When Pedro Martinez is inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame this coming July, he will join a “club within a club” made up of the ten Hall of Famers who went out on top – pitching to their last major league hitter or taking their last major league at bat while playing on MLB’s biggest stage, in the World Series. Within that group, there is an even more unique set of players – just three – who retired as World Champions, all three making their last trip to the plate for a World Series winner.
BBRT will take a look at just how those players finished up their careers, but – for those in a hurry – here’s the list without the detail.
Hall of Fame players who made their final major league appearance for a World Series winner:
- Joe DiMaggio – 1951 New York Yankees
- Johnny Mize – 1953 New York Yankees
- Eddie Mathews – 1968 Detroit Tigers
Then there are the seven additional Hall of Famers who came to the plate or went to the mound for their final major league appearance in the World Series, but whose teams did not come away champions:
- Frank “Home Run” Baker – 1922 Yankees
- Bill Terry – 1936 Giants
- Travis Jackson – 1936 Giants
- Jackie Robinson – 1956 Dodgers
- Sandy Koufax – 1966 Dodgers
- Willie Mays – 1973 Mets
- Pedro Martinez – 2009 Phillies
The fact that seven of the ten players who finished their MLB playing careers in the World Series come from the Yankees, Giants or Dodgers should be no surprise; those teams represent three of the top four franchises in terms of World Series appearances:
- Yankees … 40 World Series/27 Championships
- Cardinals … 19 World Series/11 Championships
- Giants … 19 World Series/7 Championships
- Dodgers … 18 World Series/6 Championships
Now let’s look at the list of players who went out on top. First, the three whose final appearances earned them World Series Championship rings.
Joe DiMaggio (The Yankee Clipper) – Hall of Fame 1955
Last major league appearance: With the Yankees, October 10, 1951; Game Six of the World Series (versus the New York Giants)
What can you say about the Joe DiMaggio? He was indeed a “champion.” He came in a champion as a Yankee rookie in 1936 – manning center field for every game of the all-New York World Series, as the Yankees topped the Giants in six games. And, he retired as a champion – manning center field in every game as the Yankees (fittingly) again topped the Giants in six. In between those bookends, DiMaggio played in eight more World Series – with his Yankees winning seven of them. In a total of 51 World Series games, DiMaggio hit .271, with eight home runs and 30 RBI.
How well was Joltin’ Joe seeing the ball during his record hitting streak?
In 1941, Joe DiMaggio ran off a still MLB-record 56-game hitting streak. During the streak DiMaggio went 91-for-223 (.408) with 15 home runs and 55 RBI. How well was he seeing the ball? In the 56 games, DiMaggio struck out only five times.
DiMaggio was an All Star in each of his 13 MLB seasons (1936-42 & 1946-51, in a career interrupted by three years of military service). He was a three-time AL Most Valuable Player (1939, 1941, 1947) and a two-time batting champ (1939, 1940). He also led the AL in home runs (twice), triples (once), runs (one) and RBI (twice) – compiling a .325 lifetime batting average, with 361 home runs and 1,537 RBI.
DiMaggio’s final plate appearance in the major leagues produced an extra base hit – a stand-up double to tight center, with DiMaggio gliding gracefully into second base – in Game Six (final game) of the 1951 World Series. It came in the eighth inning off New York Giants’ right-hander Larry Jansen, who had led the NL with 23 victories during the season. It was the sixth hit of the Series for the Yankee Clipper, who hit .261, with one home run and five RBI for the Series.
Johnny Mize (The Big Cat) – Hall of Fame 1982
Last major league appearance: With the New York Yankees, October 5, 1953; Game Seven of the World Series (versus the Brooklyn Dodgers)
Johnny Mize hit 359 home runs in a 15-season big league career that was interrupted for three years of military service. (Mize played in the majors from 1936-42 and 1946-53.) He was a ten-time All Star who led his league at least once in most major categories: doubles (once); triples (once); home runs (four times); batting average (once); runs scored (once); RBI (three times); total bases (three times). In 1947, while with the New York Giants (Mize played for the Cardinals, Giants and Yankees in his career), Mize hit .302, leading the league in home runs (51), runs scored (137) and RBI (138).
Injuries and age slowed Mize, who was traded by the Giants to the Yankees in 1949 (at age 36). Mize proved valuable as a part-time player and pinch-hitter, helping the Yankees win five straight World Championships during his years with the team (1949-53). Mize, in fact, was the star of the 1955 Series, when he played in five of the seven games: hitting a pinch hit home run in the ninth inning of Game Three; going 2-for-3, with a home run and a double as the starting first baseman in Game Four; hitting a three-run homer in Game Five; and picking up a pair of hits and an RBI in Game Seven. Overall, Mize hit .400 for the Series, with three home runs and six RBI.
How good was Johnny Mize when it came to bat control?
In 1947, Johnny Mize rapped 51 home runs, but struck out only 42 times. He is still the only player to have a season of 50+ homers and less than 50 strikeouts. The next season, Mize proved it 1947 was no fluke, hitting 40 home runs and fanning only 37 times.
So what about Mize’s final MLB appearance? It came in the eighth inning of Game Seven of the 1953 Series. With the Yankees up 2-1, the 40-year-old Mize was called upon to pinch hit for Yankee starting first baseman Joe Collins (with two on and two out). Mize, facing Dodgers’ reliever Clem Labine, grounded out to first. Mize went 0-for-3 as a pinch hitter in the Series, but he still retired a World Champion.
Eddie Mathews – Hall of Fame 1978
Last major league appearance: With the Detroit Tigers, October 6, 1968; Game Four of the World Series (versus the Saint Louis Cardinals)
The left-handed hitting Eddie Mathews was an All Star at third base in nine of his seventeen seasons – during which he hit .271 with 512 home runs (twice leading the NL) and drove in 1,453 runs. He also led the NL in walks four times and on-base-percentage once. He hit 493 of his round trippers as a Brave – and Mathews and fellow HOFer Hank Aaron hit more home runs while teammates (863) than any other pair in MLB history. Mathews chose a Milwaukee Braves’ cap for his HOF induction. No surprise there, Mathews played for the Braves during their last season in Boston (1952), for all 13 seasons they were in Milwaukee and for their first season in Atlanta (1966) – the only player to take the field for the Braves in Boston, Milwaukee and Atlanta. Mathews last MLB at bat, however, did not come with the Braves, or even in the National League. His final trip to the plate came in a Detroit Tigers uniform – during the 1968 World Series.
How sweet was Eddie Mathews swing?
None other than the great Ty Cobb once said, “I’ve only known three or four perfect swings in my time. This lad has one of them.”
Before making it to Detroit, Mathews made a stop in Houston. Mathews was nearing the end of his career as the 1966 season closed. His output had dropped from 23 home runs and 95 RBI in 1965 to just 16 homers and 53 RBI in 1966. In the off season, the Braves acquired third baseman Clete Boyer from the Yankees and sent Mathews to the Houston Astros – where he didn’t stay long (but long enough to hit his 500th homer run – this one off another future HOFer, Juan Marichal). In mid-August of that year, the Detroit Tigers, in the middle of a pennant race and having lost starting third baseman Don Wert to injury, picked up Mathews in a trade with the Astros. Tiger manager Mayo Smith indicated they were looking at Mathews not only for his ability to fill in at third base, but also for his veteran leadership down the stretch. Mathews played in 36 games for Detroit (3B/1B/PH), hitting .231 with six homers and 19 RBI, as the Tiger finished just one game behind the Red Sox. Mathews was still with the Tigers as they won the AL title in 1968 – primarily playing first base in an injury-interrupted season. In that final campaign, he hit .212, with 3 homers and 8 RBI in 31 games.
Now for that MLB final at bat. Mathews played in only two games in the 1968 World Series. Leading off the eighth inning of Game One, he pinch hit for Don Wert and became strikeout victim number 14 in the Cardinals’ Bob Gibson’s World Series record-setting 17-strikeout performance. (The Tigers lost 4-0.) Mathews’ final major league plate appearance came at Tiger Stadium on October 6, with Gibson back on the mound for the Cardinals. Mathews, fittingly, started his final game at the position he manned for so long – third base. Gibson was again masterful, giving up just one run (five hits, two walks, ten strikeouts) in an 8-1 Cardinal victory. Mathews, however, held his own – going 1-for-2 (single and a popup) before drawing an eighth-inning walk in his last ever major league plate appearance. Detroit went on to win the Series four games to three – and Mathews ended his career a World Series Champion.
DiMaggio, Mize and Mathews, there are your three Hall of Famers who went out as World Series Champions. Now, let’s look at the seven HOFers, who came so close – finishing their careers in the World Series, just not coming away with that championship ring.
———————————————————————————————————————————–
Frank “Home Run” Baker – Hall of Fame 1955
Last major league appearance: With the New York Yankees, October 6, 1922; Game Three of the World Series (versus the New York Giant).
Frank “Home Run” Baker’s reputation as a power hitter became so ingrained that he remains better known as Home Run Baker than Frank Baker. He earned his nickname in the 1911 World Series, when he hit a game-winning, two-run home run in Game Two (as Baker’s Philadelphia Athletics beat the New York Giants 3-1) and then rapped a game-tying home run in the ninth inning of Game Three (which the Athletic won 3-2 in eleven innings). BBRT note: These home runs were especially meaningful, as only three home runs were hit in the entire Series – won by the Athletics in six games – and Baker’s 11 regular-season home runs led the American League in 1911.
Notably, Baker went on to prove himself worthy of the “Home Run” nickname – leading the AL in home runs not only in 1911, but also 1912, 1913 and 1914. He also led the league in RBI in 1912 and 1913. Regarded as one of the top power hitters of his era, Baker not only led the league in home runs four times, but hit over .300 six times, three times topped 100 RBI and twice scored more than 100 runs. Baker finished his 13-season MLB career with a .307 average, 96 home runs and 987 RBI. He played with the Philadelphia Athletics from 1908-1914 and with the New York Yankees (1916-1919 and 1921-22.) BBRT note: Baker was out of major league baseball in 1915 due to a contract dispute with Connie Mack, who then sold Baker’s contract to the Yankees. Baker also sat out the 1920 season due to a family tragedy.
Ironically, in his final two seasons, “Home Run” Baker was a teammate of the game’s newest premier power hitter, one who would change the game and the record books (and also be better known by his nickname) – Babe Ruth.
How did Frank Home Run Baker respond to pressure?
In six World Series (25 games), Baker hit .363 with three home runs and 18 RBI.
Baker got only one at bat in that 1922 Series (in which the Giants Swept the Yankees in four games), grounding out to first as a pinch hitter (for pitcher Waite Hoyt) leading off the eighth inning of Game Three.
—–
Travis Jackson (Stonewall) – Hall of Fame 1982
Bill Terry (Memphis Bill) – Hall of Fame 1954
Last major league appearance(s): For the New York Giants, October 6, 1936; Game Six (final game) of the World Series (versus the New York Yankees)
BBRT put these two Hall of Famers together because they took their last major league swings in the final game of a World Series – for the same team on the same day.
Giants’ first baseman Bill Terry’s last at bat came in the eighth inning of the final game of the 1936 World Series, against Yankee right-hander Johnny Murphy (9-3, with five saves and a 3.38 ERA in the regular season). There were two outs and the Giants were down three games to two and by a score of 6-5 in Game Six. Terry, who had a single in his first three at bats that day (driving in a run in the seventh inning) grounded out to second to end the inning. (The Yankees went on to score seven runs in the top of the ninth to put the game and the Series away.) Terry hit .240 for the Series with no home runs and five RBI.)
When did Bill Terry tell his manager about hit retirement?
Bill Terry the player retired after the 1936 World Series, but he didn’t have to tell his manager. Terry was not only the Giants’ first baseman, he was also the team’s manager. Terry served as player-manager of the Giants from 1932 to 1936, bringing home two pennants (1933, 1936) and one World Championship (1933). He continued to manage until 1941, capturing one additional NL title (1937).
Travis Jackson, who made it to the Hall of Fame primarily on his skills at shortstop, started all six games of the 1936 World Series at third base – and ended his career just a bit earlier than Terry. Jackson was lifted (by manager Terry) for a pinch hitter in the seventh. In his final major league plate appearance, Jackson popped out to second to lead off the sixth inning against Yankees’ starter Lefty Gomez. Jackson ended the game one-for-three and hit just .190 (4-for-21) for the Series.
A little bit about these two Hall of Famers, who retired as players in the same World Series contest:
Like Jackson, Terry was an accomplished fielder (he led the league’s first basemen in putouts and assists five times each), but he earned his way into the Hall of Fame primarily with his bat. The big left-hander hit .341 over a 14-year career with the Giants. He ended with 154 home runs and 1,078 RBI. He was on the first NL All Star team (the Al;l Star game was inaugurated in 1933), and was also an All Star in 1934 and 1935. Terry hit .295 in three World Series (16 games), including .429 in a losing cause in 1924.
What was Bill Terry’s greatest season?
In 1930, Terry led the NL with 254 hits and a .401 average – and also notched career-highs in home runs (23), RBI (129), and runs scored (139). Terry remains the last National Leaguer to hit over .400 for a season.
Jackson was considered one of – if not the – best defensive shortstop of his time; with wide range and a powerful arm. While Jackson never led the league in any offensive category, he still finished in the top ten in the MVP voting four times in his fifteen seasons. Much like Terry was a solid defender, known for his skill with the bat, Jackson was a solid hitter, known for his glove. Jackson hit over .300 six times (.339 in 1930), knocked 21 home runs in 1929 (10th best in the NL) and drove in 101 runs in 1934 (seventh in the NL). He finished his career (1922-36, all with the Giants) with a .291 average. 135 home runs and 929 RBI.
How good was Travis Jackson’s glove?
Travis Jackson was selected as MLB’s Most Outstanding Shortstop by The Sporting News in 1927, 1928 and 1929.
—–
Jackie Robinson – Hall of Fame 1962
Last major league appearance: With the Brooklyn Dodgers, October 10, 1956; Game Seven of the World Series (versus the New York Yankees)
Jackie Robinson, of course, is best known for breaking MLB’s color line (April 15, 1947), but he did much more than that in his ten seasons as a Brooklyn Dodger. He was a six-time All Star, the first-ever winner of the Rookie of the Year (1947), National League MVP (1949), a batting champion (.342 in 1949), twice led the league in stolen bases and helped the Dodgers to six World Series appearances and one World Championship (1955) between 1947 and 1956. Robinson came to the major leagues at age 28, after attending UCLA, playing professional football, serving in the military, spending a season with the Negro League Kansas City Monarchs (where hit .387 in 47 games) and one with the Dodgers’ Montreal Royals minor league team (where he hit .349 and stole 40 bases in 124 games). For his MLB career, Robinson hit .311, with 137 home runs, 947 runs, 734 RBI and 197 steals.
How good an athlete was Jackie Robinson?
Jackie Robinson was UCLA’s first four-letter athlete – baseball, basketball, football, track.
In his final MLB plate appearance, Robinson made the final out of the 1956 World Series. It was Game Seven and Robinson was facing the Yankees’ Johnny Kucks with the Dodgers trailing 9-0 in the bottom of the ninth, two out and Brooklyn CF Duke Snider on first base. Robinson struck out, but Yankee catcher Yogi Berra dropped the ball and had to throw Robinson out at first – ending the Series. Robinson started at third base and hit clean-up in all seven games of the Series, going 6-for-24, with five walks, five runs and two RBI.
—–
Sandy Koufax – Hall of Fame 1972
Last major league appearance: With the Los Angeles Dodgers, October 6, 1966; Game Two of the World Series (versus the Baltimore Orioles)
If anyone ever deserved to top off their career – and final MLB appearance – with a World Series Championship, it was Dodgers’ southpaw Sandy Koufax. Not only did he lead his Dodgers to the NL pennant in his final MLB season, he was also a unanimous Cy Young Award winner – leading the league in wins (27), ERA (1.73), games started (41), complete games (27), shutouts (5), innings pitched (323) and strikeouts (317). But, I’m getting ahead of myself.
Sandy Koufax spent his entire (too short) 12-year career with the Dodgers – in Brooklyn from 1955 to 1957 and in Los Angeles from 1958 to 1966. It did take this Hall of Famer awhile to find his groove. Let’s divide is career into two twelve-year segments.
- In his first six seasons, Koufax won 36 and lost 40 – in his final six, he won 129 and lost 47.
- In his first six seasons, his ERA was 4.10 – in his final six, 2.19.
- In his first six campaigns, Koufax pitched 691 2/3 innings, walking 405 and fanning 683 – in his last six seasons, he threw 1,632 2/3 innings, walking 412 and fanning 1,713.
- In his first six seasons, Koufax three five complete-game shutouts – in the final six, he tossed 35 shutouts.
- In those final six seasons, he tossed four no-hitters, one a perfect game.
In that final six-year span, Koufax led the league in wins three times, winning percentage twice, ERA five times, complete games twice, shutouts three times and strikeouts four times. Over his final six seasons, Koufax also made the All Star team every year, won three Cy Young Awards (1963, 1965, 1966) and was the NL MVP (1963). In post season play, for his career, Koufax went 4-3, with a 0.95 ERA in eight games (seven starts). He was the MVP of the 1963 and 1965 Series.
So, why the early retirement? Koufax suffered from chronic arthritis in that potent left arm – and pitched most of his final two seasons in significant pain and at significant risk. Told by doctors that continuing to pitch could end up costing him full use of the arm, Koufax chose to retire after the 1966 Series – at the age of thirty.
What did the opposition think of Sandy Koufax?
After facing Sandy Koufax in the 1963 World Series, Yogi Berra, an astute judge of pitchers, said this: “I can see how he won 25 games. What I don’t understand is how he lost five.” (Koufax finished 25-5, 1.88, with 20 complete games, 11 shutouts and 306 strikeouts in the 1963 season.)
Koufax’ final MLB appearance came on October 2, 1966 – in Game Two of the World Series against the AL Champion Baltimore Orioles. The appropriate ending to the story would be for Koufax to have finished in a blaze of (fastball) glory, earning the victory and eventually leading the Dodgers to the World Championship. It didn’t go that way. In his final game on an MLB mound, Koufax gave up four runs on six hits and two walks (before Ron Perranoski took over in the seventh). Koufax, who struck out two in his six innings, took the loss, as the Dodger fell 6-0 (on their way to being swept by the Robinson – Frank and Brooks – led Orioles). In his last inning, Koufax gave up one run on three hits (a triple by RF Frank Robinson, singles by 1B Boog Powell and 2B Dave Johnson) and an intentional walk (CF Paul Blair). The last batter MLB hitter Koufax faced was Baltimore catcher Andy Etchebarren, who hit into a third-to home-to first double play to end the inning. Koufax did deserve a better line that day. Only one of the runs was earned, as Dodgers’ CF Willie Davis made three errors (leading to three unearned runs) in the fifth inning.
—–
Willie Mays (The Say Hey Kid) – Hall of Fame 1979
Last major league appearance: With the New York Mets, October 16, 1973; Game Three of World Series (versus the Oakland A’s)
Willie Mays was an All Star in 20 of his 22 seasons, as well as Rookie of the Year (1951), twice NL MVP (1954, 1965), four times the NL leader in home runs, four times the NL leader in stolen bases, a batting champion (1954) and a 12-time Gold Glove winner. He did practically all of this damage for the New York/San Francisco Giants (for whom he hit 646 of his 660 home runs and stole 336 of his 338 bases). Mays chose a San Francisco Giants’ cap for his induction into the HOF. Still, when Mays made his final major league appearance it was not as a Giant, but rather as a New York Met.
Mays was traded to the Mets – and back, of course, to the city where he started his MLB career – early in the 1972 season. His very first game in a Mets’ uniform was, fittingly, against the Giants – May 14, 1972, at Shea Stadium. Mays homered in the fifth inning to break a 4-4 tie in a game the Mets eventually won 5-4. In his two seasons with the Mets, Mays played in 135 games, hitting .238, with 14 home runs and 44 RBI. For his career, ”The Say Hey Kid” played in 2,992 games, hitting .304, with 660 homers, 1,903 RBI and 2,062 runs scored.
Now to the 1973 post season and Mays’ final MLB at bat.
Mays got into just one game in the 1973 NLCS, picking up a single in three at bats in Game Five, as the Mets advanced to the World Series by topping the Reds three games to two. Mays started Game One of the 1973 Series (in Oakland), playing centerfield and batting third. He had a single in four at bats in what would be his only start in the Series. In Game Two, Mays came on in the ninth inning as a pinch runner for Rusty Staub (with the Mets ahead 6-4) and stayed in the game in center field. The A’s tied it up off Tug McGraw in the bottom of the inning. Mays popped out to first in the top of the eleventh (off Rollie Fingers), and then hit an RBI (go-ahead) single off Fingers in the twelfth inning. The Mets scored three more times in the inning, and won the contest 10-7. (That twelfth-inning tie-breaking hit would have been a fitting final appearance, but Mays would get home more at bat in the Series.)
How did Willie Mays fare in All Star games?
Willie Mays played in 24 All Star games, going 23-for-75 (.307) with three home runs, three triples, two doubles, 20 runs scored, nine RBI and six stolen bases, He holds the ASG career record for runs, hits, triples, stolen bases (tied with Brooks Robinson) and total bases (40). Ted Williams once said “They invented the All Star Game for Willie Mays.”
Mays’ final major league appearance came in Game Three of the 1973 World Series (October 16 at Shea Stadium). Mays was called upon to pinch hit for pitcher Tug McGraw with two-out and a runner (Bud Harrelson) on second in the bottom of the tenth inning of a 2-2 game. He ended the inning by grounding to short (with Harrelson forced at second). The Mets lost the game in 11 innings – and lost the Series in seven games.
_____
Pedro Martinez (Petey) – Hall of Fame 2015
Last major league appearance: With the Philadelphia Phillies, November 4, 2009; Game Six of the World Series (versus the Yankees)
Pedro Martinez, an eight-time All Star, three-time Cy Young Award winner, five-time ERA leader and three-time strikeout leader finished with a 219-100 record, a 2.93 career ERA and 3,154 strikeouts. The right-hander started his 18-year MLB career with the Dodgers, won his first Cy Young Award as an Expo, had his best years (and 117 of his wins) with the Red Sox (whose cap he will wear for his Hall of Fame induction), spent four seasons with the Mets and pitched his final MLB inning (during the 2009 World Series) for the Phillies – a team he spent only a half season with.
How electric was Pedro Martinez’ stuff?
Pedro Martinez, with 760 career bases on balls, is one of only four pitchers to log 3,000+ strikeouts with fewer than 1,000 walks (Curt Schilling – 3,116 Ks/ 711 BBs; Fergie Jenkins – 3,192/997; Greg Maddux – 3,371/999).
How did Pedro Martinez get to Philadelphia and the World Series mound? In 2008, Martinez career was on the wane, as he ran up a 5-6 record with 5.61 ERA (in an injury-marred year) for a Mets team that missed the playoffs by a single game. A free agent in 2009, no one expressed much interest in the 37-year-old hurler. That is, not until July 15, when the Phillies – facing a pennant race (they were the 2008 WS Champions) and a shortage of starting pitching – signed Martinez to a one-million-dollar contract.
Martinez joined the Phillies on August 12, after three minor-league appearances. He finished the season with five wins (one loss) and 3.63 ERA; and started one game in the NLCS (against the Dodgers), going seven innings and giving up just three hits and no runs. He started Games Two and Seven (losing both) in the World Series, won by the Yankees four games to two. Martinez’ last MLB appearance came as the Game Six starter. He lasted just four innings, giving up four runs on three hits, two walks and one hit batsman, while striking out five. In his final major-league inning (the fourth), he retied the bottom of the Yankee lineup in order, getting second baseman Robinson Cano to fly out to left; striking out right fielder Nick Swisher looking; and retiring center fielder Brett Gardner on a liner to second.
—–
So, they are your ten Hall of Famer who played their final games on MLH’s biggest stage – The World Series playing field.
* The photos of Mize and Mathews first appearance in Baseball Digest.













































