This week’s Tuesday Trivial Tidbit, starts with a unicorn and grew from there. The impetus was provided by Red Sox’ LF Mike Greenwell’s performance on September 2, 1996. That evening, Greenwell – hitting out of the number-eight spot in the lineup – drove in all nine runs in a Red Sox ten-inning, 9-8 win over the Mariners (in Seattle). It made him the answer to a fine trivia query “What is the most runs driven in by an MLB player in a game in which that player drove in all of his team’s tallies?”
In the game, The Mariners got out to a 5-1 lead. In the top of the fifth, Greenwell hit an 0-0 offering from Bob Wolcott for a two-run home run to right. In his next at bat, top of the seventh, Greenwell hit a 1-0 pitch from Bobby Ayala for a Grand Slam to right, giving his Red Sox a 6-5 lead. In the bottom of the frame, the Mariners scored three times to go back ahead 8-6.
Greenwell came to the plate again in the top of eighth, with two-on and two-out and turned a 2-0 pitch from Norm Charlton into a two-run double to left, tying the game at eight apiece. (Lots of “twos” there: Two-on, two-out, two-and-oh, and a two-run, two-base hit. I just tend to notice these trivia(l) coincidences.
Greenwell’s next at bat came in the top of the tenth, again with two-on and two-out, this time he delivered a single (off a 2-0 pitch from Rafael Carmona), bringing in one of the two runners (for a 9-8 Red Sox lead). The Mariners did not score in the bottom of the inning and Boston claimed a 9-8 victory. Greenwell had one other at bat in the game, flying out to center off a 2-1 pitch from Wolcott to open the third inning. After that, he came to the plate four times, with a total of eight runners on base. In those four at bats, he saw a total of nine pitches and just four strikes. He turned those four strikes into two homers, a double and a single … driving in seven of the eight baserunners (and himself twice).
The 1996 season was the 32-year-old Greenwell’s twelfth and final MLB campaign (1985-96, all with the Red Sox). He finished the year at .277-7-44 in 77 games. His career stat line was .303-130-726, with 657 runs scored and 80 stolen bases.
Well, as usual with The Roundtable, one thing led to another and I took a look at the 17 times the major leagues have seen a batter drive in ten or more runs in a game. (The usual disclaimer, Negro Leagues’ game-by game records are not fully incorporated in the MLB record books.)
Ten RBI seemed a logical break point. First, it’s double-digits and second, while 17 players have reached (or exceeded) the ten-RBI mark in a game, 28 have notched nine-RBI in an MLB contest.
Preliminary observations:
- You can make an offensive lineup of players with games of ten or more RBI. The feat has been achieved by at least one player at every position (using the positions they started the game) except pitcher. We are looking at five first basemen, three third basemen, two center fielders, two left fielders and one each at catcher, second base, shortstop, right field and DH. (No pitcher, the closest was the Braves’ Tony Cloninger, who famously had a two-Grand Slam, nine-RBI game on July 3, 1966.)
- By batting order position, games of ten or more RBI have been achieved out of the cleanup spot six times; the five-hole five times; the six-spot twice; and once each from the leadoff, number-two, number-three and number-eight spots. No one has achieved the feat from the number-seven or -nine spots.
A few Tidbits on the games in the chart above:
- The record for RBIs in a game is shared by two Cardinals … Jim Bottomley (September 16, 1924) and Mark Whiten (September 7, 1993).
Mark Whiten’s game was “extra” special, he not only tied the single-game RBI record (12), but also tied the single-game home run record, going yard four times.
- Only two MLB rookies have driven in ten runs in a game and they both played for the Red Sox. Norm Zauchin (May 27, 1955) and Fred Lynn (June 18, 1975.)
The season of his ten-RBI game, Red Lynn was the American League Rookie of the Year and Most Valuable Player.
- In his ten-RBI game (September 19, 2024), Dodger Shohei Ohtani became first, still only, 50-50 player. In this game, he hit his 49th, 50th and 51st home runs of the season and stole his 50th and 51st base. That season, he led the NL in in runs (134), HR (54) and RBI (130) and won his third MVP Award.
- The Nationals’ Mark Reynolds’ ten RBI on July 7, 2018 came during a season when he drove in only 40 runs in 86 games (the fewest RBI in any season that included a 10-RBI game.)
- The Giants’ Phil Weintraub hit just one home run in his 11-RBI game (April 30, 1944). Every other 10+ RBI performance included at least two roundtrippers, led by Mark Whiten and Scooter Gennett with four homers.
- Only two players included a triple in their 10-RBI game: Phil Weintraub (1944, 11 RBI with two doubles, one triple and one home run) and Fred Lynn (10 RBI with a single, a triple and thee home runs).
- Tony Lazzeri of the Yankees achieved an 11-RBI game out of the number-eight spot in the order (May 24, 1936), the lowest batting order slot to achieve a double-digit RBI day.
- The Red Sox’ Rudy York (July 27, 1946) achieved a double-digit RBI day with the fewest hits – just three. York’s three-for-five game included (in order): a two-run double; a Grand Slam; a walk; a second Grand Slam; a strikeout; and a GIDP.
Rudy York, Nomar Garciaparra and Tony Lazzeri each tied the MLB single-game record for Grand Slams (2) in their double-digit RBI games.
- 10 of the 17 double-digit RBI games occurred in the hitter’s home park.
- The Red Sox have had the most player double-digit RBI games with four (two home/two away). The Dodgers and Marlins are the only teams to be victims of multiple player double-digit RBI games (twice each).
- 2017 is the only season to see two double-digit RBI games (The Nationals’ Anthony Rendon on April 30 and Reds’ Scooter Gennett on June 6.)
Unicorns
The players who are the only players at their positions to have a double-digit RBI came are: Nomar Garciaparra (SS); Reggie Jackson (RF); Shohei Ohtani (DH); and Walker Cooper (C).
- Mark Reynolds is the only player to play two positions in his double-digit RBI game. He started at 3B and moved to 1B in the eighth inning. He had all ten of his RBI while manning the 3B defensive position.
Walker Cooper is not only the only catcher with a double-digit RBI game, he is also the only player to play for two teams in the season in which he recorded his double-digit RBI game. Cooper started the season with the Giants and was traded to the Reds on June 13. He had his ten RBI game in his 18th game in a Reds’ uniform. The trade apparently agreed with Cooper. That season, he hit .211-4-21 in 42 games as a Giant and .280-16-62 in 82 contests as a Red.
Primary Resouce: Stathead.com
Baseball Roundtable – Blogging Baseball Since 2012.
Baseball Roundtable is on the Feedspot list of the Top 100 Baseball Blogs. For the full list click here.
I tweet (on X) baseball @DavidBaseballRT
Follow Baseball Roundtable’s Facebook Page here. More baseball commentary and blog post notifications.
Member: Society for American Baseball Research (SABR); Negro Leagues Baseball Museum; The Baseball Reliquary.
P 1198

Side Note: The Roundtable does not carry ads. However, I am making a small exception. On the sidebar to the right of the screen (under Links), you’ll see a “widget” that looks like a baseball with “We Fit Baseball Fans To A Tee” in it. My brother and I – more for fun that profit – have launched (and are expanding) a line of baseball-themed T-Shirts, Mugs and Hats that you might find interesting (for yourself or as a gift for a fan.) Just click on the image to go to the site. (Check out the expanding Sandlot Section.)









Speak Your Mind