL Central last season.)
Reed Garrett, RHP
Reed Garrett, plucked from the Rangers by the Tigers, brings a mid-90’s fastball and a hard slider to Detroit. In 2018, the 25-year-old righty pitched for the Frisco RoughRiders at Double A and the Round Rock Express at Triple A. The 6’2”/210-pounder went a combined 4-1, 2.04 with 21 saves and 61 strikeouts in 61 2/3 innings. Expect him to get a genuine opportunity to secure a spot the Bengal bullpen.
Joe Conner, INF
Like Sam McWilliams (two spots above), Joe Conner has already packed his bags a couple of times – traded from the Pirates (who drafted him in the first round of the 2014 MLB Draft) to the Braves and then sent on to the Dodgers last year. The Reds snatched Conner from the Dodgers in this year’s Rule 5 Draft. The 6’/205-pounder has shown versatility, last year playing first base, second base, third base and DH at Double A and Triple A. He also has shown some power – .299-17-55 in 106 minor league games in 2018. The 26-year-old has also played both corner outfield spots in the minors and could stick with the Reds as a utility player and bright-handed bat off the bench.
Brandon Brennan, RHP
Brandon Brennan moved from the Rockies to the Mariners in the Rule 5 Draft and, given the moves the Mariners have been making this off season, the 27-year-old could very well stick in the Settle pen. Brennan – drafted by the White Sox in the fourth round of the 2012 MLB draft – pitched in the White Sox system from 2012 through 2018. (He was signed by the Rockies recently as a free-agent). In 2018, Brennan went 5-4, 3.25 in 44 appearances at Double A – using a low- to mid-90s fastball, complemented by a slider and a changeup. The key to the Mariners’ interest, though, may have been his 79 strikeouts in 69 2/3 innings. He also pitched in the Mexican-Pacific Winter league this past year, putting up a 2.51 ERA in 12 appearances.
So, there are a few 2018 Rule 5 Draftee that caught BBRT’s eye. Now let’s look at some of the more interesting Rule 5 selections from the past.
Roberto Clemente – Da Bums’ Big Blunder
Okay, this is probably the number-one story told whenever the history of the MLB Rule 5 Draft is being discussed. Roberto Clemente is arguably the best player ever picked up in the Rule 5 Draft – and clearly did more for the team that drafted him than another player.
Clemente signed with the Dodgers (out of Puerto Rico) at 19-years-old in February of 1954. The Dodgers apparently felt they could keep the unprotected bonus baby under the radar in the minors – limiting his playing time and, at times, even having him take batting practice with the pitchers, rather than the position players.
Roberto Clemente was the first Latin American player to earn a World Series Most Valuable Player Award. It came in 1971, when he hit .414 against the Orioles.
Oops! The Dodgers’ strategy didn’t work. On November 22, 1954, Pittsburgh used a Rule 5 Draft pick to pirate Clemente away from the Dodgers. It was easily the most productive (from the Pirates’ point of view) and destructive (from the Dodgers’ perspective) Rule 5 transaction ever.
Clemente went on to play 18 MLB seasons – all with the Pirates – earning his way into the Hall of Fame. He was 12-time All Star, 12-time Gold Glover, four-time batting champion and the 1966 National League MVP. Exactly what did the Pirates get (and the Dodgers lose)? How about 3,000 MLB hits, a .317 career average, 440 doubles, 166 triples, 240 home runs, 1,305 RBI, 1,416 runs scored?
Clearly, for the Dodgers, Roberto Clemente is THE one that got away.
Shane Victorino – Prodigal Son Not Returned
Shane Victorino, who became known as “The Flyin’ Hawaiian” with the Phillies, started his professional career (like Roberto Clemente, above) in the Dodgers’ organization. And, with Victorino, the Dodgers had two bites at the apple.
Victorino – born in Wailuku, Hawaii – was selected by the Dodgers (as an 18-year-old) in the sixth round of the 1999 MLB Draft. Victorino worked his way up in the Dodgers’ system – from Rookie ball to AA between 1999 and 2002.
Victorino was left unprotected and picked (from the Dodgers) by the Padres in the 2002 Rule Five Draft. He made his MLB debut with San Diego in April of 2003, but played just 36 games with the Padres and hit a meager .151. In late May, Victorino was returned to the Dodgers.
He played two more minor league seasons in the Dodgers’ system and – again unprotected – was selected by the Phillies in the 2004 Rule 5 Draft. (Note: In 2004, at AA and AAA, Victorino hit .289, with 19 home runs and 16 steals.) Victorino didn’t make the Phillies major league squad out of Spring Training and was offered back to the Dodgers. This time, the Dodgers rejected the return and the Phillies were able to assign Victorino to their Triple A affiliate (Scranton/Wilkes Barre), where he really took off – hitting .310-18-70 in 126 games and earning International League All Star and MVP recognitions.
On June 3, 2007, as the Phillies celebrated Shane Victorino Day (even flying Victorino’s father in from Hawaii for the game), “The Flyin’ Hawaiin” topped off the celebration with a ninth-inning, game-winning, walk-off home run.
The rest is history, the two-time Rule 5 draftee, played eight seasons with the Phillies, hitting .279 with 88 home runs, 390 RBI and 179 stolen bases,. During his time in Philly, he led the NL in triples twice, won three Gold Gloves and was an All Star twice. He played a total of 12 MLB seasons and hit .275-108-489, with 731 runs scored, 231 steals and four Gold Gloves.
Johan Santana – Johan, we hardly knew ya!
In 1999, Jared Camp was in his fifth professional season – taking the mound for the Cleveland Indians’ affiliates at the A Double A and Triple A levels. He went combined 4-4, 2.81 and fanned 91 batters in 83 1/3 innings. That same season, 20-year-old Johan Santana went 8-8. 4.66 for the Astros’ Single A farm team – fanning 150 batters in 160 1/3 innings pitched. Neither pitcher was protected going into the 1999 Rule 5 Draft – in which the Twins had the first pick and the Marlins the second. And that’s where the fun begins.
The Twins took Camp with the first pick, while the Marlins took Johan Santana second. The Twins immediately sent Camp to the Marlins for Santana and cash. Ultimately, Santana for Camp and cash proved a Rule 5 “draft-and-trade” steal for Minnesota.
On June 12, 2012, Johan Santana threw the first no-hitter in New York Mets’ history.
Camp never pitched in the major leagues, while Santana went on to became a four-time All Star (three times as a Twin). He spent eight of his 12 MLB seasons with Minnesota – going 93-44 with a 3.22 ERA, recording the league’s lowest ERA twice, leading the league in wins once and strikeouts three times. In 2008, the former Rule Five pick was traded to the Mets (bringing the Twins Carlos Gomez, Philip Humber, Kevin Mulvey and Deolis Guerra). He pitched four season for New York (46-34, 3.18) winning another ERA title.
Jose Bautista – Doesn’t Anybody Want This Guy? Or “Country Roads Take Me Home.”
Jose Bautista was signed by the Pirates in the 20th round of the 2000 MLB draft and, by 2003, had shown some promise in the minors (three seasons, 249 games, .287 average, 20 home runs, 110 RBI, 12 stolen bases).
In December 2003, an odyssey that began with the Rule 5 draft would see Bautista become the first player to appear on five different MLB rosters in a single season – and end up back home with the same organization that originally lost him in the Rule 5 Draft. His season went like this:
- December 15, 2003 … picked selected (from the Pirates) by the Orioles in the Rule 5 draft – opened the season with the Orioles;
- June 3, 2004 … waived by the Orioles, picked up by the Rays;
- June 28, 2004 … sold by the Rays to the Royals;
- July 30, 2004 … traded by the Royals to the Mets;
- July 30, 2004 … traded by the Mets to the Pirates.
In that post-Rule 5-Draft 2004 season, Bautista actually appeared on the field for four MB teams – Orioles (16 games); Devil Rays (12); Royals (13); and Pirates (23). In addition, he appeared, briefly, on the Mets’ MLB roster. He also appeared in MLB games at five different positions – third bases, left field, center field, right filed and DH.
In 2018, Jose Bautista became the first player to homer for three different teams in the same division in the same season – two round trippers for the Braves, nine for the Mets and two for the Phillies. (Yes, Virginia, in baseball we track everything.)
Bautista ended his first MLB season hitting .205, with no home runs and two RBI in 88 at bats. To date, in 15 MLB seasons, Bautista (who has earned the nickname “Joey Bats”) has hit .247, with 344 home runs and 1,032 RBI. He’s a six-time All Star and led the AL in home runs in 2010 and 2011 (54 and 43 round trippers, respectively) with the Blue Jays.
Darrell Evans – Catch and Release
It took a long time for an MLB team to “catch” Darrell Evans. He was drafted five times (Cubs, Yankees, Tigers, Phillies, Athletics) before he finally signed with the A’s in 1967. (Evans, at the time of those many MLB Draft selections, was starring in both baseball and basketball at Pasadena Junior College.) However, after just two minor league seasons (A’s system) and a shoulder injury, he was left unprotected and picked up by the Braves (1968 Rule 5 Draft). Here’s a look at Evan’s Draft record:
- Picked by Cubs in 13th round of 1965 MLB draft – did not sign.
- Picked by Yankees in 2nd round of the 1966 MLB Draft – did not sign.
- Picked by Tigers in the 5th round of the 1966 (secondary) MLB Draft – did not sign,
- Picked by Phillies in the 3rd round of the 1967 amateur draft – did not sign.
- Signed by the Athletics out of the 7th round of the 1967 (secondary) MLB Draft.
- Picked up by the Braves in the 1968 Rule 5 Draft.
Darrell Evans was the first player with a 40-home run season in both the NL and AL. He hit 41 for the Braves in 1973 and 40 for the Tigers in 1985.
Evans played with the Braves for nine seasons – hitting .246 with 131 home runs and 424 RBI, topping 20 home runs three times (a high of 41 in 1973). He went on to a 21-season MLB career, during which he hit .248, with 414 home runs and 1,354 RBI.
Elroy (Roy) Face – A Boyhood Hero Makes His Mark
Roy Face was signed by the Phillies (free agent) in 1949 (age 21) – and he got off to a pretty good start. Pitching for the Bradford Blue Wings of the Class D Pennsylvania-Ontario-New York (PONY) League, Face went 32-7, 2.88 (primarily as a starter) in 1949 and 1950. Branch Rickey, at the time President/General Manager of the Dodgers, apparently like what he saw and snatched Face from the Phillies in the 1950 Minor League Draft.
In the Dodgers’ system, Face continued to thrive as a starter. In 1951 and 1952, he went a combined 37-20, 2.80. After four minor league campaigns, Face had 69 wins, just 27 losses, with a 2.84 earned run average – and he had pitched 840 innings. Still, the Dodgers left Face unprotected in the December 1952 Rule 5 draft. Branch Rickey, then General Manager of the Pirates, proved he could remember a “Face,” an arm and a name. At Rickey’s direction, the Pirates picked up Face in the Rule 5 Draft.
In 1959, Elroy Face went 18-1 in relief for the Pirates. His .947 winning percentages is the highest ever for a qualifying pitcher (at least one decision for every ten team games) and the most wins in relief ever in an MLB season. Face also had ten saves that campaign, when he pitched in 57 games and put up a 2.70 ERA in 93 1/3 innings.
Face went on to a 16-season (1953, 1955-69) MLB career (15 seasons with the Pirates) during which he became one of National League’s premier relievers. He was a three-time All Star, led the league in appearances twice and saves three times. Face’s final stat line was 104-95, 3.48, with 848 appearances, 191 saves, and 877 strikeouts in 1,375 innings pitched. Just 5’8” and 155 pounds, the diminutive Face was one of my boyhood heroes.
Primary Resources: Baseball-Reference.com; MLB.com
BASEBALL ROUNDTABLE MAKES TOP 100 BASEBALL BLOG LIST
Baseball Roundtable has made the Feedspot list of the Top 1oo Baseball Blogs. To see the full list, click here.
I tweet baseball @DavidBBRT
Follow/Like Baseball Roundtable’s Facebook Page here. More baseball commentary; blog post notifications; PRIZES.
Member: Society for American Baseball Research (SABR); The Baseball Reliquary; The Negro Leagues Baseball Museum.


































































