Tuesday night’s MLB All Star Game is just around the corner, which led me to reflect on some events from past All Star contests that we are not likely to see again (as well as a few other All Star Game tidbits). For example. how about a 15-inning All Star Game in which ten of the starting 16 position players played the entire contest – including the AL’s starter at catcher Bill Freehan. Or an All Star pitcher and future Hall of Famer giving up seven consecutive hits? Or maybe a hurler starting two All Star games in a single season? Let look at these stories, other oddities and some All Star stats and records.
—–WE WON’T SEE THAT AGAIN—–
A Catcher Behind the Plate for 15 Innings
In 1967, when the National League topped the junior circuit 2-1 in 15 innings (at the time, the longest All Star Game ever, later matched by the 2008 All Star contest), the following All Stars started the game and played the entire 15 innings. (Don’t think you’ll be seeing that again).
American League
Bill Freehan, Tigers, C (Yes, Freehan caught all 15-innings)
Brooks Robinson, Orioles, 3B
Tony Oliva, Twins, Twins, CF
Harmon Killebrew, Twins, 1B
Tony Conigliaro, Red Sox, RF
Carl Yastrzemski, Red Sox, LF
National League
Roberto Clemente, Pirates, RF
Hank Aaron, Braves, started in CF and finished in LF
Orlando Cepeda, Giants, 1B
Gene Alley, Pirates, SS
A Quality Start
MLB defines a quality start as one of six innings or more with three of fewer earned runs given up. Now, you can argue (correctly, I believe) that 4.50 ERA may not constitute a quality start. Given today’s All Star Game expected one, two or at the very most three-inning pitching appearances, you can confidently say we will not see another quality start in the All Star Game. Historically, there has only been one. The Yankees’ Lefty Gomez tossed an All Star Game-record six innings in 1935 – giving up just three hits and one run. Also falling into the “We’ll never see that again” category – the American League used just two pitchers in their 4-1 win, Gomez and the Indians’ Mel Harder.
A Pitcher starting two All Star Games in a Single Season
From 1959-1962, MLB featured two All Star Games each season. In 1959, Don Drysdale became the only pitcher to start two MLB All Star Games in a season. On July 7, he started at Forbes Field and held the AL hitless – with four strikeouts – for three innings. (The NL won 5-4). On August 3, he started at the Los Angeles Coliseum and again went three innings, this time giving up three runs on four hits and three walks (fanning five).
One Team Using Only Eleven Players
When the American League won the 1942 All Star Game, they used an ASG record-low 11 players. All eight position players went the distance and the team used one pinch hitter and one relief pitcher.
Here’s the lineup:
Lou Boudreau SS
Tommy Henrich RF
Ted Williams LF
Joe DiMaggio CF
Rudy York 1B
Joe Gordon 2B
Ken Keltner 3B
Birdie Tebbetts C
Spud Chandler P
Bob Johnson PH
Al Benton P
A Future Hall of Famer Giving Up Seven Straight Hits
Hall of Famer Tom Glavine started the 1992 All Star Game (he came in with a 13-3, 2.57 record). After retiring American League leadoff hitter 2B Robert Alomar on a grounder to second, he surrendered seven consecutive hits – all singles, by the way – to 3B Wade Boggs, LF Kirby Puckett, RF Joe Carter, 1B Mark McGwire, SS Cal Ripken Jr., CF Ken Griffey Jr. and C Sandy Alomar; with the AL plating four runs. In the process, Glavine set the (still) All Star Game record for hits allowed in an inning – seven. Surprisingly, he finished the frame and came out for the second inning – giving up two more hits and another run before being pulled. He set another record – most hits allowed in an All Star Game appearance at nine. I suppose it could happen, but I seriously doubt in manager would leave pitcher in for this kind of treatment any longer.
Atlee Hammaker, holds the record for the most runs surrendered in an All-star Appearance. In the 1983 All Star contest, he gave up seven earned runs on six nits and a walk in just 2/3 of an inning. The big hit was a Fred Lynn Grand Slam – still the only bases-loaded blast in an All Star Game. 1983 was Hammaker only All Star selection in a 12-season MLB career.
A Ted Williams-style Record Setting Day
Ted Williams went the distance in the 1946 All Star game – played in front of the home-town fans at Fenway and – thanks to that full-game experience – wrote his way into the ASG records books in a way we are unlikely to ever see again. Williams came into the game hitting .347, with 23 home runs, 82 runs scored and 71 RBI in 79 regular-season games. Compared to the day he was about to have that would look like a slump. Here’s how Williams’ day went.
In the first inning, batting third and facing the Cubs’ Claude Passeau, Williams drew a walk and then scored on a home run by the Yankees’ Charlie Keller.
In the bottom of the fourth, leading off against new NL hurler Kirby Higbe of the Dodgers, Williams homered to give the AL a 3-0 lead.
In the bottom of the fifth, with Higbe still in the game, Teddy Ballgame came up again – this time with one out the Senators’ Stan Spence on third and the Browns’ Vern Stephens on second. This time, Williams delivered a run-scoring single.
In the bottom of the seventh, facing the Reds’ Ewell Blackwell with none on and two out, Williams singled again.
Finally, in the bottom of the eighth – facing the Pirates’ Rip Sewell and his Ephus pitch – with Stephens and the Browns’ Jack Kramer on base, William capped off his day with a three-run homer.
The AL squad prevailed by a 12-0 score – and Williams’ final tally was: four-for-four, plus a walk, two home runs, four runs scored and five runs driven in. In the process, Williams set or tied the following All Star Game single-game records:
- Runs Scored (four – Williams still stands alone); total bases (ten – Williams stands alone);
- Runs Batted in (five – later, 1954, tied by the Indians’ Al Rosen);
- Base Hits (four – tying the Cardinals’ Ducky Medwick, 1937, and later matched by the Red Sox’ Carl Yastrzemski, 1970);
- Home Runs (two – tying Pirates’ Arky Vaughn, who did it in 1942; later tied by the Indians’ Al Rosen in 1954; Giants’ Willie McCovey in 1969; and Expos’ Gary Carter in 1981).
The youngest and oldest All Stars ever were both pitchers: Dwight Gooden (19 years-seven month-24 Days) and Satchel Paige (47 years-seven days).
Playing in 24 All Star Games – Amassing 25 All Star Squad e Selections
Willie Mays, Hank Aaron, Stan Musial all played in 24 All Star Games each A couple of things are against seeing this record ever matched. 1) It takes an unexpectedly long career to reach these numbers; 2) With 30 teams (rather than the sixteen – or even 24– of the past), it is harder to make an All Star squad. Note: There is some confusion here since, in some years (1959-62), there were two All Star Games. Aaron holds the record for seasons on an All Star Game team (21), and total All Star Game rosters made (25). Mays and Musial each played in 24 AS Games in 20 All Star seasons.
Willie Mays and Hank Aaron played on the most winning All Star teams (17); while Brooks Robinson player on the most losing squads (15 in 18 All Star appearances).
Fanning Six Future Hall of Famers
The record for strikeouts by a pitcher in an All Star Game is six – Carl Hubbell (1934); Johnny Vander Meer (1943); Larry Jansen (1950); Fergie Jenkins (1967.) Given today’s hard-throwing/free swinging brand of baseball, we may very well see that six-whiff record equaled or surpassed. But I doubt if anyone will match Carl Hubbell ‘s 1934 feat of fanning six future Hall of Famers in the same All Star Game. King Carl, on his way to a 21-win season (the second of five straight 20+ win campaigns), came into the game with a 12-5, 2.76 ERA regular-season stat line. Hubbell had struck out 58 hitters in 156 1/3 innings pitched to that point (it was, indeed, a difference game back then), but he was about to make the strikeout a much bigger part of his game.
The game was played on July 10, 1934 at New York’s Polo Grounds – with screwball-specialist Hubbell starting for the NL and Yankee Lefty Gomez starting for the AL. Facing an AL line up stacked with some of the game’s greatest hitters, Hubbell got off to a rocky start, giving up a lead-off single to Detroit’s Charlie Gehringer, followed by a walk to the Senators’ Heinie Manusch. Then the fun began, as Hubbell set down five straight future Hall of Famers – all on strikeouts – the Yankees’ Babe Ruth, Yankees’ Lou Gehrig, and Athletics’ Jimmie Foxx to close out the first. The White Sox’ Al Simmons and Senators’ Joe Cronin to open the second. Hubbell then gave up a single to Yankees’ Bill Dickey, before whiffing Lefty Gomez (also a future Hall of Famer) to end the inning. After an uneventful third inning – two fly outs, a ground out and walk – Hubbell left the game credited with three scoreless innings, two hits, two walks and six strikeouts – all six future Hall of Famers (although Gomez made it as a pitcher – not a hitter).
Oh yes, the AL won the game 9-7, and Hubbell’s feat was amplified by how those HOF whiff victims fared over the rest of the game? Against pitchers not names Hubbell, they went seven-for-sixteen, with four doubles, five runs scored and three RBI.
–—-A FEW ALL STAR GAME “FIRSTS” AND STILL “ONLYS”—–
First and still only All Star Game Steal of Home … 1934 AS game, fifth inning, two out, two on, NL trailing 8-6, NL 3B Pie Traynor (Pirates) notches the first (and still only) AS Game steal of home. (AL won game 9-7.)
First and still only All Star Game Grand Slam … 1983 All Star Game, third inning, bases loaded, two outs, AL leading 5-1, AL CF Fred Lynn hits first – and still only – AS Game Grand Slam. (AL wins 13-3)
First and still only All Star Game Inside-the-Park Home Run … 2007 All Star Game, fifth inning, one on, one out, AL CF Ichiro Suzuki hits first – and still only – AS Game inside-the-park home run.
First and still only two-triple All Star Game … 1978 ASG, Rod Carew, Twins, triples leading off the first and third innings, both off the Giants’ Vida Blue.
–—ALL STAR GAME TARGETS—–
Most Hits in an All Star Game … Four – Joe Medwick (1937); Ted Williams (1946); Carl Yastrzemski (1970)
Most Doubles in an ASG … Two – Nine players (Most recently, the Brewers’ Jonathan LeCroy in 2014. No surprise, LeCroy had a league-leading 53 doubles that season.)
Most Triples in an ASG … Two – Rod Carew (1978)
Most Home Runs in an ASG … Two – Arky Vaughn (1941); Ted Williams (1946); Al Rosen (1954); Willie McCovey (1969); Gary Carter (1981)
Most RBI in an ASG … Five – Ted Williams (1946); Al Rosen (1954)
Most Walks in an ASG … Three – Charlie Gehringer (1934); Phil Cavarretta (1944)
Most Batters Strikeouts in an ASG … Four (consecutively) – Roberto Clemente (1967)
In the 1967 All Star Game, Roberto Clemente fanned in four consecutive at bats against four different pitchers: Dean Chance (third inning); Gary Peters (sixth); Al Downing (ninth); Catfish Hunter (eleventh). He also had a single in the first (Chance) and a ground out in the fourteenth (Hunter).
Most Stolen Bases in an ASG … Two – Willie Mays (1963); Kelly Gruber (1990); Roberto Alomar (1992); Kenny Lofton (1996); Starlin Castro (2011)
Most Innings Pitched in an ASG … Six – Lefty Gomez (1935)
Most Strikeouts in an ASG … Six – Carl Hubbell (1934); Johnny Vander Meer (1943); Larry Jansen (1950: Fergie Jenkins (1967)
Most Consecutive Strikeouts in an ASG … Five – Carl Hubbell (1934); Fernando Valenzuela (1986)
Babe Ruth, appropriately, smacked the first-ever All Star Game home run.
–—CAREER ALL STAR GAME RECORDS—–
AS Game Hits … Willie Mays – 23
AS Game Doubles … Dave Winfield – 7
Gary Sheffield and Moises Alou were selected All Stars while with the most teams at five. Sheffield – Padres, Marlins, Dodgers, Braves and Yankees; Alou – Expos, Marlins, Astros, Cubs and Giants.
AS Game Triples …Willie Mays and Brooks Robinson – 3
AS Game Home Runs … Stan Musial – 6
Stan Musial hit .317 in 24 All Star games with two doubles, six home runs,10 RBI, and 11 runs scored.
AS Game RBI… Ted Williams – 12
AS Game Walks …Ted Williams – 11
Ted Williams hit .304 in 19 All Star Games, with two doubles, one triple, four home runs, 12 RBI and a.439 on-base percentage.
AS Game Stolen Bases … Willie Mays – 6
Willie Mays stole six ASG bases in seven attempts. The most ASG steals without being caught belong to Roberto Alomar and Kenny Lofton at five each.
The Most Positions Played (career) in All Star Games … Pete Rose – 5 (1B, 2B, 3B, LF RF)
AS Game Runs Scored …Willie Mays – 20
Willie Mays hit .307 in 24 All Star games, with two doubles, three triples, three home runs, nine RBI, 20 runs scored and six stolen bases.
AS Game Pitcher Wins … Lefty Gomez – 3
AS Game Total Pitching Appearances … Roger Clemens – 10
AS Games Started (pitcher) … Lefty Gomez, Robin Roberts, Don Drysdale – 5
Lefty Gomez went 3-1, 2.50 in five All Star Game starts (18 innings pitched).
AS Game Saves ... Mariano Rivera – 4
AS Games Innings Pitched … Don Drysdale – 19 1/3
AS Game Strikeouts … Don Drysdale – 19
Don Drysdale went 2-1, 1.40 in All Star games, fanning 19 batters in 19 1/3 innings (10 hits, four walks).
Most All Star Games Managed … Casey Stengel – 10 (Stengel also managed the most losses at 6)
Most All Star Winning Teams Managed … Walt Alston – Seven (in eight games)
Note: It’s hard to pick AS Game career leaders in such areas as ERA and batting average. (How many at bats or innings pitched do you use to qualify?) However, here are two BBRT nominations. If you use 20 at bats as a standard, your batting average leader is Charlie Gehringer at .500 (ten-for-twenty in six AS games, plus nine walks). If you use ten innings pitched as a qualifier, only Mel Harder can boast a 0.00 ERA (13 innings).
All Star Game Scoring Bookends
The highest scoring All Star Game ever took place in 1998 at (Where Else?) Coors Field – as the teams combined for 21 runs in a 13-8 American League win. Side note: Thirteen is the highest run total ever up by an All Star squad, accomplished by The AL in 1983, 1992 and 1998.
The lowest scoring game (combined) took place in (When else?) in 1968 (The Year of the Pitcher) – as the NL topped the AL 1-0. with the only run scoring on a double play (no RBI in the contest).
______________________________________________________
Finally, to wrap up, here’s a dozen AS Game firsts from 1933.
First Venue: Comiskey Park 1 (July 6, 1933).
First AS Game Attendance: 47,595
Final Score of First AS Game: AL 4 – NL -2
First Batter/Pitcher Match Up: NL 3B Pepper Martin (Cardinals) versus Lefty Gomez (Yankees). Gomez retired Martin on a grounder to shortstop.
First Starting Pitchers: AL, Lefty Gomez (Yankees) – NL, Bill Hallahan (Cardinals). Gomez got the first All Star win, Hallahan the first loss.
First Hit: Cardinals’ Chick Hafey (leading off second inning – off the Yankees’ Lefty Gomez). Hafey was starting in LF and batting fourth for the NL.
First Run Scored: AL starting 3B Jimmy Dykes (White Sox).
First RBI: AL starting pitcher Lefty Gomez (Yankees) – drove home Jimmy Dykes (White Sox), who had walked, with a single to center field. Take that, DH Rule.
First Double: Pie Traynor (Pirates), NL pinch hitter – top of seventh off Lefty Grove (Yankees).
First Triple: NL pitcher Lon Warneke (Cubs) – top of the sixth inning off Alvin Crowder (Senators). Take that again, DH Rule.
First Home Run: AL RF Babe Ruth (Yankees), two-run home run, bottom of the third, off Bill Hallahan (Cardinals). So, your first All Star Game double, triple and homer were hit by pitchers or former pitchers.
First Stolen Base: Bottom of first, AL 2B Charlie Gehringer (Tigers).
First Strikeout: Final out, top of second. Pitcher – Lefty Gomez (Yankees). Hitter – NL SS Dick Bartell (Phillies).
Primary Resources: Baseball-Reference.com; Baseball-Almanac.com
Baseball Roundtable is on the Feedspot list of the Top 100 Baseball Blogs. To see the full list, click here.
I tweet baseball @DavidBaseballRT
Follow/Like Baseball Roundtable’s Facebook Page here. More baseball commentary; blog post notifications; PRIZES.
Member: Society for American Baseball Research (SABR); The Baseball Reliquary; The Negro Leagues Baseball Museum.