On this date (August 28) in 1907, a left-hander pitcher named John Stein Neuer made his debut for the American League New York Highlanders (Yankees) tossing a three-hit, complete game shutout (besting the Red Sox 1-0). Over the next five weeks, Neuer pitched in six more games – starting five. In those five starts – including his final starting assignment on October 3 – he tossed two more complete game shutouts. His line for the season, 4-2, 2.17 ERA (the league ERA was 2.54), six starts, six complete games and three shutouts. Surprisingly, this budding star never appeared in another MLB game – making him, analysts maintain, the only player to begin and end his career with a complete game shutout.
How forgettable was the meteoric career of John Neuer? Even his nickname has been lost to the ages. A search of available records will find Neuer listed as “Tex” Neuer, an unusual moniker for the Ohio-born, Pennsylvania-raised hurler. In other accounts, he is referred to as “Tacks” Neuer – more likely, since in the vernacular of the day, “Tacks” was used to refer to athletes noted for erratic behavior, a description that fit Neuer’s life and pitching styles. At other times, Neuer is also referred to as “Izzy,” “Bugs” and “Nervy Neuer.” BBRT believe “Tacks” to be most accurate, and it also appears the most commonly used to describe Neuer.
So, what happened to the career of John “Tacks” Neuer?
Neuer got his initial taste of professional baseball with Wilkes-Barre of the New York State League in 1905 at the (old for a pro-rookie) age of 28 – tossing a complete game shutout (against Syracuse) in his first start. In the minor leagues, Neuer often showed brilliance n the mound, but was also subject to bouts of wildness – a combination that kept teams interested, but also frustrated management enough to keep Neuer on the move.
In 1907, the Philadelphia Phillies signed the erratic southpaw, hoping to harness his potential. Failing to develop his control during Spring Training, Neuer was sent back to the minors, where low control and high potential saw him travel from Trenton and Providence of the Eastern League to Savannah of the South Atlantic League (after receiving his unconditional release from the Phillies).
In Savannah, something seemed to click and on August 23 (after several stellar minor league starts), his contract was purchased by New York’s AL club. This started John Neuer’s five-week MLB career – that opened and closed with a pair of three-hit shutouts.
In Spring Training 1908, Neuer decided that instead of working to refine the “stuff” that got him to the big leagues, he would work on some new (trick) pitches, including the knuckleball and the spitball. The result was that Neuer’s control, never a given, completely deserted him and he started the season back in the minors (Newark) – where, in his first game, he walked nine and hit two.
Neuer bounced around minor league and semi-pro ball for a few years, continuing to show flashes of dominance, accompanied by a frustrating lack of consistency. But after tossing three complete shutouts in six 1907 MLB starts, his career at the top of baseball’s ladder was over. Still, BBRT envies the time “Tacks, Tex, Izzy, Bugs, Nervy” Neuer spent in the big leagues. And, for today at least, John Neuer is unforgettable.