Bartolo Colon’s 38 Straight Strikes – and Pitchers Who Were (apparently) Effectively Wild

Today (April 18, 2022) marks the tenth anniversary of a remarkable pitching achievements.  On April 18, 2012, Oakland A’s Bartolo Colon started on the mound against Ervin Santana and the Angels.  During one stretch of that game, won by A’s 6-0, Colon threw 38 consecutive strikes.  (The longest such streak since pitch-by-pitch data began being accurately tracked in 1988.) Were all 38 offerings in the strike zone? Perhaps not, but all those pitches that were outside the zone were close enough that the batters offered at them.

Overall, the streak lasted from the second pitch of the fifth innings until the seventh pitch of the eight frame.  Surprisingly, Colon struck out just two batters during the streak.  He also gave up two hits during the streak of strikes.

For the game, Colon threw 108 pitches – 82 strikes. For those who like such details, the first strike of Colon’s run came on his second pitch to SS Maicer Izturis leading off the Angels’ fifth. His streak ended on his second pitch to LF Bobby Abreu in the eighth. For the game, Colon pitched eight shutout innings – four hits, no walks and five whiffs – running his record to 3-1, 2.63. A few notable stats from the game:

  • 35 of the 38 pitches were fastballs (two changeups and one slider).
  • There was only one swing and miss (17 strikes looking).
  • There were ten foul fouls and ten balls put in play.

Colon pitched in 21 MLB seasons (1997-2009, 2011-18 … Indians, Expos, White Sox, Angels, Red Sox, Yankees, A’s, Mets, Braves, Twins, Rangers) – winnings 247 games (188 losses),  with a 4.12 ERA. He  fanned 2,535 batters and walked  948 in 3,461 2/3 innings. Between 2012-2016 he averaged just 1.3 walks per nine innings –  twice recording the NL’s lowest walks/nine rate.  He averaged fewer than two walks per nine frames in nine seasons.

Now, as always, with Baseball Roundtable, one thing leads to another. So, imagine my surprise, when I saw Colon as the most recent entry in Baseball Almanac’s list of pitchers to start a game and walk four consecutive batters before recording an out. It happened on June 29, 2000, as Colon started for the Indians in Kansas City. Colon opened the bottom of the first inning by walking  Royals’ LF Johnny Damon, 2B Jeff Roboulet, 1B Mike Sweeney and RF Jermaine Dye on a total of 24 pitches.  He actually survived the inning, following the four walks  with a sacrifice fly, run-scoring groundout and a strikeout. Side note: This was a pretty good hitting Royals team. Among those first-inning walks, Roboulet was hitting .309, Sweeney .347 and Dye .320.   Colon lasted five innings in the game, giving up five earned runs on two hits and six walks.

Well, that bit of research sent me on another tangent – a look at pitchers who gave  up at  least ten walks in a game, without surrendering a run.  Turns out it happened  a manageable nine times.  So, here they are, with some very subjective rankings.

  1. Jim Maloney. Reds … August 19, 1965 versus Cubs (in Chicago)

Maloney tops this list because his game was a ten-inning no-hitter – in which Maloney gave up ten walks, hit one batter and fanned  a dozen. Maloney’s toughest inning was the third, when he walked 2B Glenn Beckert and SS Don Kessinger to open the inning; then fanned P Larry Jackson and got CF Don Landrum to hit into a P-SS fielder’s choice; then walked LF Doug Clemens to load the bases, before getting RF Billy Williams on a groundout to second.  In the game, Maloney walked three in the third, two in the fourth, eighth and ninth and one in the tenth.  The Reds and Maloney won the game 1-0, scoring in the top of the tenth on a home run by number-eight hitter SS Leo Cardenas.

Maloney enjoyed a 12-season MLB career (1960-71) – all but the final year (Angels) with the Reds. He went 134-84, 3.19, twice winning 20 or more games in a season and logging six seasons of 15 or more victories.  He finished in the league’s top five in walks five times and top three in wild pitches six times (leading the league twice).

  1. Bill James, Tigers … May 12, 1916 versus Athletics (in Philadelphia)

James takes the number-two spot on this list because he managed  to not allow a run, while walking ten batters in just five innings.

  • James walked the first two batters in the first inning, but pitched out of the jam (sacrifice, fielder’s choice, strikeout).
  • He gave up a walk and a single to put runners on first and third to start the second frame, but again worked his way out (runner caught stealing, fly out, strikeout).
  • In the third, he again started the inning by putting two runners on base (walks), but slipped the hook with two ground outs and a fly out.
  • Fourth frame, guess what? First two batters get on again (walks). James then got a groundout and a strikeout (leaving runners on second and third), before another walk to load the bases. A flyball to right then ended the inning.
  • The fifth was uneventful, a lone two-out single.
  • James started the sixth with a pair of walks before being pulled – and reliever Bernie Boland got out of the inning without a run touching the plate.

So, despite two hits and ten walks in five innings, James left with a 2-0 lead.  The bullpen, oweer, eventually gave up the lead and James got a no-decision.  (The Tigers eventually won 8-6 in 11 innings.)

James pitched in eight MLB seasons (1911-12, 1914-19 … Indians, Browns, Tigers, Red Sox, White Sox). He went 64-71, 3.21.

  1. J.R. Richard, Astros … July 6, 1976 versus Mets (in Houston)

Photo: Public Domain via WikiCommons

Richard’s  qualifying game featured a ten-inning, compete-game shutout – despite eight hits, ten walks and two wild pitches.  In the first inning, Richard gave up a single and a double (3B Make Phillips and CF Bruce Boisclair), but avoided a run with Philips cut down at the plate. Richard pitched in and out of trouble all game,  but the seventh and eighth innings were especially tense. In the seventh , after getting the first out (2B Felix Milan on a grounder to short), Richard walked SS Bud Harrelson and wild pitched him to second. He then walked P Jon Matlock and 3B Mike Phillips to load the bases – but a fly out to  short center and a grounder to first got him out of the inning.  The eighth started out smooth, with two out and no one on, but Richard then walked C Jerry Grote, Milan and Harrelson to load the bases before fanning Matlock to end the inning.

Mets’ starter Jon Matlock matched Richard goose egg for goose egg  through nine, but was lifted for a pinch hitter in the tenth. Mets’ Reliever Skip Lockwood gave up a run on two singles and an error in the bottom of the tenth and Richard had a hard-fought 1-0 win.

Richard pitched 10 MLB seasons (1971-80), all for the Astros. He went 107-71, 3.15 – once winning 20 games (20-15, 2.75 in 1976) and three times notching 18 wins.  He led the NL in  strikeouts twice – both times topping 300 whiffs – and led in walks and wild pitches three times each.

  1. Gary Peters, Whites Sox …. September 13, 1967 versus the Indians (in Chicago)

Peters worked hard for little return (a no decision) – pitching 11 one-hit, no-run innings (with, of course, ten walks and one hit by pitch) – in a game the White Sox eventually won ( 17 innings) 1-0.  Peters gave up his lone hit in the top of the second –  a triple to C Joe Azcue with only one out. Peters  then walked CF Jose Vidal and 2B Vern Fuller to load the bases – before a short fly to LF and a grounder to SS got him out of the inning unscathed.  While the raw numbers would seem to dispute it, Peters really seemed to be in control, despite all the free passes.  From the third through the eleventh innings, only two runners reached second base.

Peters pitched in 14 MLB seasons (1959-72 … White Sox, Red Sox). He was a two-time All Star and went 124-103, 3.25, once leading the AL in wins (20-8 in 1964) and twice in ERA (2.33 in 1963 and 1.98 in 1966). He won 15 or more games in four seasons.

  1. Garland Buckeye, Indians … September 16, 1926 … versus Yankees in Cleveland

Have to put Garland Buckeye up here – great name and he managed a complete-game shutout against the Yankees of Babe Ruth, Lou Gehrig, Bob Meusel and Tony Lazzeri – despite giving up two hits, ten walks and a hit by pitch (and fanning only one). Buckeye spent considerable time in trouble during  the game – and Babe Ruth seemed to always be in the middle of it.

  • In the second inning, Buckeye walked RF Ruth and then gave up a double to LF Meusel (Ruth stopping a third). Buckeye then walked SS Lazzeri to load the bases. He got out of the jam with a pop up and a groundball double play.
  • In the fourth, Buckeye surrendered a single to 1B Gehrig and a walk to Ruth, before Meusel sacrificed them to second and third. A pop up and line out got Buckeye back to the bench without a run.
  • In the sixth, Buckeye walked Gehrig and Ruth with one out and pitched out of it with a couple of easy fly balls.
  • The seventh saw Buckeye issue three walks and bring Lou Gehrig to the plate with the sacks full and two out. It was then that Buckeye notched his only strikeout of the game.
  • Buckeye walked Ruth to open the eighth and followed up by hitting Meusel with a pitch – but got a double play and an infield pop up to again escape.

The game was tied 0-0 until the seventh, when the Indians put up five  runs against Yankee starter Herb Pennock. (Pennock came into the game 22-9, Buckeye at 4-8).

Garland Buckeye pitched in five MLB seasons He got a cup of coffee for the Washington Senators in 1918 (against the Yankees), and gave up three hits, six walks and four earned runs in two innings.  A big man for his time, Buckeye moved to football, where he played center and guard for the Chicago Tigers (1920) and Chicago Cardinals (1921-24)  of the American Professional Football Association (later renamed the National Football League). He returned to MLB in 1925 and played through 1928 (Indians, Giants). His career MLB stats read 30-39, 3.91 in 108 games (67 starts). As a hitter he was .230-5-23 in 204 at bats. His best season on the mound was 1925, when he went 13-8, 3.65 for the Indians.

  1. Hank Aguirre, Indians … September 24, 1955 … versus the Tigres (in Detroit)

This outing was Aguirre’s first MLB start (and just his fourth appearance).  The 24-year-old rookie struggled a bit, but managed a complete-game shutout – as his Indians prevailed 7-0.  Aguirre got off to a rocky start walking the first three batters he faced – SS Harvey Kuenn, 1B Earl Torgeson and RF Al Kaline. He wiggled out of the jam with two foul pop outs and a fly to right. He had another tough inning in the seventh, walking three of the first four batters before getting Kaline on a liner to first base and CF Bill Tuttle on a strikeout. With six of his ten free passes coming in two innings, the game was not as stressful as a ten-walk outing might seem.

Aguirre pitched 16 MLB seasons (1955-70 … Indians, Tigers, Dodgers, Cubs). He went 75-72, 3.25 and won 14 or more games in three campaigns. In 1962, he was an AL All Star (Tigers) and went 16-8, with a league-low 2.21 ERA.

  1. George Brunet, Angels … July 6, 1966 versus Tigers (in Detroit)

Brunet worked just a bit of overtime in a tight contest (the Angels won 1-0 in ten innings) to pick up a victory – giving up no runs, despite allowing three hits and 10 walks. Brunet had eight strikeouts in the game.  In the second inning, with runners on second and third and one out, Brunet fanned C Bill Freehan and SS Dick McAuliffe to escape. In the eighth, a double and a pair of walks (after two outs) loaded the bases, but Brunet coaxed a ground out to third from  LF Willie Horton. The Angels scored in the  top of the tenth to give Brunet a 1-0 lead, but  after he walked the first batter in the bottom of the inning (3B Don Wert), got 2B Jake Wood to pop out and then gave up a single to 1B Norm Cash, Brunet was relieved by Jack Sanford who got the final two outs.

George Brunet pitched in 15 MLB seasons (1956-57, 1959-71 … Athletics, Braves, Astros, Orioles, Angels, Pilots, Senators, Pirates, Cardinals). He went 69-93, 3.62.

George Brunet  is a member of the Mexican Baseball Hall of Fame. After leaving the major leagues, he pitched Mexico until 1989 (age 54).

  1. Mel Stottlemyre, Yankees … May 21, 1970 versus Senators (in New York)

This falls just a little short of one-run game.  Stottlemyre got a 2-0 win, despite six hits, 11 walks and two wild pitches.

Stottlemyre was  in trouble right from the start, giving  up two walks and two singles in a scoreless first (one runner was erased trying to advance to second on a single).  Things calmed down until the fourth, when Stottlemyre again managed to escape scoreless, despite two singles and a walk (one runner called out after being struck by a fair ball).  In the fifth, Stottlemyre gave up two walks, one hit, a stolen base and tossed a wild pitch – but a key runner caught stealing  enabled  him to escape again.  In the ninth, a single and two walks had the bases loaded with one out (in a 2-0 game) and  Stottlemyre was pulled.  Reliever Steve Hamilton came in and fanned 1B Mike Epstein and 2B Bernie Allen (the number-four and number-five hitters) to save the game.

Stottlemyre pitched in 11 MLB seasons (1964-70), all for the Yankees.  He was a five-time All Star and won 20 or more games in three seasons (15 or more games in seven seasons).  He also led the AL in losses twice. His overall record was 164-139, 2.97.

Mel Stottlemyre was an All Star in 1966, when he led the AL in losses ( 12-20, 3.80). He was 7-8, 3.15 at the break and 5-12, 4.51 in the second half.

  1. Lefty Gomez, Yankees … August 1, 1941 versus Browns (In New York)

Gomez  gave up five hits and 11 walks (one wild pitch) and still managed to shut down the Browns  in a lopsided 9-0 Yankee win. (There wasn’t a lot of pressure on Gomez, it was 3-0 after one inning and 6-0 after three.)

Really,  despite  all the walks, Gomez did not seem to be in a lot of trouble. The most bothersome innings  were bookends – the first and the ninth.  In the first, Gomez gave up a leadoff single to 2B Don Heffner, then retired the next two batters before walking a pair (Wally CF Judnich and LF Roy Cullenbine) to load the bases. This brought up RF Chet Laabs (remember that name, he’ll come up again) with the bases full and two outs. Gomez  got him on a foul pop out.  In the ninth, Gomez walked the bases full with two outs, and Chet Laabs was again the batter (told you he’d be back).  This time it was a fly out to center to end the game.

Hall  of Famer Gomez pitched in 14 MLB seasons (1930-43), all but the final one for the Yankees. (He was 0-1, 5.79 in one start for the Senators in 1943).  Gomez was 189-102, 3.34 for his career. A seven-time All Star, he led the AL in wins twice (and four times won 20+ games), and also led in ERA twice, in complete games twice, in shutouts three times and in strikeouts three times.

Primary Resources:  Baseball-Reference.com; Baseball-Almanac.com; Bartolo Colon Throws 38 Consecutive Strikes in A’s Win, The Washington Post, April 20, 2012, by Matt Brooks

 

100Baseball Roundtable is on the Feedspot list of the Top 100 Baseball Blogs.  To see the full list, click here.

I tweet baseball @DavidBBRT

Follow/Like Baseball Roundtable’s Facebook Page here.  More baseball commentary; blog post notifications; PRIZES.

Member: Society for American Baseball Research (SABR); Negro Leagues Baseball Museum; The Baseball Reliquary. 

 

More Pre-Season Musings – Teammates Finishing Atop the MVP Ballot … and More

More pre-season musings.  I was looking at rosters and noted that the Dodgers – for the second year in a row – had four former MVPs on the team: Freddie Freeman; Cody Bellinger; Mookie Betts; and Clayton Kershaw.   They did it a year ago, as well – with Albert Pujols replacing Freeman – and are the first team to achieve that distinction in consecutive seasons. Notably, of the five teams to boast four former MVPs on their Opening Day rosters, only one – the 1978 Reds – had four players who earned their MVP recognition with the team.

 

As regular readers know, when Baseball Roundtable looks into a trivia tidbit, “one thing always leads to another.”   In this case, it led to a look into teammates who finished atop the MVP voting in the same season.  I learned that the last time, MLB saw teammates finish 1-2-3 in Most Valuable Player race was in 1966– when Frank Robinson, Brook Robinson and Boog Powell of the World Champion Orioles earned the top three spots in the American League MVP balloting.  In this post, Baseball Roundtable will take a look at all those instances in which teammates finished 1-2 or 1-2-3 in the Most Valuable Player balloting.

Let’s start with a look at teammates who finished 1-2-3 in the MVP balloting.

1966 – OF Frank Robinson, Orioles, MVP … 3B, Brooks Robinson, Orioles, second … 1B Boog Powell, third

The 1966 World Champion Orioles (97-63) were clearly led by OF Frank Robinson.

  • Frank Robinson hit .316-49-122, winning the AL Triple Crown. He also led the league in runs scored (122).
  • Brooks Robinson, won his seventh straight Gold Glove, and also had a solid offensive year (.269-23-100).
  • Boog Powell came in at .287-34-109.

Notably, three Twins finished 4-5-6: Harmon Killebrew, Jim Kaat and Tony Oliva.  Also finishing in the top ten for the Orioles that year was shortstop Luis Aparicio at number nine.

From 1964-66, Brooks Robinson never finished lower than third in the AL MVP voting. One first, one second, one third.

______________________________________

1959 – 2B Nellie Fox, White Sox, MVP … SS Luis Aparicio, White Sox, second … P Early Wynn, White Sox, third

The 1959 White Sox used defense and pitching to upend the favored Yankees and finish first in the American League (94-60-2) – despite having only one player with at least 20 home runs (C Sherm Lollar , 22) and no player with more than 84 RBI or 98 runs scored. In fact, only one regular member of the lineup hit higher than .275. It’s no surprise that two Gold Glove middle infielders and a pitcher were their top MVP vote getters.

  • Nellie Fox hit .306-2-70, with 84 runs scored.
  • Luis Aparicio it .257-6-51, with 98 runs scored and 56 steals.
  • Early Wynn led the league with 22 wins (ten losses) and put up a 3.17 ERA in 37 starts.

The White Sox won the Al pennant in 1959 despite finishing sixth (out of eight teams) in runs scored and batting average and last in home runs. The ChiSox had five of the top ten finishers in the MVP balloting that year, with CF Jim Landis at number-seven and C Sherm Lollar at number-nine joining the top three.

________________________________

1941 – 1B Dolph Camilli, Dodgers, MVP … CF Pete Reiser, Dodgers, second … pitcher Whit Wyatt Dodges, third

The 1941 Dodgers went 101-54-3, finishing atop the National League –  boasting a potent attack  that led the league in runs scored (800), home runs (101) and average (.272), and a pitching staff that boasted two 20-game winners and the league’s  lowest ERA (3.14), That was reflected in the MVP balloting.

  • 1B Dolph Camilli hit .285 and led the league in home runs (34) and RBI (120), while scoring 92 runs.
  • CF Pete Reiser led the league in batting (.343), runs scored (117), doubles (39), triples (17) and tossed in 14 home runs and 76 RBI.
  • P Whit Wyatt led the league with 22 wins (10 losses) and seven shutouts. His 2.34 ERA was second in the league, as were his 23 complete games and 176 strikeouts.

Dodgers’ Kirby Higbe and OF Dixie Walker also finished in the balloting’s top ten at seven and ten, respectively.

__________________________

1914 – 2B Johnny Evers, Braves, MVP … SS Rabbit Maranville, Braves, second … P Bill James, Braves, third

The 1914 World Champion Braves finished the regular season 94-59-5. They were dubbed the Miracle Braves after finishing in fifth place the previous year and being 16 games out of first place on July 4 and  in last place (11 games out) as late as July 18.  In fact, the Braves did not drop their deficit into single digits until July 31 – and yet they finished the season 10 ½ games ahead of the second-place Giants.  No wonder they had the top three MVP vote-getters in Bill James (one of two 26-game winners on the pitching staff) and infielders Johnny Evers and Rabbit Maranville, who provided sparkling defense up the middle  (and led the league in double plays), while also contributing on offense.

  • Johnny Evers hit .279-1-40 , with 12 steals and 81 runs scored in 139 games.
  • Rabbit Maranville hit .246-4-78, with 74 runs and 28 steals in 156 games.
  • Bill James went 26-7, 1.90, with 30 complete games in 37 starts.

Brave’ pitcher Dick Rudolph also finished in the top ten, seventh in the voting.

Bill  James pitched in only four MLB seasons, with a career line of 37-21,  2.28. Outside of that 1914 miracle season, he was 11-14, 2.88. In Game Two of the 1914 World Series, James pitched a two-hit shutout, as the Braves topped the Athletics 1-0. Side note: James career was cut short by chronic arm fatigue which surfaced  in 1915.

______________________________________

Now, a look at teammates who finished  1-2 in the MVP vote.

2000 – 2B Jeff Kent, Giants, MVP … LF Barry Bonds Giants, second

In 2000, as the Giants won 97 games to lead the NL West.

  • Jeff Kent hit .334, with 33 home runs, 125 RBI, 114 runs scored and 12 steals.
  • Barry Bonds hit .306-49-106, with 129 runs scored and 11 steals.

Kent received 392 points in the balloting (with 22 first-place votes); Bonds was at 279 (six first-place votes).  They were at the heart of the Giants’ potent attack – and a solid case could be made for either player. After finishing second to Kent in the 2000 MVP voting, Bonds went on to win the National League MVP Award in each of the next four seasons.

2000 was truly a “power year in the balloting, as every one of the top 11 National League vote-getters hit at least 33 home runs (seven hit 40+) and drove in at least 104. The Rockies’ Todd Helton finished sixth in the balloting, despite leading the league in average (.373), RBI (147) and hits (216), while also stroking 42 homers.  The top four finishers  in the AL MVP race all hit 40+ homer and drove in 130+ runs. Pitcher Pedro Martinez broke the string, by finishing  fifth in the voting.

__________________________________

1989 – LF Kevin Mitchell, Giants, MVP… 1B Will Clark, Giants, second

The Giants went 92-70, finishing first in the NL West, with Clark and Mitchell each driving in 100+ runs.

On the season:

  • Kevin Mitchell hit .291, and led the NL in home runs (47) and RBI (125), while also scoring 100 runs.
  • Will Clark hit .333-23-111, and led the NL with 104 runs scored.

Mitchell outpaced Clark in balloting 314 to 222 in points and 20-to-three in first-place votes.

_______________________________________

1983 – SS Cal Ripken, Jr., Orioles, MVP … 1B Eddie Murray, Orioles, second

The Orioles finished 98-64 and went on to win the World Series behind these two MVP candidates:

  • Cal Ripken, Jr. went .318-27-102, and led the AL in hits (211) and runs scored (121), while playing in all 162 games;
  • Eddie Murray was close, ending at .306-33-111, with 115 runs scored.

It was a close vote (322-290), with Ripken getting 15 first-place nods and Murray ten.  The only other first-place votes went to White Sox catcher Carlton Fisk (three), who finished third (.286-26-86).

_________________________________

1976 – 2B Joe Morgan, Reds, MVP … OF George Foster, Reds, second

The Reds went 102-60 and won the nL West (and World Series).

  • Joe Morgan hit .320, with 27 home runs, 111 RBI and 113 runs scored (and picked up his third straight Gold Glove).
  • George Foster hit .306, with 29 home runs and a league-leading 121 RBI.

The clinchers for Morgan were likely his 60 steals (to Foster’s 17) and 114 walks to Foster’s 54. Those walks gave Morgan a league-topping .444 on-base percentage (to Foster’s .364).  Morgan got 311 points in the full ranked voting to 221 for Foster. Morgan got 19 first-place votes to Foster’s five. A third Reds’ player, Pete Rose, finished fourth in the balloting.

________________________________________

1971 – P Vida Blue, A’s, MVP … 3B Sal Bando, A’s, second

The A’s went 101-60 in winning the AL West, as Vida Blue won the Cy Young and Most Valuable Player Awards.

  • Vida Blue went 24-8, with a league-leading 1.82 earned run average. He threw 24 complete games in 39 starts and led the league with eight shutouts.
  • Bando went .271-24-94 (leading the A’s in RBI).

Blue outpaced Bando 268-182 in the full ranked voting and had 14 first-place votes to Bando’s four. Reggie Jackson, who hit .277-32-80, with 87 runs scored and 16 steals (outpacing Bando in all those categories) finished 14th in the balloting.

___________________________________

1968 – P Denny McLain, Tigers, MVP …. C Bill Freehan, Tigers, MVP

1960 was the “Year of the Pitcher,” with Denny McLain (AL) and Bob Gibson (NL) each capturing their league’s Cy Young and MVP Awards. McLain may have pulled his battery mate Bill Freehan along for the ride. The Tigers went 103-59-2 (and went on to win the World Series).

  • Denny McLain went 31-6, 1.96, leading the AL in wins (31), complete games (28) and innings pitched (336).
  • Bill Freehan went .263-25-84 in 155 games (138 behind the plate).

McLain outpaced Freehan 280 to 161 in the ranked voting and got all 20 first-place votes.  Boston’s 1B/OF Ken Harrelson finished third despite outhitting Freehan (.275, with 35 home runs and a league-topping 109 RBI). That season a .275 average was good for ninth-best in the AL.)

Denny McLain and Bill Freehan are the only battery mates to finish 1-2 in he MVP voting in the same season.

____________________________

1967 – 1B Orlando Cepeda, Cardinals, MVP … C Tim McCarver, Cardinals, second

The Cardinals went 101-60 in 1967 (and won the World Series) and Orlando Cepeda was the big bat in the lineup, leading the team in average, home runs and RBI.  For the season:

  • Orlando Cepeda hit .325-25-111, with 11 steals and 91 runs scored;
  • Tim McCarver hit .295-14-69, with eight steals and 68 runs scored and was an acknowledged team leader.

Cepeda got all 20 first-place votes and outpaced McCarver 280-136 in the balloting.

___________________________________

1965 – SS Zoilo Versalles, Twins, MVP … RF Tony Oliva, Twins, second

The Twins went 102-60 in 1965, taking the AL Pennant. SS Zoilo Versalles was selected AL MVP, topping teammate Tony Oliva.

  • Zoilo Versalles led the AL in plate appearances (728); at bats (666); runs scored (126), doubles (45), triples (12) and total bases (308), while batting .273, popping 19 home runs and stealing 27 bags.
  • Tony Oliva won the AL batting Championship (.321) and led the league in hits (185), popped 16 home runs, drove in 98 and scored 107.

In 1965, when Zoilo Versalles won the AL Most Valuable Player Award, he led the American League in strikeouts and errors.

Versalles got 19 of the twenty first-place votes and 275 total points in the balloting. Oliva got the remaining first-place vote and 174 points.

___________________________________________

1962 – CF Mickey Mantle, Yankees, MVP … 2B Bobby Richardson, Yankees, second

The World Champion Yankees went 96-66 in the regular season in 1962, as Mickey Mantle won his third MVP Award and first Gold Glove.

  • Mickey Mantle hit .321-30-89, with 96 runs scored and nine steals in 123 games.
  • Bobby Richardson hit .302-8-59, with 99 runs scored and a league-topping 209 hits in 161 one games (and was the glue in the Yankee infield).

Mantle got 13 first-place votes and 234 points in the balloting. Richardson got five first place votes and 152 points.  The remaining two first-place votes went to the Twins’ Harmon Killebrew and the Yankees’ Tom Tresh.

Bobby Richardson is the only player to win the World Series MVP Award while playing on the losing team (1960).

________________________________________

1961 – RF Roger Maris, Yankees, MVP … CF Mickey Mantle, Yankees, second

Okay, how do you not give the MVP Award to the player who broke Babe Ruth’s hallowed home run record?  But, despite the record, the vote was a lot closer than you might think. Here are the stats.

  • Roger Maris hit just .269, but led the AL in home runs (61), RBI (141) and runs scored (132), as he captured his second straight MVP Award.
  • Mickey Mantle hit .317-54-128, with 131 runs scored and 12 steals.

In the voting, Maris got seven first-place votes and 202 points; Mantle got six first-place votes and 198 points.  (Jim Gentile, who tied Maris for the RBI lead and had 46 home runs and a .302 average picked up five first-lace votes in a third-place finish.) The Yankees won 109 regular-season games (53 losses, one tie) and the World Championship behind the M&M boys.

__________________________________________

1960 – RF Roger Maris, Yankees, MVP … CF Mickey Mantle, Yankees, second

In a precursor to the 1961 MVP results, Roger Maris edged teammate Mickey Mantle for the AL MVP Award as the Yankees went 97-57-1 to lead the American League.

  • Roger Maris hit .281, with 39 homers and a league-topping 112 RBI (98 run scored).
  • Mickey Mantle hit .275, hit an AL-best 40 homers, drove in 94 runs and scored an AL-leading 119.

In the balloting Mantle got ten first-place votes to Maris’ eight, but lost 225 to 222 in total points.

The 1960 MVP race between Roger Maris and Mickey Mantle was the closest ever among teammates – a three-point difference among 447 points for the two leaders. The closest vote ever came in 1947, when Joe DiMaggio edged Ted Williams by one point (202-201) – despite the fact that Williams won the Triple Crown.

_______________________________________

1956 – CF Mickey Mantle, Yankees, MVP … C Yogi Berra, Yankees, second

Another Yankee 1-2 punch in the MVP chase. Finishing atop the MVP balloting for the World Champion Yankees (970-57 in the regular season) were:

  • Triple Crown winner Mickey Mantle (.353-52-130, with a league-leading 132 runs scored); and
  • Yogi Berra (.298-30-105, with 93 runs scored).

Mantle got 336 points and all 24 first-place votes and Berra accumulated 186 points.  The Yankees went 97-57 – and went on to win the World Series (over the Dodgers) four games-to-three.

In an 18-season MLB career, Mickey Mantle finished among the top three in AL MVP voting seven times.

__________________________________________

1956 – P Don Newcombe, Dodgers, MVP … P Sal Maglie, Dodgers Second

The 1955 Dodgers edged the Milwaukee Braves by one game for the NL pennant going 93-61. Overall, the Dodgers outscored the Braves 720-709 on the season and gave up 32 fewer runs.

A pair of Dodgers pitchers finished 1-2 in the MVP balloting.

  • Don Newcombe, led the NL in wins with 27 (seven losses), put up a 3.06 ERA and tossed 18 complete games in 36 starts.
  • Sal Maglie went 13-5, 2.87 for the Dodgers after coming over from the Indians in May.

Newcombe got eight first-place votes and 223 points to Maglie’s four first-place votes and 183 points. Notably, two pretty well-known Braves finished third and fourth: Hank Aaron (.328-26-92) and Warren Spahn (20-11, 2.78).

___________________________________

1955 – C Roy Campanella, Dodgers, MVP … CF Duke Snider, Dodgers, second

In 1955, the Dodgers finally knocked off the crosstown rival Yankees in the World Series.  They got there on a 98-55-1 regular-season record fueled, in great part, by Roy Campanella and Duke Snider.

  • Roy Campanella hit .318-32-107, with 81 runs scored.
  • Duke Snider hit .309, with 42 home runs, a league-leading 136 RBI and a NL-best 126 runs scored.

Each of these two Dodgers got eight first-place votes (the Cubs Ernie Banks got six), with Campanella winning the total point count 226-221.

_________________________________

Bobby Shantz In the Lead

In 1952, the Athletics’ Bobby Shantz won the AL Most Valuable Player Award on the strength of a 24-7, 2.48 record … despite the Athletics’ 79-75 fourth place finish (or maybe because of it … the Athletics were 25-8 in games in which Shantz pitched and 54-67 when he didn’t take the mound). Shantz gets a shout out here because the next three finishers in the MVP balloting were all from the World Champion Yankees: Allie Reynolds, Mickey Mantle and Yogi Berra.

______________________________________

1945 – P Hal Newhouser, Tigers, MVP … 2B Eddie Mayo, Tigers, second

The 1945 World Champion  Tigers won the AL pennant with an 88-65-2 record, behind the big arm of Hal Newhouser.

  • Hal Newhouser led the AL with 25 wins (nine losses) and a 1.81 ERA. He also led in starts (36), complete games (29), shutouts (8); innings pitched (313 1/3) and strikeouts (212).
  • Tigers’ 2B Eddie Mayo hit .285-10-54, with 71 runs scored.

Although the statistics would seem to say otherwise, the vote was closer than you might expect, as Mayo was rewarded for sparkling defense, on-field leadership and solid offensive numbers for a middle infielder (at the time). Mayo got seven fist place votes to Newhouser’s nine – and was outscored 236-164 in the full voting.

_________________________________

1944 … P Hal Newhouser, Tigers, MVP… P Dizzy Trout, Tigers, second

The Tigers finished second in 1944 (88-66-2), despite having the number-one and two finishers in the MVP balloting – a pair of pitchers who combined for 56 wins.

  • Southpaw Hall Newhouser led the league with 29 wins (nine losses) and 187 strikeouts, while putting up a 2.22 ERA, 25 complete games and six shutouts.
  • Righty Dizzy Trout nearly matched Newhouser with 27 wins (14 losses) and led the league in ERA (2.12), complete games (33) shutouts (7) and innings pitched (314).

In 1944, Hal Newhouser and Dizzy Trout finished 1 & 2 in the AL (in varying order) in wins, ERA, innings pitched, strikeouts, complete games and shutouts.

In the balloting, Trout got 10 first-place votes to Newhouser’s seven, but lost out in the full ranked voting 236-232.

_________________________________________

1943 … OF Stan Musial, Cardinals, MVP … C Walker Cooper Cards, second

Stan Musial, in just his second full MLB season, captured his first batting crown and MVP Award as the Cardinals finished on top of the NL with a 105-9-3 record.

Side note: Sign of the times, the Cardinals had no batter with more than 13 home runs and no hitter with more than 81 RBI (Musial and Walker Cooper tied for the team lead). Still, they finished second in the NL in runs scored and home runs.  They also posted the league’s best earned run average (2.57) – more than a half run better than the second-best team.

  • Stan Musial led the league in average (.357), hits (220), doubles (48) and triples (20); while scoring 108 runs, hitting 13 home runs, driving in 81 and stealing nine bases.
  • Walker Cooper hit .318-9-81, with 52 runs scored – and caught the pitching staff that led the league in ERA.

Musial got 13 first-place votes and 267 ranked points to Cooper’s five and 192, respectively,

In the six seasons Between 1946 and 1951, Stan Musial finished in the top two in the NL MVP race five times. In those six campaigns, he averaged .349-28-112, with an season-average 122 runs scored, 40 doubles, 14 triples, 87 walks and just 34 strikeouts. Stan “The Man,” indeed.

_________________________________________

1942 – P Mort Cooper, Cardinals … OF Enos Slaughter, Cardinals, second

The World Champion Cardinals went 106-48-2 on the season , topping the league in run scored (755) and ERA (2.55). It seems appropriate that a Cardinals’  pitcher and batter would find their way to the top of the MVP balloting.

  • Mort Cooper had a solid season going 22-7, 1.78 (although, truth be told, the Cardinals’ Johnny Beasley was not far behind at 21-6, 2.13). Cooper also had 22 complete games and ten shutouts. Cooper led the NL in wins, ERA and shutouts.
  • Enos Slaughter led the Cardinals’ lineup in average (.318), RBI (98), home runs (13), runs scored 100, hits (188) and triples (17). He led the NL in hits and triples, was second in average and runs scored and third in runs batted.

Cooper got 13 first place votes and 263 points to Slaughter’s six first-place recognitions and 200 ranked points.

In 1942 Mort Cooper won the NL Most Valuable Award. A year later, his brother Walker Cooper nearly duplicated the feat – finishing second in the MVP voting to Stan Musial. 

_________________________________

1934 – C Mickey Cochrane, Tigers, MVP … 2B Charlie Gehringer, Tigers, second

The 1934 Tigers finished first in the AL with a 101-53 record – led by player-manager Mickey Cochrane (who was also the AL MVP). All Star second baseman Charlie Gehringer finished second in the balloting.

  • Mickey Cochrane played in 129 games and hit .320, with two home runs and 75 RBI, while also managing and, of course, handling backstop duties.
  • Gehringer hit .356-11-127, scored a league-leading 135 runs and posted an NL-best 214 hits.

Cochrane edged Gehringer 67 points to 65 in the voting.

Primary Resource: BaseballReference.com

 

100Baseball Roundtable is on the Feedspot list of the Top 100 Baseball Blogs.  To see the full list, click here.

I tweet baseball @DavidBBRT

Follow/Like Baseball Roundtable’s Facebook Page here.  More baseball commentary; blog post notifications; PRIZES.

Member: Society for American Baseball Research (SABR); Negro Leagues Baseball Museum; The Baseball Reliquary. 

 

 

 

Pre-Season Musings – “No-Out Wonders”

As Baseball Roundtable waits for the MLB  season to start in earnest, my mind tends to wander to all sorts of big-league achievement and oddities – iconic, ironic or just plain unusual baseball events. In my recent (March 18), Baseball Roundtable Tenth Anniversary post, I described ten of my favorites such MLB occurrences. (Click here for that post.) Today, I’d like to continue those off-beat musings – looking at 39 pitchers who took the MLB mound at least once in their career – and never retired a batter.  I ask that readers keep in mind that, despite their lack of success, all these hurlers belong to that elite group of athletes that actually made it to the major-league mound.

N0t Sure If This One Counts

This list can be expanded to a fabulous forty if you include Larry Yount, brother of Hall of Famer Robin Yount, who had arguably the shortest MLB career ever.  On September 15, 1971, Yount (with the Astros) was called to  the mound in the top of the ninth with Houston  trailing the Braves 4-1. He was slated to face LF Ralph Garr, 1B Hank Aaron and C Earl Williams. He faced none of them. Young had experienced a bit of an elbow twinge in the bullpen and, while warming up on the mound, it got worse.  The trainer came to bump and Yount was pulled from the game – officially registering an MLB pitching appearance, but without tossing a single pitch. Yount pitched two more minor-league seasons, but never made it to the MLB mound again.  (In seven minor-league seasons, Yount went 40-69, 4.56.)

So, let’s look at some of the 39 “No-Out Wondes.”

Twenty-nine of the 39 gave up at least one earned run, giving them an earned run average of infinity. 

Bill Childers of the 1895 Louisville Colonels and Elmer “Doc” Hamann of the 1922 Cleveland Indians gave up the most earned runs in their no-out MLB mound careers – six each.

Childers sole MLB appearance came on July 27, 1895. He was called on with one out in the top of the ninth, with his Louisville Colonels trailing the Baltimore Orioles 12-6.  Childers proceeded to face seven batters – giving up two hits and five walks (and tossing three wild pitches) before being relieved in a 22-6 Louisville loss.

One September 21, 1922, Hamann (with the Indians) was brought in to open the top of the ninth (versus the Red Sox), with the Indians trailing 9-5. In his six-earned-run outing, Hamann, like Childers, faced seven batters,Hamann gave up three hits, three walks and one hit-by-pitch. The final score of this one was Red Sox 15 – Indians five. (For Baseball Roundtable’s Minnesota readers, Hamann (a New Ulm native), played baseball and basketball for  St. Thomas College. Side note: This no-out outing proved to be not only Hamann’s only MLB appearance, but his only professional pitching appearance.

_________________________________________________

Five  of the 39 were position players called in to pitch.

The most famous of the position players who took the mound during their career without ever retiring a batter was Stan Musial. On September 28, 1952, Musial, already a five-time batting champion, was called in –  not from the bullpen, but from CF – with one out and one on  in the top of the first inning in a Cardinals/Cubs tilt in St. Louis. Cardinals’ starting pitcher Harvey Haddix  went from the mound to RF, with RF Hal Rice moving to center. Musial faced Cubs’ RF Fran Baumholtz (hitting .325 at the time – second only to Musial in the NL batting race). Stan the Man  almost pitched his way off this list.  Baumholtz put Musial’s first (and only) MLB pitch into play and “The Man” would have recorded an out, except for an error (on a groundball) by Cardinals’ 3B Solly Hemus.  After facing Baumholtz, Musial went back to CF, Haddix returned to the mound and Hal Rice went back to right.

If you’re wondering why Musial was called to the mound, it was kind of a “courtesy” call. Musial started his professional career as a pitcher – and , in fact, appeared only as a pitcher in his first two minor-league campaigns. (Shoulder issues eventually led him to give up moundwork – which turned out to not be a bad deal at all.) In three minor-league seasons, Musial went 33-13, 3.52.

Other MLB position players to make at least one mound appearance without retiring a batter include: OF Vic Davalillo; OF Gerardo Parra; OF Jose Roque, OF Billy Sunday and C/OF Dave Pierson.

_______________________________________________

Only one player has made two career mound appearances without recording a single out.

Vic Davalillo, who enjoyed a 16-season MLB career as an outfielder (1963-74, 1977-80), took the mound for the Cardinals twice in 1969, without retiring a batter – both times against the Mets. On June 30, he opened the top of the ninth with the Cardinals trailing the Mets 10-2. He gave up a walk to CF Tommie Agee and a single to 3B Bobby Pfeil, before being relieved by Chuck Taylor, who got out of the inning without a run scoring. Just three days later, Davalillo pinch hit for pitcher Ray Washburn in the top of eighth, with the Cardinals down to the Mets by a 7-0 score.  Davalillo lined out the end the frame and stayed in to pitch in the eighth. He again started with a walk to CF Tommie Agee and then gave up a run-scoring double to 2B Ken Boswell before being pulled.  Over his career, Davalillo was a one-time All  Star and a one-time Gold Glover. He had a career line of .279-36-329, with 12t stolen bases in 1,458 MLB games.

__________________________________________________

 

Fourteen of the 39 no-out wonders achieved this “goal” as starting pitchers.

Harry Heitmann’s (1918 Brooklyn Robins) only MLB appearance came in the second game of a double header on July 27, with his Brooklyn Robins facing the Cardinals in Brooklyn. Heitmann faced four batters and gave up four runs on four hits – without recording an out. It was the only MLB appearance for Heitmann, who was called up to Brooklyn after compiling a 17-6 record at Double A Rochester. He went on to pitch eight more minor-league seasons, winning 17 games for Rochester again in 1921, but never made it back to the big leagues.

________________________________________________

Only two of the no-out wonders surrendered a home run in their appearance.

Zack Weiss is the only pitcher on this list to give up two home runs in his no-out MLB pitching career. On April 12, 2018 – as his Reds faced the Cardinals in Cincinnati – Weiss came on in relief in the top of the seventh, with the Reds down by just one run (5-4).  Weiss gave up a home run on a 2-0 pitch to Cards’ 1B Jose Martinez.  Then, C Yadier Molina took a 2-0 pitch out 0f the park. Next, Weiss walked SS Paul DeJong on four pitcher and 2B Kolten Wong on five pitches before leaving the game.  Weiss is still active, so he can pitch his way off this list, but for now, he has thrown 15 MLB pitches – 12 balls and three strikes, with two of his three strikes going yard.

The only other no-out career pitcher to surrender a home run in his appearance is Dave Pierson, a catcher/outfielder pitched in one game for the 1876 Cincinnati Reds. It came in the bottom of the first inning (Pierson started the game), as his Reds faced the Louisville Colonels (May 18, 1876). Pierson faced two batters and gave up two hits – the second of which was an inside-the-park home run to Louisville 3B Bill Hague. The Reds lost that one 9-3 – and Pierson was tagged with the defeat.

______________________________________________________

Baseball Roundtable Extra – Relieved by a One-Legged Pitcher

Lots of players discussed here can boast of an earned run average of infinity, but what about measurable ERA? Well, the highest measurable ERA – which would be by a pitcher who recorded at least one MLB out – is 189.00, It belongs to the 1945 Washington Senators’ righty Joe Cleary – and he gets extra credit since, in his one and only MLB appearance, he was relieved by MLB’s only one-legged pitcher.  More on that in a minute.

Cleary was in his fifth pro season (1939, 1941-42, 1944-45, when he was called up to the Senators (in the pitching lean war years). On August 4, in the second game of a double header between the Senators and the Red Sox, Cleary made his MLB debut in the top of  fourth inning, with the Senators trailing 6-2, a runner on third base and one out. Clearly made his way once through the Red Sox lineup and it went like this:

  • RBI single by CF George Metkovich;
  • Walk to 1B Dolph Camilli;
  • RBI single by RF Pete Fox;
  • Walk to 2B Skeeter Newsome;
  • Two-run single by C Bob Garbark;
  • Strikeout by P Dave Ferris;
  • RBI single by SS Eddie Lake;
  • Walk to 3B Ty LaForest;
  • Three-run double by LF Tom McBride.

That brought Metkovich for the second time in the frame and brought Bert Shepard – the one-legged pitcher I mentioned earlier – to the mound. Shepard stuck out  Metkovich to end the inning.

Although Cleary pitched in five more minor-league seasons, he never made it back to the big leagues. As for Shepard, he pitched five more innings that day, giving up just one run on three hits. (Washington lost 15-4.)  Side note: Shepard lost part of his right leg (below the knew) when his P-38 fighter was shot down near Hamburg Germany in May of 1944.  He received the Distinguished Flying Cross, Air Medal and a Purple Heart.  For the story of how he made it to the big leagues on one leg, click  here.

Primary Resources:  Baseball-Reference.com; Retrosheet.org

 

100Baseball Roundtable is on the Feedspot list of the Top 100 Baseball Blogs.  To see the full list, click here.

I tweet baseball @DavidBBRT

Follow/Like Baseball Roundtable’s Facebook Page here.  More baseball commentary; blog post notifications; PRIZES.

Member: Society for American Baseball Research (SABR); Negro Leagues Baseball Museum; The Baseball Reliquary. 

 

Baseball Roundtable Celebrates Tenth Anniversary

In this tenth anniversary post, Baseball Roundtable will present some highlights from past posts, as well as the listings of The Roundtable’s ten favorite fiction and non-fiction baseball books.

Today (March 18), marks the tenth anniversary of  Baseball Roundtable.  Over that span, Baseball Roundtable has published 887 posts – covering baseball past, present and, occasionally, future – with a combination stats and stories,  observation and opinion (mine and the readers’).   On these pages, The Roundtable has launched:

  • The Annual John Paciorek Award – honoring players with brief, but in some way notable, baseball careers. For the latest JPA post – with a link to all the JPA offerings, click here.
  • The “Who’s Your Daddy?” Series – presenting position-by-position lineups of players who performed exceptionally well against some of the best pitchers of all time. For the latest “Who’s You Daddy?” post, which includes links to the entire series, click here.
  • The Baseball Roundtable Trot Index – tracking the percentage of plate appearances that result in a “trot” – around the bases (home run); back to the dugout (strikeout); or to first base (walk, hit by pitch, catcher’s interference.)
  • The annual Baseball Roundtable Unofficial Fan Hall of Famed Ballot, as well as fan surveys on the baseball experiences (time of game, concessions, etc.), proposed rule changes and the general state of the game.
  • Lists covering topics from Baseball Roundtables’ favorite baseball quotes, nicknames and baseball cards.

Baseball Roundtable has also offered month-by-month MLB season summaries – with team and individual stats, stories (highlights) and Baseball Roundtable’s Players, Pitchers and Surprise of the Month.  There have also been a host of predictions, trivia questions, book reviews – (and interviews with authors).  And, of course, there’s been plenty of musings about the national pastime  (that, as regular readers know, provide proof of Baseball Roundtable’s assertion that when I research a hardball topic “one thing always leads to another.”  Baseball Roundtable has also featured guest posts by former players; coaches; sportswriters; writers from such websites as LiftYourGame.net, CatcherHome.com; The BaseballReviews.com; OldSportCards.com; I70Baseball.com; and even an Emmy Award Winner.

So, to get this tenth anniversary post rolling, here are my ten favorite hardball tidbits (with a few “extras”) from past posts (not necessarily the ten best, just those that seem to have stuck with me over time.

NUMBER ONE. This story has been told often, but it remains The Roundtable’s favorite baseball coincidence. On May 2, 1954,  Stan “The Man” Musial had one of the greatest days at the plate in major-league history.  That day, the New York Giants faced Musial’s Cardinals in a double header before 26,662 fans at Busch Stadium (I). Game One, a 10-6 Cardinal win, saw Musial go four-for-four with three home runs (his first-ever three-homer game) and six RBI. In Game Two, a 9-7 Cardinals’ loss, Musial went two-for-four, with two home runs and three RBI – becoming the first player ever to hit five home runs in a doubleheader. 

Why is this event at the top of this list?  Well. among the 26,662 fans witnessing Musial’s feat was eight-year-old Nate Colbert – who, on August 1, 1972, would become the second player in MLB history (and there are still only two) to hit five round trippers in a double header. In Game One of that doubleheader (Padres at Braves), Colbert went four-for-five, with two home runs and five RBI, as the Padres won 9-0.   In Game Two, an 11-7 Padres’ win, Colbert went three-for-four with three home runs and eight RBI.  Stan Musial, however, was not in the crowd.  (Now, that would really have been a coincidence.)

NUMBER TWO. This one falls into Baseball Roundtable’s “iconic and ironic” list.  I’ve always been impressed by the fact that the first National League (any position) to hit two Grand Slams in a game was a pitcher – Tony Cloninger, who did it in a Braves 17-3 win over the Giants  on July 3, 1966.  Cloninger collected a pitchers’ record nine RBI in the game – and also threw a complete-game seven-hitter. This tidbit gets “extra credit”  when you add the fact that, after retiring from MLB, Cloninger became a world-class slow-pitch softball player. In 1978 (six years after his MLB retirement), playing  for the United States Slow-Pitch Softball Association’s Slow-Pitch World Series Champion Howard & Carroll team, Cloninger was selected as the third baseman on the Series All-World Team.  For trivia buffs, Cloninger used Denis Menke’s bat to hit that pair of Grand Slams.

Baseball Roundtable Tenth Anniversary Extra

On August 15, 1962, as the Philllies topped the Mets 9-3 in the first game of a twin bill, Phillies’ starting left fielder Don Demeter touched up starting pitcher right-hander Bob Miller (Robert Lane Miller) for a third-inning, solo home run. In the ninth frame, Demeter (who had now moved to CF) hit a three-run home run, this time off  left-handed reliever Bob Miller (Robert Gerald Miller). So, two home runs in one game off two Bob Millers, one southpaw and one righty, one starter and one reliever, while in the lineup at two different positions.

NUMBER THREE.  In 1961, the Orioles’ Jim Gentile  tied the MLB record and set a new AL mark (both since broken) for Grand Slams in a season with five bases-loaded long balls.  Every one of Gentile’s five four-run blasts was hit in a game started by  Orioles’ righty Chuck Estrada (who, as you would expect, picked up a victory in all four contests).  Added credit for the fact that Gentile hit only one other Grand Slam in his career (June 26, 1960) and – you guessed it – the starting and winning pitcher in that contest was Chuck Estrada – and for the fact that this was the first trivia question I ever posed on a Ballpark Tours trip.

Baseball Roundtable Tenth Anniversary Extra

In 1987, Yankees’ first baseman Don Mattingly set an MLB single-season record (since tied) with six Grand Slams. Despite a 14-season career that included 163 bases-loaded plate appearances, Mattingly did not hit another Grand Slam before or after those record-setting six.

NUMBER FOUR. On July 27, 1998, Tyrone Horne (Double-A Arkansas Travelers) became the first (and still only) professional ballplayer to hit for the “Home Run Cycle” – popping a solo, two-run, three-run and Grand Slam home run in one game (a 13-4 road win over the San Antonio Mission). Horne never made it to the major leagues, completing a 13-season minor-league career with a .288 average and 143 home runs.

NUMBER FIVE. On August 14, 1958, the Indians’ Vic Power tied an MLB record by stealing home an MLB record-tying  twice in one game – the second of which came in the bottom of the tenth inning, giving the Indians a “run-off” 10-9 win over the Tigers.  Why does this feat rank so high on my list?  Power stole only three bases during the entire 1958 season.

Baseball Roundtable Tenth Anniversary Extra

Babe Ruth had more inside -the-park home runs and more steals of home than Ricky Henderson.

NUMBER SIX.  Ron Wright played professional baseball from 1994-2004, but got only one game in the big leagues. As his Mariners took on the Rangers (in Texas) on April 14, 2002, Wright started at DH. That day he would see nine pitches in three plate appearance and be responsible for six outs. In his first plate appearance, he struck out on three pitchers, with two runners on base (second inning). He came up with two on again in the fourth and hit into a triple play on a 2-2 pitch (although there were some baserunning miscues that contributed …  the play went 1-6-2-5-1-4). Wright came up again in the sixth, again with two on, and hit the first pitch he saw into a traditional 6-4-3 double play. The Mariners pinch hit for Wright in the seventh – and he never appeared in a major league game again.

Baseball Roundtable Tenth Anniversary Extra

John Miller hit just two home runs in his MLB career – one for the Yankees in 1966 and one for the Dodgers in 1969.  Those blasts mad him one of just two MLB players to homer in their first and last MLB plate appearance. 

NUMBER SEVEN. Only five times in MLB history has a pitcher fanned 20 batters in nine innings  – Roger Clemens (twice); Kerry Woods; Max Scherzer; and Randy Johnson. (Johnson was the only non-complete game. He fanned twenty in nine innings, but was relieved by Byung-Hyun Kim in the top of the tenth with the score tied 1-1.) The tidbit that attracted me here is that is that in those five 20-strikeouts outings, these dominating pitchers did not walk a single batter. That’s right, 100 whiffs and not a single walk.

Baseball Roundtable Tenth Anniversary Extra

In 2021, Padre’s reliever Austin Adams led MLB in batters  hit-by-pitch with 24. The curveball here? He only pitched 52 2/3 innings – the fewest innings ever pitched in a season of 20 or more HBP.  To find the second-fewest, you have to go all the way back to Ed Doheny, who hit 22 batters in 1900 – in 133 2/3 innings pitched. Further, Adams’ 24 plunkings are the most since Jack Warhop’s 26 in 1909 (and he pitched 243 1/3 innings that season).

NUMBER EIGHT. The final score of the Yankees/Red Sox game on October 1, 1961 – when Roger Maris hit his historic 61st home run (breaking Babe Ruth’s long-standing single-season record) was 1-0.  Despite the chance to witness history, only 23,154 fans were in attendance –  just 34 percent of Yankee Stadium’s listed capacity at the time (67,337). That means, of course, about two of every three seats were empty.

Baseball Roundtable Tenth Anniversary Extra

Casey Stengel, while a member of the New York Giants, hit the first-ever inside-the-park and over-the-fence post-season home runs in Yankee Stadium, (Games One and Three of the 1923 World Series.)

NUMBER NINE.  On July 17, 1990, facing the Red Sox in Boston, the Minnesota Twins became the first (and still only) team to turn two triple plays in a single game. They came in the fourth and eighth and both were the purist triple killings possible – grounder to third (Gary Gaetti) for a force and then a relay to second (Al Newman), then on to first (Kent Hrbek).  What adds to this remembrance is that the very next day, the Twins turned six double plays, which gave them share of the AL record for double plays turned in single game –  and, add the four double plays turned by the Red Sox, and the Twins and Red Sox set the record for combined double plays in  a single game.

NUMBER TEN. In August of 1903, the Giants’ Joe McGinnity started both games of a double header three times (August 1, 8 and 31), pitched six complete games and won them all, giving up just ten runs.  What puts this on this list is, that same month, McGinnity pitched just one game on six other occasions – going 1-5 and giving up 28 runs. Apparently, he liked a full day’s work.

Baseball Roundtable Tenth Anniversary Extra

In 1946, the Boston Braves played a record 46 doubleheaders – including a record nine consecutive twin bills between September 4 and September 15.  In those doubleheaders, they recorded 42 wins, 48 losses and two ties.

___________________________________________________________

Baseball Roundtable’s  Big Surprise

Ten years ago, when I was searching for a domain name for this blog, I was surprised to find my first choice – baseballroundtable.com – was available. 

___________________________________________________________

Now, let move on to Baseball Roundtable’s list of favorite baseball books (baseball is, after all, the most literary of sports). Two things to keep in mind: 1) This is a subjective list. I do not maintain that thee are the “best” baseball books, but just (for various reasons) my favorites; 2) To qualify for this list, these books had to be on may “fan cave” bookshelves.

Non-Fiction

  1. The Baseball Encyclopedia (Macmillan) and ESPN Baseball Encyclopedia … A treasure trove of statistical information. I’ve spent (and still spend) more hours than I’d like to admit, pouring over these pages and pages of numbers. Open to any page and you’re likely to find something “new.” Sadly, the “newest” edition on my bookshelf is from 2008.
  2. The Glory of Their Times, by Lawrence S. Ritter … A look at the early day of bases through the eyes (and words) of those who played the game.
  3. Only the Ball was White, by Robert Peterson … A must read look at the Negro Leagues.
  4. The Summer of Bear and Whiskey, by Edward Achorn … A wild and wooly – and true – tale of baseball in the 1880s.
  5. Eddie Mathews and the National Pastime, by Eddie Mathews and Bob Buege … This book gets a spot in the top five since Ed Mathews is my all-time favorite player – and this read will tell you he was a pretty colorful bruiser and basher, with a great love of the game.
  6. The Baseball Maniac’s Almanac,  by Bert Sugar … Page upon page of all-time baseball trivia and tidbits.  Want to know which brothers played together as MLB double play combinations, which players hit World Series home runs for three different teams or see a list of MLB pitchers who have stolen home (there are more than you’d think)? It’s all here (and more).
  7. The Baseball 100, by Joe Posnanski … An entertaining and informative look at Posnanski’s 10o greatest players – full of fun stories, fascinating facts and a feel for the game and those who played it.  Sure to move up my list as I spend more time with this recent edition to my library.
  8. Ball Four,  by Jim Bouton … A first glimpse into the MLB club house that really needs no explanation.
  9. Baseball Nicknames – A Dictionary of Origins and Meanings, by Jakes K. Skipper, Jr. … A fun look at what’s behind more than 4,000 baseball nicknames. Where else can you learn why Lou Gehrig was once known as “Biscuit Pants” or how “Sparky” Anderson got his nickname. Indexed by player’s last name, as well as by nicknames, for easy reference.
  10. Catcher in the Wry, by Bob Uecker … Great entertainment from a truly funny former major leaguer.

There are, of course, dozens upon dozens of worthwhile baseball reads like: 24, Life and Stories from the Say Hey Kid; Satchel, the Life and Times of a Legend; Why Time Begins on Opening Day; Veeck as in Wreck; and I could go on and on (but I had to pick just ten).  Also, I’d be remiss if I didn’t mention another go to book for Baseball Roundtable, The Elias Book of Baseball Records.

Fiction

  1. The Great American Novel, by Philip Roth … The story of the Ruppert Mundys … a 1940’s team of shallow skills and deep neurosis, that (due to wartime circumstances) played the an entire season on the road. Hard to describe … Fun to read.
  2. If I Never Get Back, by Darryl Brock … A modern player steps off a train and into 1869, where he joins up with the Cincinnati Red Stockings.
  3. Bang the Drum Slowly, by Mark Harris … A heart-tugging baseball story (and a pretty good movie, too).
  4. The Natural, by Bernard Malamud … Darker than the movie, but the story of Roy Hobbs is compelling.
  5. Shoeless Joe, by W.P. Kinsella … “If you build it, he will come.” Nothing more needs to be said.
  6. Home Game, by Paul Quarrington … A combination of humor and compassion, Home Game is the story of a down-on-his-luck former major leaguer who is drawn into a conflict between a group of circus sideshow performers  and a conservative religious sect … that ends in a high-stakes baseball game between the two factions.
  7. The Iowa baseball Confederacy, by W.P. Kinsella … In 1908, the Chicago Cubs traveled to Onamata, Iowa to play a game against an amateur quad (made of of players from Iowa Baseball Confederacy) – a game that turned into a 2,000 inning contest. Or so the tale goes. Unfortunately,  no one believes the story and there is no real evidence to support it. Decades later – in attempt to document the event  – two friends travel back in time.
  8. The Universal Baseball Association, Inc. J. Henry Waugh, Proprietor, by Robert Coover … When fantasy baseball runs amok.
  9. The Art of Fielding, by Chad Harbach … A novel  about ambition, commitment, friendship, love and baseball- centered round how an errant throw changes the life of star college shortstop Henry Skrimshander.
  10. Brittle Innings,  by Michael Bishop … A strange, but enjoyable, tale that finds the Frankenstein monster playing  minor-league baseball in the 1940s

Hope you enjoyed this Tenth Anniversary post.

Primary Resources:  Baseball-Reference.com; Baseball-Almanac.com; MLB.com, The Elias Book of Baseball Records.

 

100Baseball Roundtable is on the Feedspot list of the Top 100 Baseball Blogs.  To see the full list, click here.

I tweet baseball @DavidBBRT

Follow/Like Baseball Roundtable’s Facebook Page here.  More baseball commentary; blog post notifications; PRIZES.

Member: Society for American Baseball Research (SABR); Negro Leagues Baseball Museum; The Baseball Reliquary. 

 

Remember that Time When … Andy Hawkins Lost the Same No-Hitter TWICE

Passing time browsing Baseball-Reference.com while I wait for the owners and players to come to their senses, I ran across an interesting boxscore – Andy Hawkins’ 1990 no-hitter, which he lost 4-0 and then later lost … Oops, getting ahead of the story here.

Andy Hawkins’ Double-Lost No-Hitter

As Yankees’ righthander Andy Hawkins took the mound on July 1, 1990, the fans may not have expected a victory and almost certainly would not have been expecting a no-hitter.  Yet, Hawkins – who brought a 4-9 record (13 games/12 starts) and  a 6.40 earned run average into the game – would get (temporarily) the least expected of the two.

The game was being played in Chicago and Hawkins’ mound opponent was southpaw Greg Hibbard, who was 8-6, 2.49 at the time. After seven  frames the game was knotted at 0-0, and Hawkins had given up no hits, while walking two and fanning three. Hibbard had also tossed seven scoreless innings (four hits, no walks, four whiffs).

Barry Jones came to the mound for the ChiSox in the top of the eighth and held the Yankees without a run.  In the bottom of the eighth, the baseball Gods began to “mess with” Hawkins’ game.  It started out fine, with ChiSox catcher Ron Karkovice and 2B Scott Fletcher both going down on infield pop ups.  Then, RF Sammy Sosa  (batting in the eight-hole) reached first on an error by Yankee third baseman Mike Blowers (a bobbled ground ball). Hawkins followed by walking SS Ozzie Guillen on a 3-2 pitch and then issuing a four-pitch walk to CF Lance Johnson. Sacks full, but shutout, no-hitter and the chance of a much-needed win still intact. Next up was 3B Robin Ventura,  who hit a playable flyball to rookie Jim Leyritz in LF. The ball clanked off Leyritz’ glove for an error and – with the runners moving (two outs) – all three  scored (Ventura ended up on second).  Next up was DH Ivan Calderon, who hit a fly to RF that Jesse Barfield lost in the sun and dropped (another error) enabling the fourth run of the inning to score.  Hawkins then retired LF Dan Pasqua to end the inning.

The Yankees went scoreless off reliever Scott Radinsky in the top of the ninth, ending the game. At that moment, Andy Hawkins had a complete-game, no-hitter, 4-0 loss. Little did Hawkins know; he was going to lose this no-hitter a second time.

In September of the following season (1991), MLB ruled that official no-hitters had to be at least nine innings.  Since the White Sox had not batted in the bottom of the ninth, Hawkins, despite the complete game, no longer had an official no-hitter.

It Was That Kind Of Season

In Andy Hawkins’ next start, just five days after his July 1, 1990 no-hit loss, Hawkins carried a NO-HIT, shutout into the twelfth inning (against the Twins in New York).  Unfortunately, the Twins’ Allan Anderson and Juan Berenguer held the Bombers scoreless (despite ten hits).  The Twins got to Hawkins for two runs (two walk and two hits) in the twelfth and Rick Aguilera set down the Yankees without a run in the bottom of the inning. So, 11 no-hit innings for Hawkins and the end result was another loss.  That gave Hawkins a streak of 19 consecutive hitless innings over the two games – with two losses to show for it. 

Hawkins finished 1990 at 5-12, 5.37. Hawkins pitched in 10 MLB seasons (1982-91 … Padres, Yankees, A’s), going 84-91, 4.22. His best season was 1985, when he went 18-8. 3.15.

_______________________________________

Looking into Hawkins’ lost (in more ways than one) no-hitter, set me to looking for other unusual no-hitter outings.

A.J. Burnett …  A Walk on the Wild Side

In A.J. Burnett’s May 12, 2001 no-hitter for the Marlins, a 3-1 win over the Padres, every starting position player for the Padres reached base at least once.   (Burnett walked nine and hit one batter).  Burnett’s nine walks are the most ever in a nine-inning, one-pitcher no-hitter. Burnett threw 65 strikes and 64 balls in the game – his 50.4 percent strike-to-ball ratio is the worst ever in a no-hitter.

His game looked like this:

  • First inning – One (four-pitch) walk, one left on base.
  • Second inning- Two walks (both on 3-2 pitches), one left on base.
  • Third inning – Two walks (on  3-1 and 3-2 counts), one wild pitch, two left on base.
  • Fourth inning – One walk (3-1 pitch), one hit by pitch (3-2 count), two left on base.
  • Fifth inning – Three up, three down.
  • Sixth inning – Three up, three down.
  • Seventh inning – One walk (four-pitch), one left on base.
  • Eighth inning – Two walks (on four-pitch, one on a 3-2 count), two left on base.
  • Ninth inning – Three up, three down.

A.J. Burnet pitched in 17 MLB seasons (1999-2015 … Marlins, Blue Jays, Yankees, Pirates, Phillies), going 164-157, 3.99. He won ten or more games in 11 seasons (a high of 18 for the Blue Jays in 2008).

A First for A.J.

A.J. Burnett made his first All Star team in his final MLB season (at age 38 in 2015). He was 2-4, 2.53, for the Pirates, at the All Star break.  He went 7-3, 3.89 the rest of the way. 

Ken Johnson … How About a Little Help from My Friends?

On April 23, 1964, the Houston Colt .45s’ Ken Johnson had held the Reds hitless through eight innings (in Houston) – walking two and fanning nine. However, the Reds’ Joe Nuxhall also had a shutout going, although he had given up five hits.   A couple of errors in the ninth cost Johnson the game – but not the no-hitter.  In the top of the ninth, Nuxhall led off against Johnson and grounded out (third-to-first). The next batter, 2B Pete Rose, attempted to end the no-no with a bunt to the third base side of the infield.  Johnson fielded the bunt, but threw wildly toward first base.  Rose ended up on second (a two-base error). Chico Ruiz followed up with a line drive off Johnson that was fielded by 3B Bob Aspromonte, who threw Ruiz out at first (with Rose going to third). Next up was Reds’ CF Vada Pinson, who was safe on an error by Houston 2B Nellie Fox (Rose scoring). Johnson then retired RF Frank Robinson on a routine fly to left.  The no-hitter was intact, but the damage was done – one unearned run. Nuxhall  held the Colt .45s scoreless in the bottom of the inning and Johnson had MLB’s only complete-game, official no-hitter loss.

Edwin Jackson – Who’s Counting?

On June 25, 2010,  the Diamondbacks’ Edwin Jackson got off to a wild start against the Rays.  Jackson’s pitch count was up to 70 after just three innings – during which he gave up seven walks, threw one wild pitch and fanned two.  He settled down after that – walking just one more batter, fanning four more and holding the Rays hitless.  Jackson threw 149 pitches, the most ever in a no-hitter, as the Diamondbacks prevailed 1-0.

Jackson pitched in 17 MLB seasons (2003-2019 … Dodgers, Rays, Tigers, Diamondbacks, White Sox, Cardinals, Nationals, Cubs, Braves, Marlins, Padres, Orioles, A’s, Blue Jays).  His career MLB stat line was 107-133, 4.78.

I’m a Travelin’ Man

Edwin Jackson pitched at the major-league level for more teams (14) than any other player in MLB history. In the five seasons between 2009 and 2013, he pitched for six different MLB teams (Tigers, Diamondbacks, White Sox, Cardinals, Nationals, Cubs).  He pitched for two MLB teams in six of his 17 MLB campaigns. 

Steve Barber – One for the Books

The most walks in a no-hitter by one pitcher is ten by Steve Barber in a combined no hitter.  Barber took a no-hitter, albeit with seven walks, and a 1-0 lead into the top of the ninth as his Orioles played the Tigers in Detroit on April 30, 1967.  Barber walked the first two batters in the final inning. Then a sacrifice moved them to second and third.  A wild pitch followed, plating the tying run.  Barber walked the next hitter, and was relieved by Stu Miller. Miller finished up the no-hitter, but the go-ahead run scored on an error, giving the Tigers a 2-1 win without the benefit of a hit.

Barber enjoyed a 15-season MLB career (1960-74 … Orioles, Yankees, Pilots, Cubs, Braves, Angels., Giants), going 121-106, 3.36. He was a two-time All Star and a 20-game winner (20-13, 2.75) in 1963 (Orioles).

Jim Maloney …  You Win Some, You Lose Some (not necessarily in that order) … or a Very Larry Tale

On June 14, 1965, the Reds’ Jim Maloney held the New York Mets hitless for ten innings (in Cincinatti) – walking one and fanning 17.  Unfortunately, the Mets’ Frank Lary and Larry Bearnarth held the the Reds scoreless through ten frames (on six hits).  Mets’ RF J0hnny Lewis led off the tenth with a home run off Maloney, the Reds did not score in the bottom of the inning and all Maloney had to show for his effort was a loss.

Maloney, however, was not to be denied a 1965 no-hitter. On August 19, he held the Cubs hitless over the first nine innings (in Chicago). The Cubs’ Larry Jackson, however, had matched him zero-for-zero … in what was a wild game, at least for Maloney.  As they went into the tenth, Maloney had walked nine, hit one batter and fanned 12, while Jackson had surrendered seven hits, walked none and fanned five. Reds” SS and number-eight hitter Leo Cardenas touched Jackson for a solo home run in the top of tenth and Maloney walked one and then got a fly out and a 6-4-3 double play to end the game and  get the no-phit victory.  Side note: In  his very first start of the 1965 season (April 19 at Milwaukee), Maloney had taken a no-hitter into the eighth, only to have it broken up a a Denis Menke single (the only hit of the game for the Braves). 

Maloney pitched in a dozen MLB seasons (1970-71 … Reds, Angels), going 134-84, 3.19. He won 15 or more games six times and was twice a 20-game winner (23-7, 2.77 for the 1963 Reds and 20-9, 2.54 for the 1965 Reds).

Johnny Vander Meer … Working Hard to Finish

Most fans know that Johnny Vander Meer is the only MLB pitcher to toss consecutive no-hitters (June 11 and 15, 1938 – in the 23-year-old southpaw’s second MLB season). But, were you aware of the wild finish to the second no-no?  On June 15, facing the Dodgers in Brooklyn, the Reds’ Vander Meer took a no hitter and a 6-0 lead into the ninth inning.  At this point, he had walked five and fanned seven. He got the first batter of the frame,  Buddy Hassett, on a weak grounder to the mound.  Then things got a little wild – as he walked the bases loaded (C Babe Phelps, 3B Cookie Lavagetto and 1B Dolph Camilli). Next up was CF Ernie Koy, who hit a grounder to third that resulted in a force out at the plate.  Sacks still full, with the shutout and no-hitter intact. SS Leo Durocher was up next and Vander Meer got him a fly out to center.

Vander Meer pitched in 13 MLB seasons (1937-43, 1946-51 … losing two prime years to military service).  He pitched for the Reds, Cubs and Indians.  Vander Meer was a four-time All Star (all before his military years) and won 15 or more games in five seasons. He led the National League in strikeouts in each of the three seasons before his military break. Vander Meer’s final MLB stat line was 119-121, 3.44.

This One May Top Them All … Especially if You Like Pitchers’ Duels

On May 2, 1917, the Cubs faced the Reds in Chicago – with Fred Toney (4-1, 1.88) starting for the Reds and Jim “Hippo” Vaughn  (3-1, 2.25) on the mound for the Cubs. (Side note: In 1917, the MLB overall earned run average was 2.68. ) At the end of nine frames, the game was scoreless and the fans had yet to witness a hit by either team. There had been only five base runners in the game (four walks and one safe on an error ). In fact, only seven  batted balls had even reached the outfield. In the top of the tenth, the Reds broke through, scoring a run on two singles and an error. Toney held firm in the bottom of the inning, recording a 1-2-3 frame (two strikeouts) and putting a no-hitter into the record books. Toney finished the season at 24-16, 2.20 (and had a career line of 139-102, 2.69 in 12 seasons); while Vaughn went 23-13, 2.01 in 1917 and 178-137, 2.49 in 13 MLB seasons. 

Primary Resources:  Baseball-Reference.com; Baseball-Almanac.com

 

100Baseball Roundtable is on the Feedspot list of the Top 100 Baseball Blogs.  To see the full list, click here.

I tweet baseball @DavidBBRT

Follow/Like Baseball Roundtable’s Facebook Page here.  More baseball commentary; blog post notifications; PRIZES.

Member: Society for American Baseball Research (SABR); Negro Leagues Baseball Museum; The Baseball Reliquary. 

 

Willie, Mickey and the Duke … With a Side Trip on the Bill(s)

The outlook isn’t brilliant for baseball fans today,

As owner and players squabble, we can only look on in dismay.

It seems they are willing to take our game away.

And keep us in suspense about “When is Opening Day?”

 

When can we have a hot dog and a vendor-delivered beer?

When can we salute our favorites with a loud and lengthy cheer?

When will there be double plays, stolen bases and home runs?

When will the players and owners see it’s a game and should be fun?

 

We don’t know when will there be scorecards, so carefully filled in.

Or when we can gasp at a fastball near a batter’s chin.

Or when can we view that most welcome sight of all;

An umpire pointing at the mound and shouting the words “Play Ball.”

 

So, as the financial squabbling  seem to drag on and on, 

We can only think fondly of baseball days bygone.

So, here in Baseball Roundtable, as the baseball lockout lasts,

We’ll entertain ourselves with memories of baseball from the past. 

______________________________________

Spoiler Alert – A Tale of Two Bills and a Duke

Duke Snider faced hard-throwing Bill Pierro just five times in his career and never made an out. In fact, he hit for the cycle against Pierro (plus a walk).  On the other side of the coin,  Snider faced Bill Henry five times in his career and all Snider had to show for it were four strikeouts and a groundout.

That Bill Pierro and Bill Henry made their way onto this page is another example of “how one thing always seems to  lead  to another” when researching for Baseball Roundtable topic.   Normally, at this time of year, I would be busy putting together predictions for the upcoming season.  However, with so many free agents still out there and the start date for the 2022 season delayed and  “up in the air,”  that seems a bit premature.  So, I find myself  searching for topics that might provide some fan entertainment during the  owners/players squabble. In my search, I came across an old Baseball Digest article in which Mickey Mantle name Dick Radatz as the toughest pitcher he ever faced. (Notably, I also came across instances were Mantle put Sandy Koufax and Herb Score on that list.) The lyrics to “Talkin’ Baseball” also came up as I searched for Mantle quotes – and that led me to consider a post on which pitchers were toughest on “Willie, Mickey and the Duke.”  In the Duke Snider portion of that research, I was distracted by the tales of Bill Pierro and Bill Henry (versus Duke Snider) – which I would like to share before I get to the Willie, Mickey and the Dule portion of this post.

___________________________________________________

A Baseball Double Bill

Bill Pierro, was a hard throwing 6’1”, 155-pound right-hander signed by the Pirates in 1947. He quickly became one of the Pirates’ top pitching prospects. Pierro went 8-9. 4.30 with the Class-D Bartlesville Oilers of the Kansas-Oklahoma-Missouri League in his first pro-season (1947).  The 21-year-old then went 17-8, 2.15, reportedly fanning 300 in 230 innings, for Bartlesville in 1948. The following year, he was promoted to the Class-B (Big State League) Waco Pirates, where he went 18-11, 2.96 and fanned 275 hitters in 255 innings. (There were some cautionary signs.  In addition to the 275 whiffs, he walked 126 batters and hit 16.) Pierro  started 1950 with the Double-A Indianapolis Indians and was 8-3,  2.60 when the Pirates called him up. With Pittsburgh, Pierro went 0-2, 10.55 in 12 appearances (three starts) – walking 28 batters in 29 innings.   MLB never got to see if Pierro could harness his command and deliver on his early promise, In 1951, he  contracted encephalitis, which nearly ended his life and did end his pitching career.

Cycling the Pierro/Snider story. Duke Snider faced Bill Pierro just five times in his career – all between July 22 and September 19, 1950. In a span of three games and 13 pitches, Snider hit for the cycle against Pierro –  collecting  a single, double, triple, home run and walk. On July 22, with Pierro starting against the  Dodgers in Pittsburgh, Snider walked on a 3-1 pitch in the first and singled (on a 1-0 pitch) in the third inning. Exactly one month later, on August 22, Pierro came on in relief (third inning) against the Dodgers (again in Pittsburgh).  In the fourth, Snider hit Pierro’s first pitch to him for an RBI triple. Then, on September 9, Pierro  again came on in relief against the Dodgers, this time in Brooklyn. Pierro relieved Vern Law in the top of the second, with the Dodgers up 6-1, no outs and runners on first and third.  The first batter he faced? You guessed it. Duke Snider. Snider hit  his first offering for a two-run double. With Dodgers up 10-2, Pierro was still around when Snider led off the bottom of the fourth – with a solo home run on a 2-1 pitch – and the cycle against Pierro was complete. (Snider never faced Pierro again.) Side note: If you eliminate that first at-bat walk, Snider actually completed the cycle against Pierro in eight pitches.

Putting a Good Swing on the Bill Henry Story. The other Bill provides The Roundtable with a totally different (and much longer) story. Bill Henry did not show the early potential of Bill Pierro.  Toiling in the minors he went 44-52 over his first four seasons (1948-52). Still, he made his MLB debut on April 17,  1952. From 1952 through 1956, he bounced between the major and minors (Red Sox), appearing in 75 MLB games and 68  minor-league contests. Then, in January 1957, the 30-year-old was traded from the Red Sox to the Cubs and his perseverance began to pay off. In 1957, he went 14-6 as a starter for the  Double-A Memphis Chicksaws. In 1958, the Cubs converted him to a reliever – and opportunity came knocking in a big way. That season, Henry went 5-3, 3.60 for the Triple-A Portland Beavers (17 games/two starts) and 5-4, 2.88, with six saves for the Cubs. In 1959, at age 31, Henry played his first full season in the majors (Cubs), going 9-8, 2.68, with 12 saves, while appearing in a league-leading 65 games.  (I warned you this was a long story.) The conversion to reliever worked well. From his age-30 season forward, Henry made 452 MLB mound appearances (just two starts).  Ultimately,  Henry enjoyed  a 16-season MLB career (1953-55, 1958-69 … Red Sox, Cubs, Reds, Giants, Pirates Astros), pitching in the majors until he was 41-years-old. He went 46-50, 3.26, with 90 saves  in 527 appearances. He made one All Star Team (1960).

Now, we FINALLY get to why Henry is in this post.  Duke Snider’s record against Bill Henry was kind of the opposite of how he fared against Bill Pierro. Snider faced Henry five times in his career (five games over three seasons … 1959, 1961, 1963). Those five at bats resulted in one infield groundout and four strikeouts. Henry, by the way,  put up some solid  numbers against an impressive lineup of future Hall of Famers.  Just a few examples; Frank Robinson (a .059 average in 17 at bats); Stan Musial (.167 in 18 at bats); Roberto Clemente (.154 in 13 at bats); Yogi Berri (.091 in 11 at bats); Eddie Mathews (.188 om 32 at bats).

_____________________________________________________

Now, on to Willie Mickey and the Duke … and the Pitcher Who Were Tough on Them

Willie Mays

When looking pitchers Willie Mays found particularly tough, I came across a YouTube video (posted by Joe McNamara) in which Mays lists some of the usual suspects 0 Don Drysdale, Sandy Koufax and Bob Gibson – but also drop in a surprise in the form of Bob Rush.

Looking at the numbers, Mays did well against Don Drysdale – .330-13-30 in 60 games.  Sandy Koufax was a bit tougher on Mays – .278-5-14 in 43 games. Bob Gibson, however, truly earned his spot at the top of Mays’ list, holding him to a .196 average and fanning in him in 30 of 108 plate appearances (27.8 percent).  Mays bit over .250 against Gibson in just three of the 143 seasons he faced him,

As for the surprise from Mays’ interview, Bob Rush.  Rush faced Mays between 1951 and 1960, some of Mays’ most productive seasons. In those nine seasons (1953 lost to military service), Mays hit .317-279-812, was the Rookie of the Year (1951), the NL MVP (1954) and an All Star seven times. Rush held him to a .244 average and struck him out 18 times (to nine walks) in 36 games.

Bob Rush pitched 13 MLB seasons (1948-60, primarily with the Cubs). He went 127-152, 3.65. The two-time All Star won 13 or more games in five season.

Tom Sturdivant faced Mays between 1961 And 1964 –  again, some of Mays’  prime years (he was an All Star all four seasons and hit .307-174, 478 over that span. Sturdivant held Mays to a .105 average and did not give up an extra-base hit to Mays, fanning him five times and walking him just once.Sturdivant pitched in 10 MLB seasons (1955-64 … Yankees, Athletics, Red Sox, Senators, Pirates, Tigers, Mets). He went 59-51, 3.74, with 17 saves in 335 appearances (101 starts). His best season were as a Yankee.  In 1956, he went 16-8, 3.30 for New York and in 1957, he went 16-6, 2.54 for the Bombers.

Steve Arlin and Bill Singer also did well against Mays, but their appearances against him came later in Mays’ career.

Arlin  faced Mays 28 times between 1971 and 1973 (the final three years of Mays career), holding him to a .125 average and fanning him ten times in 28 plate appearances. Singer faced Mays in 17 games between 1966-71, holding him to a .171 average and notching 14 whiffs versus Mays (with just four walks).

Arlin had a six season MLB career (1969-74), during which he went 34-67, 4.33.   Bill Singer pitched in 14 MLB seasons (1964-77… Dodgers, Angels, Rangers, Twins, Blue Jays.) The two-time All Star went 188-127, 3.39 and was twice a 20-game winner.

In two of the seasons Steve Arlin faced Willie Mays, Arlin led the NL in losses (9-19, 3.48 for the 1981 Padres and 10-21, 3.60 for the 1972 Padres).  In those  two seasons, he held Mays to two hits in 20 at bats.

Of course, it wouldn’t be fair to not  at least mention a few pitchers that Mays raked. For example, he hit .632-2-7 against Danny McDevitt in 19 games (Mays’ highest average against any pitcher he faced at least 25 times) and .500-6-18 against Jay Hook in 17 contests.  And, as the chart below shows, He also handled Warren Spahn pretty well. His 18 home runs and 40 RBI against Spahn are Mays most against any pitcher and his 68 hits are second only to his 75 safeties verse Don Drysdale.

Willie Mays first-ever major league hit was a home run off Warren Spahn.

_______________________________________________________

Mickey Mantle

Looking Mickey Mantle, I came across an old Baseball Digest article in which he noted just how tough Dick Radatz was on him – and the numbers back up that assessment. Radatz faced Mantle 19 times between 1962 and 1966 and fanned him in twelve (63.2 percent) of the plate appearances.

In 1962, when MIckey Mantle went .321-30-89 and was the AL MVP,   rookie righty Dick Radatz face him six times. The result? Five strikeouts and a walk.

Radatz, at 6.6’, 230-pounds, was an imposing presence on the mound (and could bring the high heat). In a seven-season MLB career (1962-67, 1969 … Red Sox, Indians, Cubs, Tigers, Expos), Radatz made 381 appearances (all in relief) and went 52-43, 3.13 with 120 saves. The two-time All Star led the AL in saves as a rookie in 1962 and again in 1964.

There are few other pitchers who could make Mantle’s toughest list (at least the stats would seem to indicate that.)

Luis Tiant held Mantle to a .111 average (the lowest for Mantle against any pitcher he faced at least 25 times) and struck Mantle out in ten of thirty plate appearances.

Then, there’s: Saul Rogovin, who faced Mantle early in his career (1951-55) and held him to a .150 average and no extra base hits in 15 games; Jack Urban, who faced Mantle in 1957-58 and held him to a . 143 average with no extra-base hits in ten games; and finally, Joe Sparma who face Mantle from 1964 to 1968  and held him to a .162 average in 14 games (and struck Mantle out in 30 percent to his plate appearances).

Rogovin went 48-48 in eight MLB seasons (1949-53, 1955-57 … Tigers, White Sox, Orioles, Phillies). He won ten or more games in three seasons (a career-best 14-9 for the 1952 White Sox) and led the AL in ERA in 1951 at 2.78. Urban pitched in just three MLB seasons (1957-59 … Athletics, Cardinals), going 15-15, 4.83. Sparma pitched in seven MLB seasons (1964-70 … Tigers, Expos). Primarily a starter, he went 52-52, 3.94. In 1967, he was 16-9, 3.76 for the Tigers.

It wouldn’t be fair to not take a look at a couple of pitcher Mantle did well against. Conder longtime White Sox ace Billy Pierce. Mangle got more career hits, doubles, triples and RBI versus Pierce than against any other pitcher.

Pierce pitched 18 MLB seasons (1945, 1948-64 … Tigers, White Sox, Giants). He was a seven-time All Star and a two-time 20-game winner.  He final stat line was 211-169, 3.27 and he led the AL in wins once, ERA once, strikeouts once and complete games three times.

Mantle also hit .500 (25-for-50), with five homers and 21 RBI in 32 games  against Hank Aguirre. Aguirre had a 16-season MLB career (1955-70 … Indians, Tigers, Dodgers, Cubs). He went 75-72, 3.25, with 33 saves.  In 1965, he made his only All Star team, while going 16-8 and leading the AL with a 2.21 ERA. That season, he started 22 games (completing 11) and relieved in 20 contests.  For his career he had 149 starts in 447 appearances.

_________________________________________________

Duke Snider

Looking into Duke Snider, the name Juan Marichal kept emerging when he was asked about the toughest pitchers he ever faced, along with Bob Gibson. Not a bad pair  to start with. Gibson did hold Snider to a .212-3-5 line in 12 games, but Marichal was even tougher on the Duke.

Baseball Roundtable would add a couple of other pitchers to the “tough on the Duke” list, starting with Harvey Haddix, who held Snider to a .158 average over 15 games and fanned him in 34.1 percent of his plate appearances. In 1954, when Snider hit .341-40-130, Haddix faced him 12 times in three starts – and fanned him six times (giving up a lone single and two walks in 12 plate appearances).

Harvey Haddix pitched in 14 MLB seasons (1952-65 … Cardinals, Phillies, Reds, Pirates, Orioles), going 136-113, 3.63.  He was a three-time All Star and won ten or more games in nine seasons (a high of 20 in 1953, when he went 20-9, 3.06 and led the NL with six shutouts among his 19 complete games_.

Luis Arroyo also handled Snider pretty well, holding him to a .125 average in 10 games and fanning him in nine of 16 plate appearances between 1955 and 1957.

It wouldn’t be fair not to list at least a couple of hurlers that Snider took the measure of, like Warren Hacker, whom Snider  hit for a .363 average, with ten home runs and 15 RBI in 40 games. Hacker had a 12-season MLB career (1948-58, 1961 … Cubs, Reds, Phillies), going 62-89, 4.21, with 17 saves (306 appearances/157 starts). Then, there’s Hall of Famer Robin Roberts, whom Snider touched for a .295 average, with 19 home runs and 50 RBI in 73 games (the most RBI and home runs he had against  any pitcher. (Also, the most home runs and RBI Roberts gave up to any hitter.)

Duke Snider Face Robin Roberts in 14 MLB seasons. Over the first three, he hit .178, with three home runs and three RBI in 14 games.  Over the next 11, he hit .321-16-47 in 59 games.

Primary Resource: Baseball-Reference.com

Coming Soon:  More Lockout Reading – How Andy Hawkins Lost the Same No Hitter … Twice – and other wild no-hitter stories.

100Baseball Roundtable is on the Feedspot list of the Top 100 Baseball Blogs.  To see the full list, click here.

I tweet baseball @DavidBBRT

Follow/Like Baseball Roundtable’s Facebook Page here.  More baseball commentary; blog post notifications; PRIZES.

Member: Society for American Baseball Research (SABR); Negro Leagues Baseball Museum; The Baseball Reliquary. 

 

A Little “Relief” from the CBA Banter – Baseball Roundtable Look at Unique Relief Performances

Want a little relief from all the Collective Bargaining Agreement banter?  How about a look at some of the best – or most unique – relief pitching accomplishments/events?   That’s one way Baseball Roundtable is passing the time, while I wait to see if – and when – players take the field in 2022.

Greatest Relief Performance Ever

Ernie Shore – Photo: Library of Congress. Harris & Ewing Collection

When talking about great relief performances, the first that usually comes to mind first is Ernie Shore’s relief outing (taking over for Babe Ruth) on June 23, 1917. Ruth, carrying a 12-4, 2.35 record (with 14 complete games in 16 starts) started on the hill for the Red Sox (in Boston.) against the Senators.  Ruth, however, did not last long. He walked Senators’ lead-off batter 2B Ray Morgan and, to put it mildly, did not agree with umpire Brick Owens’ strike zone. An argument and melee ensued during which landed a punch to the side of Owens’ head. Ruth was tossed after the one batter (and later fined $100 and suspended for ten games).

In came Ernie Shore (8-7, 2.63, with nine complete games in 18 starts). Along with Shore came catcher Sam Agnew, replacing starting backstop Pinch Thomas.  The Agnew-for-Thomas switch paid off quickly. Morgan attempted to steal second and was gunned down by Agnew.  Shore went on to prove himself masterful in relief, retiring the next 26 batters in order, completing a perfect outing that – due to that opening walk by Ruth – is now on the books as a combined no-hitter. The Red Sox topped the Senators 4-0.

Shore ended the season 13-10, 2.22 – with 27 starts and just two relief appearances. Ruth finished the year, 24-13, 2.01, with a league-leading 35 complete games. Shore played six MLB seasons (1912, 1914-17 and 1919-20 … Giants, Red Sox, Yankees), going 65-43, 2.47 (121 starts and 39 relief outings).

Staying Pretty Darn Close to the Shore

Now, Shore’s  perfect outing deserves the top spot here, but 38-seasons later,  Hal  Brown of the Orioles came pretty darn close.  On August 31, 1955, the Orioles faced the Indians in Cleveland. Starting for Baltimore was Bill Wright (3-5, 2.53 at the time, with 28 appearances and four complete games in eight starts). On the mound for Cleveland was rookie sensation Herb Score, 13-10, 3.21,  with eight complete games in 27 starts. (The 22-year-old Score would go 16-10 and lead the American League in strikeouts with 245 that season, taking AL Rookie of the Year honors.)

It was not to be Wright’s day. In  the bottom of the first, he faced seven batters, giving  up five runs on  three singles, two doubles and two walks – failing to record a single out.  Hal Brown came on in relief  and proceeded to throw eight no-hit innings (the Indians, with a 5-1 lead, did not bat in the bottom of the ninth). In his no-hit relief outing, Brown walked five and fanned ten. I rate Brown’s performance close to Shore since the Indians clearly  came in with their hitting shoes on – and Brown quickly “tied those shoes up.”  Those ten whiffs were also impressive, as the average strikeouts per nine innings in MLB that season was 4.4 (compared to 8.9 in 2021).

Brown finished the season, 1-4, 3.98 in seventeen games (five starts). He  had a 14-season MLB career (1951-64 …. Orioles, Red Sox, Colt .45s, White Sox , Yankees – going 85-92. 3.81 (11 saves) in 211 starts and 147 relief appearances.

____________________________________________

So, there you have a couple of the all-time great relief performances.  Let’s take a look at a few others that stand out for Baseball Roundtable – in no particular order.

Record-Setting Whiffs … Not so Long Ago

On August 2, 2020, the Tigers faced the Reds in Detroit in one of those short-season, seven-inning doubleheader matchups. Game One saw The Tigers’ Rony Garcia starting against the Reds’ Anthony DeSclafani. Garcia gave up a two-run home run to Reds’ RF Nick Castellanos in the first inning and a solo shot to Castellanos to open the top of the third.  That brought Tyler Alexander in from the pen – and he did his job, fanning the first nine hitters he faced, setting an MLB record for consecutive strikeouts in a game by a reliever and tying the MLB record for most consecutive strikeouts from the first batter faced in an appearance.   His whiff streak went like this:

  • 2B Mike Moustakas, striking out swinging on a 2-2. Foul tip.
  • 3B Eugenio Suarez, strikeout on an 0-2 pitch, taking all three strikes.
  • DH Jesse Winker, strikeout an 0-2 pitch, swinging at all three strikes… ending the third.
  • CF Nick Senzel, strikeout swinging on a 1-2 pitch to open the fourth inning.
  • 1B Josh VanMeter, strikeout looking on an 0-2 pitch.
  • SS Freddy Galvis, strikeout swinging on a 3-2 offering … an 8-pitch at bat that ended the inning.
  • C Tucker Barnhart, strikeout looking on a 1-2 pitch to open the fifth inning.
  • LF Shogo Akiyama, strikeout looking on a 1-2 pitch
  • RF Nick Castellanos, strikeout swinging on a 2-2 pitch to end the inning.

Alexander was now in position to tie all-time record for consecutive strikeouts in a game (10 – held by Tom Seaver, Aaron Nola and Corbin Burnes) in the top of the sixth.  And, it looked like he might do just that, as he had Moustakas down one-ball/two-strikes before hitting him with a pitch to end the streak.  What did the next batter do? Saurez went down swinging on a 1-2 pitch.   Travis Jankowski, running for Moustakas, was caught stealing during pinch hitter Matt Davidson’s at bat (Alexander to 1B C.J. Cron to 2B Jeimer Candelario).  Davidson eventually walked and Carson Fulmer replaced Alexander on the mound.  In his outing, Alexander three 38 strikes in 55 pitches (69/1 percent).

Alexander went 2-3, 3.96 in 14 appearances in 2020, fanning 34 batters in 36 1/3 innings.  At the close of the 2021 season, the 26-year-old southpaw was 5-11, 4.13 in 68  MLB appearances over three seasons.

As a high school senior (Carroll Senior High in Southlake, Texas), Tyler Alexander was 12-1, with a 0.66 ERA. Then, in two seasons as Texas Christian University, he went 16-6, 2.71. He was a 23rd round draft pick in 2013.

Making a Good First Impression

They say you only get once chance to make a first  impression. Well, when it comes to taking the major-league mound, Pete Richert did just that.

Richert was signed right out of high school (Sewanhaka High School, Floral Park, Florida), where – despite his small statue – he was noted for an impressive fastball. (Adam Ulrey’s Society for American Baseball Research bio on Richert indicates Richert was 5’7” and 150 pounds in high school and 5’11”/165-pounds when he made it to the major leagues as a 22-year-old).

Richert made his MLB debut on April 12, 1962 – with the Dodgers facing the Reds in Los Angeles. Stan Williams started for the Dodgers versus Joey Jay (one of my favorite baseball names) for the Reds. With two outs in the top of the second, the Dodgers already trailed 4-0 and the Reds had another runner in scoring position.  Williams was clearly not on his game having already  given up two hits and four walks – and committed a balk.  Dodger Manager Walt Alston called  to the pen and Richert came to the mound. History was about to be made.

The first batter Richert faced was the number-three hitter in the Reds’ lineup – CF Vada Pinson. Rookie jitters? No problem.  Richert fanned Pinson  on three pitches.

Things didn’t get any easier for the rookie in the top of the third.  First up was future Hall of  Famer RF Frank Robinson.  Richert struck him out on four pitches. Then came 1B Gordy Coleman – another three-pitch strikeout (but Coleman reached first on a passed ball).  So, now Richert had thrown just ten MLB pitches, facing the three-four-five hitters in the Reds’ lineup and had recorded three whiffs.  But he wasn’t done yet. Next up was LF Wally Post – another four-pitch strikeout. Post was followed by C Johnny Edwards.  Perhaps, Richert was tiring. It took him five pitches to fan Edwards and end the inning.

Third baseman Tommy Harper led off the top of the fourth and Richert recorded another three-pitch strikeout.  So, now his MLB career consisted  of 22 pitches, 18 strikes, four balls and six strikeouts – and he had the MLB record for the most consecutive strikeouts at the start of an MLB career. Ironically, Reds’ starting pitcher Joey Jay (who would hit .114 for his 13-season MLB career and strikeout in 42.7% of his at bats) broke the whiff string, grounding out to first base on an 0-1 offering.  Richert went 3 1/3 innings in the contest, giving up no hits, no walks and fanning seven. The Dodgers came back for an 11-7 win and Richert got the victory.  Overall, Richert threw 41 pitches – 33 strikes (including balls put in play) and just eight balls.

Pete Richert is the only major leaguer with a four-strikeout inning in his MLB debut.

Richert finished his rookie season at 5-4, 3.87 (19 games, 12 starts), with 75 strikeouts in 81 1/3 innings. The two-time All Star enjoyed a 13-season MLB career (1962-74 … Dodgers, Senators, Orioles, Cardinals, Phillies) – going 80-73, 3.19 with 51 saves (429 games/122 starts).

Working Overtime … NO, Really Working Overtime

Zip Zabel. Photo: Bain News Service, Public Domain

On June 17, 1915, the Cubs faced off against the Brooklyn Robins (Dodgers) in Chicago, with Bert Humphries (3-2, 0.59) starting for the Cubs and Jeff Pfeffer (5-4, 2.61) on the mound for the Robins. With two out and one-run across in the top of the first inning, George Washington “Zip” Zabel was called on to relieve Humphries, who had been hit on the pitching hand by a line drive

To make a lo-o-o-ng story short – Zip Zabel was still on the mounds in the 19th inning, with the score knotted at 3-3. His 18 1/3 innings (nine hits, two runs, one walk, six strikeouts) remains the longest relief effort in MLB history. The Robins pushed across a run in the bottom of the nineteenth to give Zabel the win.   Notably, Pfeffer (Cubs’ starter) tossed a complete game in the loss.

Zabel finished the season at 7-10, 3.20 in 36 games/17 starts. His MLB career lasted just three seasons (1913-15), all with the Cubs, and he went 12-14, 2.71, (It was reported that Zabel came up with a sore arm after his 18 1/3 inning relief stint.     Zabel was 5-4, 2.25 on the season through June 17 and was 2-6, 4.15 after the outing.  It was his final major-league season, although he did pitch two more season in the minors.)

Tomorrow, Tomorrow … It’s only a Day Away

Randy Johnson. Photo by SD Dirk

On June 18, 2001, the Diamondbacks were facing the Padres in San Diego, with the Diamondbacks starting Curt Schilling on the mound against the Padres’ Woody Williams.  The game was suspended in the top of the third inning, with Arizona up 1-0 – after an electrical malfunction knocked out part of the outfield lighting.  The suspended game was to be completed before the following day’s regularly schedule game.  Southpaw Randy Johnson was slated to start the regularly scheduled contest, but D-back’s manager Bob Brenly (with the Padres’ lineup in the resuming game set for righty Schilling) moved Johnson up to begin the suspended game. Williams returned to the mound for the Padres.  Johnson pitched seven scoreless, one-hit innings for the win (3-0). More important for the record books, he fanned 16 batters, still the record for strikeouts in a single relief appearance. Notably, it was Johnson’s only relief appearance of the season and his first relief assignment since September 27, 1997.

Johnson finished the 2001 season 21-6, 2.49, with 372 strikeouts in 249 2/3 innings. The Hall of Famer enjoyed a 22-season MLB career (1988-2009 … Expos, Mariners, Astros, Diamondbacks, Yankees and Giants). He went 303-166, 3.29 and fanned 4,875 batters in 4,135 1/3 innings. In 22 seasons, he made just 15 relief appearances (603 starts).

Walter Johnson. Photo by pingnews.com

If you want to know the strikeout record for an AL relief appearance (and for a relief appearance that took place on the same day the game started), that would go to  another Johnson: Hall of Famer Walter Johnson. The St, Louis Browns were facing the Washington Senators in Washington on July 25, 1913. George Baumgardner(7-11, 2,47) was on the mound for St. Louis, Joe Engel (8-13, 3.67) for the Senators. Neither was around for long. Baumgardner lasted just 1/3 of an inning, giving up two runs on three hits (two home runs).  Engel fared a bit better, lasting three frames and giving up four runs (three earned). Tom Hughes followed Engel, but lasted just two-thirds of an inning, before Johnson was called in with the Senators trailing 7-6. Washington tied it in the fifth, but St. Louis scored a run off Johnson to take an 8-7 lead in the seventh, only to have Washington retie then score in the eighth.  The game ended in an 8-8 tie and Johnson had gone 11 1/3 innings, giving up seven hits, two runs (one earned), walking two and fanning an AL still single-game record for relief pitchers 15 batters.

One that Stands Out

Walter Johnson led the League in strikeouts an MLB-record 12 times.  Ironically, despite working primarily as a starter (666 career starts/136 relief appearance). His highest single-game strikeout total came (15) came in the above noted  July 25, 1913 relief appearance

Walter Johnson pitched 21 MLB seasons (1907-1927), going 417-279, 2.17. He won 20 or more games in 11 seasons ( 30+ in two of those) and led the AL in wins six times, ERA five times, strikeouts 12 times, complete games six times and shutouts seven times.

Let’s Keep that Plate Clean

The longest scoreless relief outing was fourteen innings – by the Cubs’ Bob Osborn on May 17, 1927, facing the Boston Braves (in Boston). Surprisingly, Osborn did not come into the game until ninth inning.  At that point, the game was knotted 3-3. Osborn went on to pitch 14 scoreless frames, giving up just six hits (all singles), while walking two and fanning just one. The Cubs scored on a walk, sacrifice and single in the top of the 22nd inning to give Osborn a well-earned win.  Braves’ starter Bob Smith went the distance – giving up four runs (three earned) in 22 innings – on 20 hits and nine walks (that was one tough day at the office).  Osborn finished the season at 5-5, 4.18 in 24 appearances (12 starts). He pitched in six MLB seasons (1925-27, 1930-31 … Cubs, Pirates), going 27-17, 4.32 in 121 games (43 starts).

Shortest-ever Relief Appearance … and It Lasted an Entire MLB Career

Larry Yount, brother of Hall of Famer Robin Yount, made his MLB debut on September 15, 1971 – coming on in the top of the ninth to replace Skip Guinn (who had been pinch hit for in the previous half inning).   The score was 4-1 and, if all worked out, Yount would face LF Ralph Garr, 1B Hank Aaron and C Earl Williams.  All did not work out. Yount had experienced a bit of elbow pain in the bullpen warming up  and, as he continued to warm up on the mound, it only got worse. He called the trainer to the mound and, after a bit of discussion, Yount walked off the field – officially registering an MLB appearance, but not tossing s single pitch. Yount pitched two more season in the minors, but never came to the major-league mound again.

Another Short Relief Appearance that Didn’t End a Career, but Did End a Game

On July 15, 2005, Mike Stanton of the Nationals was called into a game in a tough spot. It was the bottom of the tenth inning, the Nationals and Brewers were tied at 3-3 and the Brewers had runners on first and third with one out when Stanton came to the mound to take over from Luis Ayala.  Conventional wisdom? Intentionally  walk Lyle Overbay to load the bases and set up a possible double play. Unconventional outcome. The game resumes after Stanton’s warmup and, before tossing a pitch, Stanton balks in the winning run.  Game over, without Stanton throwing a single pitch.

Stanton, for those who like to know such things, pitched 19 years in the major leagues (1989-2007 …. Braves, Yankees, Red Sox, Mets, Nationals, Giants, Rangers, Reds), appearing in 1,178 games, picking up 69 wins (63 losses), with 84 saves and a 3.92 ERA. He made one start in his career.  On May 9, 1999 – for the Yankees against the Mariners – going four innings (two hits, no runs, one walk, three strikeouts) and leaving with a 4-0 lead (but getting no decision).

A Few More Short Stories

Disappointed with the major-leagues bargaining this off-season? Think about how Oliver Perez must have felt on June 29, 2018.  With the Indians down 2-0 to the Athletics in the bottom of the seventh, and the Athletics threatening to break the game open (runners on second and third and two out), Indians’ manager Terry Francona brought in southpaw Perez to face left-handed (leadoff) hitter CF Dustin Fowler.   Athletics’ Manager Bob Melvin countered by pinch hitting with  right-handed hitter Mark Canha (who would be followed by left-handed hitting LF Matt Joyce).  Now, the managerial wheels were turning. Francona had Perez intentionally walk Canha to load the bases and get to lefty Joyce. (Remember, this was with the new “wave ‘em to first” intentional walk rule, so Perez had yet to throw a pitch.)  Melvin made another managerial move, having righty Chad Pinder hit for Joyce.  Francona countered by pulling Perez and bringing in righty Zach McAllister. So, Perez was out of the game without tossing a pitch. He was also credited with a walk and, if that runner on third scored, it would go against his ERA.  Ouch!   Fortunately, McAllister fanned Pinder on four pitchers and Perez was off the hook.

There are also a few instances of pitcher actually getting a decision (win or save) without throwing a pitch.  Keeping in mind that batter counts pre-1980 are not readily available, here are three such instances I could document (baseball-reference.com).  I’d welcome info on any other such instances.

On April 28, 1989, The Cubs were leading the Padres 3-0 going into the bottom of the ninth – with Paul Kilgus on the mound for the Cubs and the 3-4-5 hitters due up for San Diego.  Kilgus got CF Tony Gwynn on a fly to deep left, but then 1B Jack Clark doubled to right; C Benito Santiago reached on an error (Clark going to third); LF Carmello Martinez reached on a fielder’s choice (as Clark was cut down at the plate – third-baseman Curt Wilkerson to catcher Rick Wrona); and RF Luis Salazar singled Santiago home, with Martinez going to third. Manager Don Zimmer brought in Mitch Williams to face SS Garry Templeton. Before tossing a pitch to Templeton, Williams picked Martinez off second (SS Shawon Dunston covering) ending the inning and the game – and giving William a “save” without a pitch. Williams ended the season 4-4, 2.76 with 36 saves and a league-leading 76 appearances.  Williams pitched in 11 MLB seasons (1986-95, 1997 … Rangers, Cubs, Phillies, Astros, Angels, Royals) going 45-58, 3.65 with 192 saves. (He had three seasons of 30 or more saves, a high of 43 in 1993).

On May 1, 2003, the Orioles faced off against the Tigers in Detroit. The game was tied at 1-1 in the bottom  of the seventh, when the Tigers scored the go-ahead run off Pat Hentgen (in his fifth inning of relief).  With two out and a runner (Omar Infante) on first , Orioles’ manager Mike Hargrove brought B.J . Ryan in to face Tigers’ RF Bobby Higginson. Before tossing a pitch, Ryan caught Infante off base and he was retired Ryan to 1B  Jeff Conine to shortstop Deivi Cruz.  The Orioles scored three in the top of the eighth to take the lead. Ryan was replaced by Buddy Groom to open the bottom of the eighth. The Orioles went on to win 5-2 and  Ryan picked up an MLB victory without tossing a pitch. Ryan finished the season 4-1, 3.40 in 76 appearances. He pitched in 11 MLB seasons (1999-2009 … Reds, Orioles, Blue Jays), going 21-28, 3,37, with 117 saves in 560 appearances (all in relief). Ryan was an All Star in 2005 and 2006, saving 36 and 38 games in those two seasons, respectively,

On July 7, 2009, the Rockies took on the Nationals in Denver. The two teams went into the eighth innings tied at four apiece, with Joel Peralta (the Rockies’ fourth pitcher of the ay) on the mound for the Rox. With two outs, a runner (Austin Kearns) on first base and Washington’s leadoff hitter, lefty CF Nyjer Morgan, due up, Rockies’ manager Clint Hurdle called in southpaw Alan Embree. Before tossing a pitch, Embree caught Kearns off first and he was retired in a rundown (Embree to 1B Todd Helton to SS Troy Tulowitzki and back to Embree for the putout). Seth Smith pinch hit for Embree as The Rockies scored the winning run in the bottom of the inning,. Huston Street came in to toss a 1-2-3 ninth and Embree had a win without throwing a pitch.

Now, let’s move on to some “longer” relief accomplishments.

We’ll Never See This Again

In 1974, the Dodgers’ Mike Marshall put up the grand-daddy of all relief seasons – becoming the first reliever to win the Cy Young Award and setting the still-standing record for appearances with 106 and relief innings pitched in a season at 208 1/3. He finished the season 15-12, with a league-topping 21 saves and a 2.42 ERA.  Marshall was called on to go more than one inning in 74 games (68.5 percent of the time) and toiled three or more innings 22 times.  Marshall’s longest stint came on August 19, when he came on in the seventh inning of a 7-7 game against the Cubs – and went six innings, earning the win as the Dodgers topped the Cubs 8-7 in twelve innings.

In 1974, Mike Marshall took the mound every day from May 17 through May 24 (8 days) … pitching 14 2/3 innings and giving up just one earned run.

Lucky  Number 13

Just two relievers have pitched in 13 consecutive games:

Mike Marshall appeared in 13 consecutive games for the Dodgers from June 18 through July 3, 1974 – going 6-0, 1.69 with two saves.

In his rookie season (1986), the Rangers’ Dale Mohorcic appeared in 13 consecutive games from August 6 through August 20  – going 0-1, 3.86 with two saves. He finished the season 2-4, 2.51, with seven saves in 58 appearances. Mohorcic played five MLB seasons (1986-90 … Rangers, Yankees, Expos), going 16-21, 3.49 with 33 saves. His best season was 1987, when he went 7-6, 2.99, with 16 saves for the Rangers.

Dale Mohorcic, who played college baseball at Cleveland State University, made his professional debut at age 22, with the low-A Victoria Mussels. He made his MLB debut in his ninth pro season, at age 30. After minor-league stops at Victoria, Dunedin (Blue Jays), Salem (Pirates), Portland (Beavers), Buffalo (Bisons), Hawaii (Islanders), Lynn (Sailors), Nashua (Pirates) and Oklahoma City (89ers).

84 Straight Saves

Eric Gagne. Photo: OctopusHat, CC BY-SA 2.0 <https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/2.0>, via Wikimedia Commons

From August 28, 2002 through July 3, 2004  the Dodgers’ Eric Gagne converted a record 84 consecutive save opportunities, during that stretch he appeared in 123 games, going 6-3 (the three losses did not come in “save” situations), with a  1.98 earned run average and 207 strikeouts in 132 innings.

__________

Bookends

The Blown Save that preceded the start of Eric Gagne’s 84-saves streak came against the Diamondbacks on August 26, 2002.  Gagne came into the game in the ninth to protect a 3-2 Dodger lead, but a single by Steve Finley and a double by David Dellucci tied the game (the Dodgers lost 6-3 in twelve frames). The Blown Save the ended the string came on July 5, 2005 – again versus the Diamondbacks. Gagne came on in the top of the ninth to protect a 5-3 lead, but gave up two runs on a Shea Hillenbrand single, Louis Gonzalez double and Chad Tracy single.

__________

Gagne pitched in 10 MLB seasons, going 33-26, 3.47 with 187 saves. He was a three-time All Star and won the 2003 NL Cy Young Award when he went 2-3, 1.20 with 55 saves in 55 save opportunities.

A What Might Have Been Story

Eric Gagne made his MLB debut with the Dodgers in 1999,  as a 23-year-old starting pitcher. In his first three seasons with LA, he was a middling 11-14, 4.61 in 56 appearances (48 starts) at the back of the Dodger rotation.  Then, in 2002, Dodgers’ closer Jeff Shaw retired and Gagne was one of the arms the Dodgers took a look at for the role.  The rest is history. From 2002 through 2004, he was the best in the business – earning  the nickname Eric “Game Over” Gagne.   In those three seasons, Gagne went 13-7, 1.79, saved 152 games in 158 opportunities and fanned 365 batters in 247  innings – making three All Star teams and picking up the 2003 NL Cy Young Award along the way.  Finishing the 2004 season at 28-years-old, the sky seemed the limit.  However, it was not to be. Over the next four seasons (2005-08), Gagne went 9-5, 4.28, with just 35 saves and 114 strikeouts in 113 2/3 innings.

What happened? The frailties of the human arm.  First, you need to know that Gagne had Tommy John surgery (elbow) in 1997.  He had elbow surgery again in 2005 and 2006 – and also had back surgery (herniated disc) in 2006. (He appeared in only 16 games in 2005-06.) Gagne also suffered a shoulder injury in 2008 (his final MLB season … Brewers).

Baseball Roundtable Obligatory Chart

The MLB record holder in relief appearances is Jesse Orosco, who came out of the bullpen 1,248 times. Orosco, however, had four starts early in his 24-season MLB career.  All-time saves leader (652) Mariano Rivera had ten starts in his first year with the Yankees and all-time leader in career wins in relief Hoyt Wilhelm made 52 starts over his 21-season MLB career.   As starters, Orosco was 0-2, 6.38; Rivera was 3-3, 5.94; and Wilhelm was 19-19, 2.68 (with 20 complete games and five shutouts).

Roy for the Win

In 1959, the Pirates’ Roy Face set the (still-standing) MLB record for relief wins in a season – going 18-1, 2.70 with 10 saves. In that season, Face pitched two or more innings in 24 of his 57 relief appearances.  Ten of his 18 victories came in extra-inning games; four wins came in games in which he also recorded a blown save (retroactively); his longest outing was five innings; and his lone loss came on September 11, after 17 wins to start the season.

Face began his professional career as a starting pitcher, going 69-27 in four minor-league seasons (1949-52), earning a spot on the Pirates in 1953.  At the time, the  Face relied on a fastball and curveball, but at about 5’8” and 160 pounds, he was not your classic fastball/curve power pitcher. And major league hitters made that clear.  In 1953, Face was 6-8, 6.58 – and in 1954 he was sent back down to Double-A, where he developed the forkball that eventually defined his career.

He was back with the Pirates in 1955, working primarily as a reliever and going 5-7, 3.58 with five saves in 42 games (ten starts).  From there his career as a reliever took off, and he appeared in 50 or more games in 11 of the next 12 seasons (twice leading the league in games and three times in saves).

Face ultimately played 16 MLB seasons (1953, 1955-69 …Pirates, Tigers, Expos) going 104-95, 3.48, with 191 saves.

Primary Resources: Baseball-Reference.com; Baseball-Almanac.com; Gagne to have back surgery, miss rest of season, Associated Press, July 7, 2008.

100Baseball Roundtable is on the Feedspot list of the Top 100 Baseball Blogs.  To see the full list, click here.

I tweet baseball @DavidBBRT

Follow/Like Baseball Roundtable’s Facebook Page here.  More baseball commentary; blog post notifications; PRIZES.

Member: Society for American Baseball Research (SABR); Negro Leagues Baseball Museum; The Baseball Reliquary. 

 

 

 

 

For the Love of the Game … John Lindsey’s Long Climb to the Majors

I have often noted in this  blog how  – when I start digging into one baseball event, career or question – “one thing leads to another.”  This post is no exception.  I started with the intention of looking at who the newest, oldest-ever MLB rookie is, now that Satchel Paige has had to relinquish that crown (with the classification of the 1920-48 Negro Leagues as major leagues).  I got a bit sidetracked as my research took me to the player who had the longest minor-league career (16 seasons) before making his MLB debut.  We’ll get to Paige’s successor, but first a look at John Lindsey’s remarkable climb to the majors.

How many of  us – as baseball fans – would  have given anything for even just one at bat in the  leagues? Or, if we were really lucky, one hit (or one strikeout or one mound win)?  Getting our picture on a big-league baseball card – or our name on a page in The Baseball Encyclopedia would have been heaven.

Well, John Lindsey accomplished that dream – and, in doing it, showed more perseverance than any major leaguer before or since.  Lindsey spent 16 seasons and a combination of 1,571 minor-league games, as well as four seasons and 141 games in the Mexican, Dominican and Venezuelan Winter Leagues, before his September 8, 2010 MLB debut with the Dodgers. Lindsey’s was the longest minor-league  “internship” ever before an MLB debut.  In fact, before he put on the Los Angeles uniform, he had he had played in the Rockies, Mariners and Dodgers’ systems, suiting up for the:

  • Arizona Rookie League Rockies;
  • Northwest League Portland Rockies;
  • South Atlantic League Asheville Tourists (two seasons);
  • Carolina League Salem Avalanche (three seasons);
  • California League San Bernardino Stampede;
  • Florida State League Jupiter Hammerheads;
  • Independent Canadian-American Association New Jersey Jackals (two seasons);
  • Pacific Coast League Las Vegas 51s (two seasons);
  • Dominican Winter league Estrellas de Oriente (San Pedro de Macoris);
  • Pacific Coast League New Orleans Zephyrs;
  • Southern League Jacksonville Suns;
  • Mexican Pacific Winter League Hermosillo Naranjeros and Mazatlán Venados; and
  • Pacific Coast League Albuquerque Isotopes.

Let’s take a look at the remarkable perseverance and positive attitude that got Lindsey to the big-leagues as a player and what happened once he got there (and beyond).

Lindsey was a signed as a teenager, right out of Hattiesburg (MS) High School, where he played football and baseball.  He was a 13th round pick of the Rockies in the 1995 MLB Draft. He got off to a bit of a slow start, with averages ranging from .208 to .275 over his first five seasons – although the big first baseman did have a solid season in 1998 at Class-A Asheville (.275-14-73 in 126 games).  Promoted to High-A Salem the next season (1999), he struggled (.208-4-35 in 75 games), but then turned it around and hit .280-16-88 in 155 games over  the next two  seasons (both at Salem).

Lindsey  was granted free agency after the 2001 season and signed with the Mariners – who assigned him to High-A San Bernardino, where he showed a solid bat with power,  hitting .297-22-93 in in 127 games. That earned him a promotion.  In 2003 – now 26 and in his eighth pro season – he moved up to Double-A (San Antonio), where he had two very solid years:  .296-22-93 and .282-19-72.  Despite those  solid campaigns, Lindsey again found himself as a free agent after the 2004 season. He signed with the Cardinals in October of 2004, was released by St.  Louis in March 2005. He ended up starting the 2005 season with the New Jersey Jackals of the Independent  Canadian-American Association – still determined to earn that big-league opportunity. That season, he hit .321-9-62 in 56 games and earned a spot on the Can-Am 2005 All Star Team. His performance also earned him a  contract (signed that July) from the Marlins  – who assigned him to High-A Jupiter, where Lindsey hit just .219 in 30 games.   After the 2005 season, he once again found himself a free agent.

Some might have given up the dream, but Lindsey just kept working.  In 2006, it was back to New Jersey, where he hit .311-10-41 in 69 games and attracted the attention of the Dodgers, who signed him in January 2007.   The Dodgers sent him to Double-A Jacksonville, where a .286-11-33 line (in 56 games)  finally earned him – at age 30 and in his apparently lucky 13th minor-league season – a shot at Triple-A ball.  One step closer to the dream. 

Lindsey continued to improve.  In 2007, he hit .333-19-88 in 77 games at Triple-A Las Vegas.  He followed that up with .316-26-100 in 133 games at Las Vegas in 2008.  He once again displayed average, power and clutch performance – and still no call up. By this time, he was 31-years-old, with 13 minor-league seasons under his belt. The clock was ticking on the dream. In fact, the Dodgers let him get away, as a free-agent signee with the Marlins for a second time. As a Florida farmhand, Lindsey turned in a .251-19-83 season at Triple-A New Orleans in 2009.

The Dodgers must have remembered what they liked about Lindsey, as they resigned him after the 2009 season. In 2010, he found himself at first base for the Triple-A Albuquerque Isotopes. At Albuquerque, he continued to impress the Dodgers – and boasted a .353-25-97 line when he was called up in  early September.  Goal one – making it to the bigs – accomplished.  Now,  to get that at bat and hit.  We’ll get to that in a minute, but first more about Lindsey’s path to Dodger blue.

Over this arduous journey, Lindsey earned a reputation for his perseverance, professionalism, positive attitude, relentless work ethic, passion for the game – and seemingly never missing smile.

What Kind of Character It Really Takes … A Great Lesson in Never Giving up

About a week before John Lindsey’s 2010 call up, the Dodgers’s (then) Farm System Director De Jon Watson said this about Lindsey, “He is unbelievable for our young guys. He shows what it takes to persevere in this game. He’s a quality human being with a great work ethic and integrity.  You want those kinds of people around  your young guys that are on their way to the big leagues, so they don’t forget what this game really takes, what kind of character it really takes, what kind of resolve it takes to come in every single day and keep grinding away.” 1

Commenting on Lindsey’s call up, Dodgers’ (then) manager Joe Torre said “ That’s a great lesson in never giving up.  That’s the simple way to put it … he’s got this big smile on his face all the time.  Very polite, very respectful and just worked at getting himself better.” 2

______________________________________________________________

John Lindsey’s First MLB Appearance (Kind Of)  …. and His Final MLB Appearance (Kind Of)

John Lindsey “kind of” made his first MLB appearance on September 8, 2010 – as the Dodgers faced the Padres in San Diego. It came in the eighth inning, with the Dodgers trailing San Diego 4-0, with runners on first and second and no outs. Lindsey was called in to pinch hit for left-handed hitting LF  Scott Podsednik against southpaw Joe Thatcher – producing that traditionally preferred lefty-right matchup.  Finally, Lindsey was coming to the plate in a major-league game – almost.  Padres’ manager Bud Black pulled Thatcher and brought in right-hander Luke Gregerson.  Dodgers’ skipper Joe Torre quickly countered, calling Lindsey back to the dugout and sending up  lefty-swinging Andre Ethier.  So, while Lindsey is officially credited with his first major-league game that day – he did not appear in the batter’s box, on the basepaths or in the field. To add insult to injury, Ethier grounded into a second-to-first double play on Gregerson’s very first pitch.

Lindsey appeared in ten more games as the season wound down – primarily as a pinch hitter He did start two games at first base).  He got one hit in 12 at bats – a pinch hit single off the Astros’ Nelson Figueroa on  September 12.

On September 25, Lindsey got his second (and final) start of the season at first base. In the seventh inning, he was hit on the right hand by a pitch (on a 1-2 count)  from the Diamondbacks’ Daniel Hudson.  The broken hand ended his season  – again kind of – and required surgery.

Then on the final day of the season (October 3), Dodgers’ manager Joe Torre chose to honor Lindsey’s attitude and perseverance.  He “officially” called on  Lindsey to pinch hit for pitcher Ted Lilly in bottom of the seventh (with the Dodgers leading the Diamondbacks 2-1) – and then immediately removed him for pinch-hitter Trent Oeltjen (who popped up to the pitcher on a bunt attempt).  That would turn out to be the last MLB game of Lindsey’s career.  So, in both his first and late official MLB appearances, he did not “appear” in the batter’s box. on the basepaths or in the field.

_____________________________________________________

While that October 3, 2010 game was Lindsey’s last in the major leagues, it was not his last as a professional. He continued to play  for five more years – taking the field for  teams in the International League,  Canadian-American Association (yes, back to the New Jersey Jackals), Mexican League and Mexican Pacific Winter League.  While his MLB record is one single and one hit-by-pitch in 13 plate appearances, overall Lindsey is credited with 21 pro seasons, 2,277 games, 2,291 hits, a .284 average, 377 home runs, 1,536 RBI – and a never diminished passion for the national pastime.  We could all learn a lesson about passion, perseverance and a strong work ethic in pursuing our dreams from major-leaguer John Lindsey.

  1. John Lindsey Waits for his chance, by Ramona Shelburne, ESPN, ?August 29, 2010.
  2. Dodgers’ Lindsey finally a big leaguer, by David Wassen, The Press Enterprise, September 7, 2010.

Back to My Original Search

Who holds the title of MLB’s oldest rookie?  For years, of course, that crown has belonged to Satchel Paige … who debuted for the Cleveland Indians on July 9, 1948  (at a reported 42-years and two-days old). But with the recent changes assigning major league status to the Negro Leagues (1920-48), Paige’s major-league debut now came as a 20-year-old with the 1927 Birmingham Black Barons.  Your new oldest MLB rookie would be Dominican-born southpaw Diomedes Olivo – who was 41-years and 227-days of age when he debuted for the Pirates on September 5, 1960.  By the time he reached the major leagues, Olivo had  pitched in Mexico, Puerto Rico, Cuba, Venezuela, Nicaragua and Columbia. As you might expect, his MLB career was short. He was 5-6, 3.10 in 85 games (one start) over three MLB seasons (1960, 62-63). As a 43-year-old in 1960, he went 5-1, 2.77 with seven saves in 62 games for the Pirates.

Primary Resources:  Baseball-Reference.com; Baseball-Almanac.com; Where Nobody Knows Your Name: Life in the Minor Leagues of Baseball, by John Feinstein, Anchor Books, 2014

100Baseball Roundtable is on the Feedspot list of the Top 100 Baseball Blogs.  To see the full list, click here.

I tweet baseball @DavidBBRT

Follow/Like Baseball Roundtable’s Facebook Page here.  More baseball commentary; blog post notifications; PRIZES.

Member: Society for American Baseball Research (SABR); Negro Leagues Baseball Museum; The Baseball Reliquary. 

 

 

 

Baseball Roundtable’s All 2021 MLB Debut Lineup

From the Cubs’ Corey Abbott to the Royals’ Angel Zerba and from 20-year-old Wander Franco to 33-year-old Mickey Jannis, 265 players made their MLB debuts in 2021.  In this post, I’d like to present a lineup (by position) of what Baseball Roundtable rates as 2021’s  “best” debut games.  But first, a few  2021 trivia tidbits:

  • 2021 debuts included 164 pitchers and 101 position players (including designated hitters).
  • The Orioles saw the most 2021 MLB debuts at 16, followed by the Angels and Cubs at 15.
  • The Braves and Cardinals saw the fewest debuts at three, followed by the White Sox and A’s at four each.
  • April first (Opening Day) was the earliest 2021  debut date – with nine players making their first major-league appearance on that date.
  • Two players made their debuts on October 3 – the season’s final day.
  • National League Rookie of the Year Jonathon India of the Reds made his debut in 2021; American League Rookie of the Year Randy Arozarena of the Rays made his MLB debut in 2019 (with the Cardinals) and had played 42 regular-season MLB games and 25 post-season games before the 2021 season opened.
  • Twelve countries were represented among the debut players.

Baseball Roundtable Rates the Top 25 (All-Time) MLB Debuts

For Baseball Roundtable’s rating of the top 25 MLB debuts, click here.  You’ll find players from stars like Willie McCovey (four-for-four with two triples in his debut) to record-setters like Karl Spooner (15 strikeouts in his debut) to lesser-known players like Ray Jansen (with four hits in his only MLB game, which was also his first-ever  professional game at any level).

Now, that All-2021 Debut Lineup.

Kent Emanuel, Astros … April 24, 2021

  • 8 2/3 IP, five hits, two earned runs, zero walks, five strikeouts

There were a handful of pitchers whose 2021 MLB debuts deserved consideration. Pirates’ 23-year-old  righty Max Kranick, for example, made his debut on June 27 (starting against the Cardinals) and pitched five perfect innings (three strikeouts), picking up his first MLB win. Or there’s the Rangers 25-year-old right-hander Glenn Otto, who debuted on August 27  – starting against the powerful Astros – and gave up just two hits (no runs) over five innings, while fanning seven.  But, for Baseball Roundtable, the most striking (pun intended) 2021 pitching debut belonged to the Astros’ 29-year-old southpaw Kent Emanuel.

The rookie, who had already spent seven seasons in the minors, settled into the Astros’ bullpen ready to watch Houston starter Jake Odorizzi go to work,  He didn’t get to watch for long.  Odorizzi retired  leadoff hitter David Fletcher on five pitchers, but then had to  had to leave the game with forearm tightness – and suddenly Emanuel found himself heading to an MLB mound for the first time. Emanuel finished the game, tossing 8 2/3 innings, giving up just five hits and two runs (on home runs by Albert Pujols and Shohei Ohtani), walking none and fanning five. He threw 90 pitches, 55 for strikes. Emanuel picked up the win, as the Astros triumphed 16-2.

Emanuel pitched in nine more games for the Astros, before an elbow injury (requiring surgery) ended his season in late May. He never pitched more than two innings in any of those appearances and ended the season at 1-0, 2.55, with a total of 17 2/3 MLB innings on his resume.  In November,  the Astros placed Emanuel on waivers and he was claimed by the Phillies.

Emanuel was drafted in the third round of the 2013 MLB Draft (out of the University of North Carolina, where he had gone 28-10, 2.52 in three seasons).

Kent Emanuel was name Atlantic Coast Conference Pitcher of the ear in 2013.

In seven minor-league seasons – interrupted by 2015 Tommy John surgery,  Emanuel went 35-25, 4.77. In 2019, he was 8-2, 3.90 with the Triple-A Round Rock Express.

———————————————————-

Catcher – Nick Fortes, Marlins … September 18, 2021

  • Two-for-three, one run, two RBI, HR

Nick Fortes was drafted by the Marlins in the fourth round of the 2018 MLB Draft (out of the University of Mississippi, where he had played 126 games over three seasons, going .308-16-82,with 14 stolen bases). In three minor-league campaigns he hit .232-10-84 in 190 games.

He made his MLB debut on September 18, catching and batting seventh for the Marlins (versus the Pirates in  Miami).  In his first at bat (leading off the bottom of the third against the Pirate starter Bryse Wilson), he hit an 0-1 pitch for a groundball single up the middle. He came up against Wilson again in the fifth, with a runner on first, one out and the Marlins trailing 5-0. In that at bat, he hit Wilson’s first offering for a home run to deep left. In his third at bat, he grounded out to short, The Marlins lost the game 6-3,

Fortes got in 14 games for the Marlins in 2022, hitting .290, with four home runs, seven RBI, six runs scored and one stolen  base.

—————————————————-

First Base –  Alfonso Rivas III, Cubs … August 29, 2021

  • Two-for-three, one double

Rivas was drafted by the Oakland Athletics  in the fourth round of the 2018 MLB Draft (out of the University of Arizona, where he hit .323-15-141, with nine steals in 173 games over three seasons). In two minor-league seasons in the Oakland system (183 games), Rivas hit .289-10-88. Then, in January 2020, he was traded to the Cubs.  When called up in 2021, Rivas was hitting .284-4-32 (58 games) for the Iowa Cubs.

In his first MLB game, he was at first base, batting eighth, as the Cubs faced the White Sox. The White Sox’ Dylan Ceases (10-6, 3.92 at the time) started and went six innings (four hits, one run, 11 strikeouts) for the win. Cease retired the first seven Cubs he faced, before Rivas singled up the middle on the first MLB pitch he saw (top of the third). He came up again in the fifth – again facing Cease –  with the Cubs down 3-1, and doubled down the left field line. (Cease showed his “stuff” by fanning the next three Cubs.) In the seventh, Rivas flied out to  center off reliever Ryan Tepera.

In his next four games, Rivas went zer0-for-ten, but he  then hit safely in 11 of his final 13 2021 games, ending the season at .318-1-3 in 18 contests.

____________________________________

Second Base – Jonathan India, Reds … April 1, 2001

  • Two-for-four, one double

Jonathan India was a first-round pick (fifth overall) for the Reds in the 2018 MLB Draft (out of the University of Florida, where he it .310-31-126, with 41 steals  in 194 games over three season).

In 2018, Jonathon India was a first-team All American and the SEC Player of the Year. In that season, he went .350-21-52, with 15 steals in 68 games. 

 In two minor- league seasons, India hit.254-17-67, with 17 steals in 165 games.

The 24-year-old made his first start for the Reds on April 1, 2021,  playing second base and batting seventh against the Cardinals in Cincinnati. It was a less than auspicious start, as the Cardinals’ Jack Flaherty fanned him looking on a 3-2 pitch to end the second inning. India got the better of Flaherty in the fourth inning (with the Reds already down 11-3), doubling to left. India then led off the sixth with a single to left center off reliever Ryan Hensley, before flying out to right in his final at bat of the day (bottom of the seventh.). India got off to a good start overall, with 10 hits (.476 average) and 10 RBI in his first six MLB games.  He ended the season at .269-21-69, with 12 steals and 98 run scored in 150 games – capturing the Rookie of the Year honors.

_________________________________________

Third Base, Wander Franco, Rays…  June 22, 2021

  • Two-for-four, two runs, three RBI, one double, one home run, one walk

Wander Franco was considered  a top international  prospect when he signed (as a 16-year-old) with the Rays during the 2017 international signing period. He immediately began delivering on his potential with a .351-11-57 season (61 games) at Rookie-Level ball in 2018. In 2019, he hit .327-9-53 at  A and High-A.  In 2021, still just 20-years-old, he was hitting  Triple-A pitching for a .313 average, with seven homers and 35 RBI in 40 games.

The switch-hitting Franco made his first start  for the Rays on June 22, 2021 (batting second and playing third base against the Red Sox) and kept right on raking. In his first MLB plate appearance, he showed great discipline for a 20-year-old, working a six-pitch walk off starter Eduardo Rodriguez (the only walk Rodriguez would surrender in six innings of work). Wander later scored on a single by Francisco Mejia.

Wander worked the count to 3-2 again leading off the third, before flying out to center. Then in the fifth, with the Rays trailing 5-2, he jumped on the first pitch from Rodriguez for a game-tying three-run home run to left. Wander wasn’t done yet, as he doubled to left off reliever Josh Taylor in the seventh. He came up again in the bottom of the ninth needing a triple for the cycle, but grounded out to pitcher Matt Barnes. The Red Sox won in 11 innings by a 9-5 score.

Franco went on to play 70 games for the Rays in 2021 (starting 61 at SS).  He’s at third base here because that was his debut position.  He hit .288, with seven home runs and 39 RBI for the season.  He then went on to hit .368-2-4  in AL Division series (verso Boston).

___________________________________

MLB Debut Extra – A Long Time A’Comin’

Orioles’ pitcher Mickey Jannis, at 33-years-old, was the oldest player to make his MLB debut in 2021. It came on June 23 – in his eleventh professional season.  He came in in the top of the fifth, with the Astros leading the Orioles 6-0 and the number four-five-six hitters coming up.  The knuckleballer fanned the first MLB hitter he ever faced (DH Yordan Alvarez); got SS Carlos Correa on a flyout to right; and walked RF Kyle Tucker (who was erased trying to steal). Unfortunately, things didn’t go as well after that inning, as Jannis gave up seven runs in 3 1/3 innings.  Still, his perseverance did get him to the major-league mound.

Shortstop, Oneil Cruz, Pirates … October 2, 2021

  • Two-for-five, one run, one RBI

Cruz almost didn’t make this lineup.  First, he didn’t get make his MLB debut until the second-to-last game of the Pirates’ season.  Second, Wander Franco might seem like the logical choice here, but the fact that Franco made his debut at third base,  left the shortstop spot open on in this lineup.

Cruz made his MLB debut for the Pirates, playing Shortstop and batting eighth. It came on October 2, 2021. The late-season call up recognized Cruz’ fine 2021 season at Double-A and Triple-A – .310-17-47, with 19 steals in 68 games.

When Oneil Cruz stepped onto the field  on October 2 in Pittsburgh, he – at 6’-7” – became the tallest shortstop to start an MLB game.

In his first MLB at bat, Cruz grounded out to short to end the bottom of the second. He came up again in the fifth, with the Pirates trailing 5-0, with two runners on and no outs. In that plate appearance, he hit an RBI single through the right side of the infield, helping spark a six-run Pirates’ rally. He batted again the inning, striking out. He later added  single in the seventh inning and a strikeout in the eighth. Cruz was in the lineup again for the season finale, going one-for-four and collecting his first MLB home run.

Cruz was signed out of the Dominican Republic by the Dodgers (as a 16-year-old) in July of 2015.   In 2016, he hit .294, with 23 RBI and 11 steals (no home runs) in Rookie-Level ball. Then, in 2017, he was hitting .240-8-36 at A-Level, when the Dodgers traded him to the Pirates (July 31). Cruz has played in five minor-league seasons, hitting .281-49-207, with 60 steals (404 games).

____________________________________________

Left Field, Akil Baddoo, Tigers … April 4, 2021

  • One-for-three, solo home run

Akil Baddoo made his debut playing left field and batting ninth, as the Tigers faced the Indians in Detroit.  His first plate appearance came leading off the bottom of the third inning (Tigers ahead 2-1) and he hit the first MLB pitch he ever saw (from Aaron Civale) for a home run to left field. It was one of only three Tiger hits that afternoon, as Detroit fell 9-2.

“Hitting” the Ground Running

In his first four MLB games, Akil Baddoo went five-for-eleven (.455), with a triple, two home runs and seven RBI.

Badoo finished his rookie MLB season at .259-13-55 in 124 games.  He also had seven triples and was successful on 18 of 22 steal attempts.

Baddoo was signed by the Twins (out of Salem High School in Conyers, GA) in the second round of the 2016 MLB draft. While he struggled as a 17-year old in the Gulf Coast Rookie League (hitting .178 in 38 games), he found his footing the following season, when he hit .323-4-29 in 53 Rookie-Level games. In four minor-league seasons in the Twins’ organization, he hit .249-21-93, with 47 steals (in 233 games).  Baddoo had Tommy John surgery in 2019 (and, of course, did not play in 2020 due to the Corona virus).  The Twins left him available in the Rule Five draft and he went to the Tigers, where a  strong Spring earned him a roster spot.

___________________________________________________

MLB Debut Extra … I Get Around

Luke Williams made his MLB debut for the Phillies, as a pinch hitter, on June 8, 29012 – bunting  for a single to lead off the fifth inning and eventually scoring a run.  That’s not what gets him in as an “Extra” in this post.  What gets him here is that, in his debut MLB season, he appeared (and handled fielding chances) at every position except pitcher and catcher.

_______________________________________

Center Field Jarren Duran, Red Sox … July 17, 2021

  • One- for-two, one run, one walk

Jarren Duran debuted for the Rd Sox, manning center field and batting seventh, as they took on the Yankees and Gerrit Cole in New York. On the very first MLB pitch he saw (from Cole), Duran singled  to deep center – eventually coming around to score on a single by Red Sox’ second baseman Christian Arroyo (scoring the only run in a 3-1 Red Sox loss). Duran also drew a five-pitch walk against Cole, who pitched all six innings of the rain shortened game (Cole gave up five hits, two walks and fanned 11).  So, Duran was on base in two of  three plate appearances versus the Yankee “ace.”

Duran was drafted by the Red Sox in the seventh round of the 2018 MLB Draft (out of Californian State University, Long Beach, where he hit .294-3-66, with 49 steals in 169 games over three seasons). In three minor-league seasons, he hit .307-24-109, with 86 steals in 259 games. In his first MLB season, Duran hit .215-2-10 in 33 games. His MLB season was cut short by an early September positive COVID test. After returning from the COVID list, he was sent down to Triple A.

___________________________________________

Right Field, Kyle Isbel, Royals … April 1, 2021

  • Three-for-five, one run, two RBI

After just two (uneven)  minor-league seasons (.327 average in 2018 & .233 in 2019), Kyle Isbel found himself in the starting lineup (RF, batting seventh) for the Royals (versus Rangers) on Opening Day of the 2021 season. And, he acquitted himself well. In the bottom of the fist inning, he lashed an RBI single to right. He struck out on four pitches leading off the third inning, but came back with a single to left in the fourth. Like his up and down minor-league seasons, he fanned again on four pitches in the fifth, but came back with a run-scoring single in the seventh – giving him a nice three-for-five debut in the Royals’ 14-10 win.

Isbel got in 12 April games for the Royals, hitting .265,with one extra base hit (a triple) and three RBI.  However, he had just two walks versus 15 strikeouts in 36 plate appearances. In late April, Isbel was sent down to the Royals’ alternate training site (and then to Triple-A Omaha, where his .269-15-55 and 22 steals in 105 games earned him another look from the Royals). Called back up in mid-September, he hit .286-1-4 for the Royals in 16 games between September 12 and August 3. His final  line in his first MLB season was .276-1-7 in 28 games.

Isbel was drafted by the Royals in the third round of the 2018 MLB Draft (out of the University of Nevada, where he went .322-21-110 in three seasons (170 games).

In 2016, Kyle Isbel was the Mountain West Conference Co-Freshman of the Year. In  2018, he  earned First-Team All Mountain West Conference recognition.  

____________________________________________

Designated Hitter – Yohei Pozo, Rangers … August 13, 2021

  • Two-for-three, one run, three RBI, one home run

A catcher by trade, Yohei Pozo made his debut for the Rangers as a DH, batting eighth. He had quite a day, knocking in three of the Rangers’ runs in an 8-6 win over the Athletics (in Texas).

He started with a single leading off the bottom of the second. Then, a taste of reality in the big leagues, a three-pitch strikeout in the fourth. He followed that with a three-run home run off veteran Sergio Romo in the sixth and finished with a foul pop up in the seventh.

Pozo ended up the MLB season, hitting .284-1-9 in 21 games.

Pozo was signed by the Rangers (out of Venezuela) as a 16-year-old in 2013.  By age 22 he had six minor-league seasons under his belt (.278-25-192 in 444 games).  Then, in November of 2020, he was signed as a minor-league free agent by the Padres.  The Rangers, however, got him back in the fold a month later in the Rule Five Draft.  It proved to be a good move. Assigned to Triple-A to start the season, Pozo hit .337 with 19 home runs in 66 games to earn his call up to the Rangers. Note: Pozo was sent back down to Triple A in late September.

________________________________________

Debut Post Extra – Show about a Beer?

How can you not include the MLB debut of a ballplayer names “Beer?”  There’s jersey I have to have. Seth Beer made his MLB debut as a pinch hitter for the Diamondbacks on September 10, 2021.  And he did it in style.  Beer, In the eighth inning of that contest, in his first MLB plate appearance, stroked a pinch-hit home run to right field off reliever Diego Castillo to pull the Diamondbacks to within one run of the Mariners (4-5, the eventual final score). Seth Beer played in five 2021 games for Seattle, going four-for-nine with four runs scored, one home run and three RBI.  His season was cut short by a shoulder injury (which required surgery).  When called up by the Mariners, Beer was hitting  .287-16-59 (100 games) for the Triple-A Reno Aces.  Baseball Roundtable first wrote about the player with the perfect baseball name back in 2017.  For that post, click here.

Primary Resource:  Baseball-Reference.com

100Baseball Roundtable is on the Feedspot list of the Top 100 Baseball Blogs.  To see the full list, click here.

I tweet baseball @DavidBBRT

Follow/Like Baseball Roundtable’s Facebook Page here.  More baseball commentary; blog post notifications; PRIZES.

Member: Society for American Baseball Research (SABR); Negro Leagues Baseball Museum; The Baseball Reliquary. 

 

Trivia Heroes – A Few Off the Wall Tidbits to Stump Your Baseball Friends

In this post, I’d like to share just a few oddball trivia tidbits I’ve come across over time.  It’s kind of a stream of consciousness post, going whatever direction the baseball winds (and my whims) take me.  (My mind does tend to wander in the off season.) The goal is to present a few tidbits that may offer you a chance to stump your baseball friends when you start to throw around trivia questions over an adult beverage or two (or on a Ballpark Tours bus ride).

Many Questions – One Answer

Jimmy Sheckard has become one of my trivia heroes.   Sheckard enjoyed a 17-season MLB career, during which time he became the answer to:

  • Who was the first MLB player to poke a walk-off hit in a World Series game?
  • Who was the first MLB player to lead the league in stolen bases and home runs in the same season?
  • Who was the first – and still only – player to hit inside-the-park Grand Slam home runs in consecutive games?
  • Who was one-half of the only pair of teammates to hit inside-the-park Grand Slams in the same game.?

In addition, Sheckard is the answer to:

  • Who holds the MLB single-season record for double plays started by an outfielder?
  • Who holds the MLB career mark for assists by a left fielder?

Any of these questions would make a pretty good trivial puzzler.  Wrap them altogether and you’ve got the makings of a true “trivia hero.”  I’ll provide a bit more on Sheckard – his career and his firsts – and then touch on a few additional trivia heroes.

Sheckard played in the majors from 1897 through 1913 (Brooklyn Bridegrooms/Superbas, Baltimore Orioles, Chicago Cubs, St. Louis Cardinals, Cincinnati Reds). He was known as a speedy, strong-armed outfielder.  During his career, he led the league in stolen bases twice (a high of 77 in 1899), home runs once, triples once (with eight seasons of ten or more), runs scored once (three season of 100+), walks twice, on-base percentage once and slugging percentage once. He also led in assists, putouts and double plays as a LF four times each. He is, as already noted, the career assist leader among left fielders (243)  and number-eight in assists for outfielders overall (307).

Sheckard, at times, showed the talent to be a real star on the diamond.  However, inconsistency, worked against him.   For example, he hit a career-high .354 in 1901, fell to .265 in 1902, jumped back to  .332 in 1903 and dropped to .239 in 1904.  Similarly, his nine home runs led the NL in 1903, but  he hit a total of nine home runs over the next six campaigns.  You get the idea.

So, what about those potential trivia stumpers?

Sheckard’s Chicago Cubs came into Game Four of the 1910 World Series (October 22) trailing the Athletics three games-to-none. To that point, they had been outscored 25-to-9.  Playing in Chicago, the Cubs were tied with the Athletics 3-3 going into the bottom of the tenth inning.of Game Four. With future Hall of Famer Charles “Chief” Bender on the hill for Philadelphia, Cubs’ SS  Joe Tinker led off the bottom of the inning with a pop out to shortstop, catcher Jimmy Archer followed with a double to left, a groundout by pitcher Mordecai Brown moved Archer to third and Sheckard singled to left bringing in Archer with the winning  – and notching the first-ever World Series walk-off hit. (Unfortunately, Sheckard’s heroics only staved off defeat for a day, as the Cubs lost Game Five and the series the next day.  They couldn’t blame Sheckard. In 21 plate appearances he was one base 12 times (seven walks, five hits) and scored five of the tam fifteen runs.

How about being the first to lead the league in home runs and stolen bases in the same season? In 1903, playing for Brooklyn, Sheckard led the NL in home runs with nine and steals with 67 (tied with Frank Chance).  His .332 average was seventh in the league, his 99 runs seventh, his 29 doubles seventh, 75 RBI eighth; and 75 walks fifth.

Those inside-the-park Grand Slams in consecutive days?  They came in a September 23, 1901 in a Brooklyn 25-6 win over Cincinnati and on September 24 in a  16-2 win (again Brooklyn over Cincinnati). In the two games, Sheckard was six-for-twelve, with four runs scored and ten RBI. In 1901, the 22-year-old Sheckard set career highs for average (.354), home runs (11), RBI (104). He also scored 116 runs and had a career-high 196 hits (in 133 games).  Notably, in that September 23 25-run outburst, Sheckard’s teammate Joe Kelly also hit an inside-the-park Grand Slam, marking the only time two teammates hit ITP Grand Slams in the same game. 

Let’s move on now to a few additional Baseball Roundtable Trivia Heroes.

This Yankee Shortstop Brought ‘Em Home

The New York Yankees have had a lot of great shortstops over time: Derek Jeter; Phil Rizzuto; Tom Tresh; Frank Crosetti to name just a few.  So, who is the answer to the question: “Who holds the New York Yankees Franchise record for RBI in a season by a shortstop?”

That would be Lyn Lary, who drove in 107 tallies for the 1931 Yankees – stat line .280-10-107, with 100 runs scored and 13 steals. Lary spent six of his 12 MLB season with the New Yorkers. Notably, 1931 was the only season in his career  in which he drove in more than 77 runs (one of only two in which he reached 60 RBI). In fact, his 107 RBI in 1931 represent just over 20 percent of his career total. In 12 MLB seasons (1929-40 … Yankees, Indians, Browns, Senators, Dodgers, Cardinals, Red Sox), Brown went .269-38-526. Side note: In 1931, the Yankees scored 1,067 runs  and had six player score 100 or more runs.  Want to change up the question? ”

You’ll Have to Earn Your Way On … The Old-Fashioned Way

Here’s another surprise.  How about looking at the question: “What qualifying pitcher has the lowest single-season walks per nine innings mark since the four-ball walk rule was instituted?” (Four balls became a walk in 1888, prior to that walks were – at varying times – nine, eight, six and five balls.)  The answer? Carlos Silva, who – as a Twin in 2005 – walked just nine batters (and one of those was intentional) in 188 1/3 innings – a stingy 0.430 walks per nine frames rate.

You could follow up this question with: “How many right-handed hitters did Carlos Silva walk in 2005?”  The answer is one – the Tigers’ Craig Monroe – and that was Silva’s one intentional walk.  So, not a single righty was able to “work him” for a walk all-season.  Monroe, by the way, drew only 40 walks in 623 plate appearance n 2005.   You might also be interested to know that Silva is the only pitcher – among the 25 best single-season walks per nine rates – whose landmark season came after the four-ball walk rule came into effect.

Silva pitched nine MLB seasons (2002-10 … Phillies, Twins, Mariners, Cubs) and went 70-70, 4.68. He walked 238 batters in 1,241 2/3 innings – 1.5 per nine frames – 2005 was his only season under 1,5 walks per nine.

Rookie Fever

How about this set of questions?

  • Who was the first pitcher to throw a shutout in a deciding seventh game of a World Series?
  • Who was the first rookie to start a deciding Game Seven of a World Series?
  • Who was the fist rookie to win three games in a single World Series?

The answer to all three?  Babe Adams.

Right-hander Charles “Babe” Adams came into the 1909 seasons having had brief  MLB “looks” in 1906-07 — no wins, three losses 7.96 in five games (so, his rookie status was intact.). Pitching in the minors in Louisville in 1908, he went 22-12. In 1909, he stuck with the Pirates, getting in 25 games (12 starts/seven complete games) and putting up a 12-3, 1.11 record.  Adams was far from the star of the Pirate  staff which included Howie Camnitz (25-6, 1.62), Vic Willis (22-11, 2.24) and Lefty Leifield (19-8, 2.37).  But manager Fred Clarke like liked Adam’s composure on  the mound, his strong finish to the season and how Adam’s  stuff  and style matched up against the Tigers.  So, Adams got the Game One start and the rest is history.

Adams earned complete-game wins in Games One and Five, giving up just four earned rust  Then came the deciding Game Seven.  (The World Series’ first-ever deciding seventh game. Adams again went the distance, shutting out the tigers on six hits (one walk and one whiff).  Thus, he pitched and won the first deciding Game Seven (as a rookie) and also became the first rookie to win three games in a best-of-seven World Series.

Adams pitched 19 MLB seasons (1906-07, 1909-16, 1918-26 … all but 1906 with the Pirates). He went 194-140, 2.76, twice was a 20-game winner, five times led the league in WHIP, four times allowed the fewest walks per nine innings (among qualifiers) and four time led   in strikeouts-to-walks ratio.

BONUS TRIVIA TIDBIT

Red Sox rookie Hugh Bedient has the unique distinction of being the  only rookie to start Game Eight of a best-of-seven World Series.  (Game Two of the 1912 Series ended in 6-6 tie after 11 innings due to darkness). Bedient, a 22-yer-old right-hander had gone 20-9, 2.92 in his rookie campaign.  In the World Series against the Giants, he tossed one scoreless inning of relief in Game Two’s 11-inning tie; one scoreless inning in relief in Game Three’s 2-1 Red Sox loss; and threw a complete-game in Boston’s Game Five 2-1 win.  He then started Game Eight (versus Christy Mathewson) and tossed seven scoreless  innings in a 3-2 Boston victory.  Bedient pitched just four MLB seasons, going 60-53, 3.08.

I Get By With a Little Help from My Friend

In 1961, the Orioles’ Jim Gentile tied an MLB record (since broken) for Grand Slams in a season (five). Who were the starting pitchers in the games in which Gentile launched a Grand Slam?  Two-word answer: Chuck Estrada. 

Here’s how it went.  In 1961 – with Yankee sluggers Mickey Mantle and Roger Maris dominating headlines in their chase of Babe Ruth’s record 60 home runs in a season – Jim Gentile of the Orioles quietly put up quite a season of his own. Gentile hit .302, with 46 home runs (including those five Grand Slams) and a league-topping 141 RBI.   In addition, he tied an MLB record with two Grand Slams in a game – May 9.

Orioles’ pitcher Chuck Estrada was the main beneficiary of Gentile’s 1961 offensive outburst – every one of Gentile’s record-tying five four-run blasts was hit in a game started by Estrada (who, as you would expect, picked up a victory in all four contests).  Notably, Gentile hit only one other Grand Slam in his career (June 26, 1960) and – you guessed it – the starting and winning pitcher in that contest was Chuck Estrada.

In 1961, Jim Gentile was pretty much an offensive juggernaut when paired with Chuck Estrada.  He played in 29 of Estrada’s 31 starts.  In those 29 games, he hit .356, with 15 home runs and 47 RBI. How potent is that?

For those of you who like a little more – Don’t baseball fans always want that next fact or stat? – here’s some background. Gentile was in the majors with the Dodgers (1957-58), Orioles (1960-63), A’s (1964-65), Astros (1965-66) and Indians (1966). In nine MLB campaigns, he was an All Star in three seasons (1960-61-62) and 1961 was his best year. His career stat line was .260-179-549. That’s 1961 season saw Gentile reach his all-time career highs in nearly every offensive category.  It was the only season in which he reached a .300 batting average, 100 or more RBI and 40 or more home runs (he had a total of five seasons of at least 20 homers – including the 46 in 1961 and 33 in 1962).

Estrada’s best season was his rookie year (1960) with the Orioles, when the 22-year-0ld led the AL with 18 wins (11 losses and a 3.58 ERA). He finished second in the AL Rookie of the Year balloting to his Orioles’ teammate, shortstop Ron Hansen, who hit .255, with 22 home runs and 86 RBI.  Estrada was an All Star in just one season – his rookie campaign –  in a career that saw him win 50 and lose 44, with a 4.04 ERA. He pitched for the Orioles (1960-64), Cubs (1966) and Mets (1967).

How to (Not) Play Your Way into the Record Book

Charles “Cap” Peterson’s name does not come up in a host of baseball discussions.  An outfielder, Peterson played in eight MLB seasons (1962-69 … Giants, Senators, Indians).  His career stat line was .230-19-122 and he played in 100 or more games just once. In 1967 (with the Senators), he set career highs in games (122), hits (97), home runs (8) and RBI (46).  On June 12 of that season, he tied an MLB record (for inactivity) and became part of the answer to the question: Who holds the record for the longest game played in the field without recording a single fielding chance (putout, assist, error)?  It’s a two-player answer.  Billy Bruton and Cap Peterson each managed to play a 22-inning game without recording a fielding chance – Bruton in CF for the Tigers on June 24, 1962 and Peterson in RF for the Senators on June 12, 1967.

Peterson’s “chance-less” game in the outfield came in a 22-inning win over the White Sox in Washington D.C.  Peterson was a bit more active at the plate in the contest going four-for-nine with two home runs, two runs scored and three RBI. It was the only multi-homer game of his career.   Bruton’s came in a 22-inning 9-7 loss to the Yankees (in Detroit). In his game, Bruton was two-for nine (with two walks) in 11 plate appearances, with two runs scored and a stolen base.  Bruton, by the way, played 12 MLB seasons (1953-64 … Braves, Tigers). He hit .273-94-545 in 1,610 games. He also stole 207 bases leading the NL in steals in each of his first three seasons.

 If I Could Pose an Off-the-Wall Trivia Question

If I could write a zany trivia question, it might read like this:  “What is the most times on base in a doubleheader by a shortstop who had zero fielding chances in that doubleheader?  The answer is eight.  On June 25, 1976 the Texas Rangers faced the Chicago White Sox in a doubleheader (in Texas). There was plenty of action in the field, as the Rangers won Game One 8-4 and lost Game Two 14-9.  Surprisingly, Rangers’ shortstop Toby Harrah, who played all 18-innings, did not record a single fielding chance (an MLB doubleheader first for shortstops).  I might add that it’s not like the ball was not being hit around the infield. In the two games, the Rangers’ three other  infielders (we’ll leave the catcher out of it since he get a putout on a strikeout) recorded 26 putouts, 14 assists and three errors.  In response to my question, at the plate, Harrah was six-for-eight, with two walks, two runs, eight RBI, two home runs and a stolen base. 

For those that like to know these things, the Rockies’ Trevor Story holds the record for the longest game without recording a fielding chance as a shortstop. On September 24, 2019 – as the Rockies beat the Giants 8-5 in 16 innings (in San Francisco), Story played all 16 innings without recording a putout, assist or error. 

Primary Resources:  Baseball-Reference.com; The ELIAS Book of Records, ELIAS Sports Bureau, 2021

____________________________________

100Baseball Roundtable is on the Feedspot list of the Top 100 Baseball Blogs.  To see the full list, click here.

I tweet baseball @DavidBBRT

Follow/Like Baseball Roundtable’s Facebook Page here.  More baseball commentary; blog post notifications; PRIZES.

Member: Society for American Baseball Research (SABR); Negro Leagues Baseball Museum; The Baseball Reliquary.